{ "summary": { "release": "v2026-08", "projects": 11856, "registries": { "VCS": 5285, "GOLD": 4189, "CAR": 1283, "ACR": 998, "ISO": 71, "ART": 30 }, "candidates": 2092, "candidates_with_vintage_overlap": 321, "name_threshold": 0.62, "incremental": { "countries": 155, "countries_recomputed": 141, "countries_reused": 14, "pairs_reused": 0, "pairs_total": 2092, "renamed_ids": 0 }, "adjudicated": 478, "same_asset": 63, "same_asset_with_overlap": 21, "overlap_volume": 2762944, "needs_review": 89, "covered_pairs": 450, "awaiting_verdict": 0, "second_pass": 152, "adjudicator": "GitLab Duo release-steward flow (374 pairs); gemma-4-12b-it-qat-q4_0 (local, llama.cpp, temperature 0) (104 pairs)", "adjudicators": [ { "name": "GitLab Duo release-steward flow", "pairs": 374 }, { "name": "gemma-4-12b-it-qat-q4_0 (local, llama.cpp, temperature 0)", "pairs": 104 } ], "source": "Berkeley Carbon Trading Project, Voluntary Registry Offsets Database v2026-08 (CC BY 4.0)", "merkle_root": "0x9e69c44084fe760aee3a6358381c879ac75f2bcd9a7adf2b6409eec666d897ee", "leaf_encoding": "keccak256(abi.encode(string id, bytes32 keccak(a), bytes32 keccak(b), uint16[] vintages, uint256 overlapVolume, string verdict))" }, "findings": [ { "id": "GS7538~VCS1931", "a": "GS7538", "b": "VCS1931", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.8, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [ 2019, 2020, 2021 ], "overlap_volume": 1812874, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.92, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS7538", "Project Name": "Energising India using Solar Energy", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Solar - Centralized", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "AZURE POWER INDIA PRIVATE LIMITED", "Total Credits Issued": 1828464, "Total Credits Retired": 1346978, "issued_by_vintage": { "2019": 400699, "2020": 902275, "2021": 525490 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS1931", "Project Name": "Energising India using Solar Energy Projects", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Solar - Centralized", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Azure Power India Pvt ltd (PP)", "Total Credits Issued": 4842862, "Total Credits Retired": 2544669, "issued_by_vintage": { "2017": 8169, "2018": 283983, "2019": 735425, "2020": 886685, "2021": 869791, "2022": 916208, "2023": 900407, "2024": 242194 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Energising India using Solar Energy", "value_b": "Energising India using Solar Energy Projects" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "AZURE POWER INDIA PRIVATE LIMITED", "value_b": "Azure Power India Pvt ltd (PP)" }, { "field": "Country", "value_a": "India", "value_b": "India" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Solar - Centralized", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Solar - Centralized" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "value_b": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources" } ], "differences": [ "Registry: GOLD vs VCS", "Name suffix differs slightly ('Projects' added in VCS)", "Developer name formatting differs" ], "reason": "Both listings share the identical project name 'Energising India using Solar Energy', the same developer (Azure Power India), the same country, scope, and methodology, strongly indicating the same physical solar asset.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0xb5cd512a1157790b33c60be58bb6e0770da58d954d0c47fa0634eebf22533632", "proof": [ "0x6b46ae4f752607537365cfe0b57e697b9f1487d9e80d53ca63a08b5b2ee52753", "0x6beefdae6706cd7e8f53aa60694d22f52d99bb59107196dff38d1332a27d9326", "0x6d006c2326b635c83608b0bd731310605279f452dda4c9769a6cc37d220c1931", "0xdb19012e2f4e412a2a7bf28af2faa99a258cd06f3e917a93d45f7d13bda226a2", "0x331bf28c39d17059910460b7b9dfd4d3fe3c6357bb5e0adb86b05d214c4a3cef", "0xc429896de000cd047f8e2054e1b0c49ea585d5364171a5664edaf942690fb367" ] }, { "id": "GS417~VCS135", "a": "GS417", "b": "VCS135", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "China", "screen_score": 0.5203, "name_sim": 0.6733, "overlap_vintages": [ 2008, 2009, 2010 ], "overlap_volume": 184738, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS417", "Project Name": "Hebei Shangyi Manjing East Wind Farm Project", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "China", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Carbon Resource Management Ltd.", "Total Credits Issued": 311368, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2007": 11249, "2008": 114520, "2009": 124830, "2010": 60769 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS135", "Project Name": "Shangyi Manjing Windfarm Project", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Late to Verify", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "China", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Guohua (Hebei) Renewable Energy Co Ltd.", "Total Credits Issued": 184738, "Total Credits Retired": 177327, "issued_by_vintage": { "2008": 70908, "2009": 80992, "2010": 32838 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "China / None / None", "value_b": "China / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Wind", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Wind" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "value_b": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS417 vs VCS VCS135", "Name: Hebei Shangyi Manjing East Wind Farm Project vs Shangyi Manjing Windfarm Project", "Developer: Carbon Resource Management Ltd. vs Guohua (Hebei) Renewable Energy Co Ltd.", "Status: Gold Standard Certified Project vs Late to verify" ], "reason": "Both listings describe a Renewable Energy / Wind project in China using Methodology ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x6b46ae4f752607537365cfe0b57e697b9f1487d9e80d53ca63a08b5b2ee52753", "proof": [ "0xb5cd512a1157790b33c60be58bb6e0770da58d954d0c47fa0634eebf22533632", "0x6beefdae6706cd7e8f53aa60694d22f52d99bb59107196dff38d1332a27d9326", "0x6d006c2326b635c83608b0bd731310605279f452dda4c9769a6cc37d220c1931", "0xdb19012e2f4e412a2a7bf28af2faa99a258cd06f3e917a93d45f7d13bda226a2", "0x331bf28c39d17059910460b7b9dfd4d3fe3c6357bb5e0adb86b05d214c4a3cef", "0xc429896de000cd047f8e2054e1b0c49ea585d5364171a5664edaf942690fb367" ] }, { "id": "ACR0931~CAR2112", "a": "ACR0931", "b": "CAR2112", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.9429, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [ 2025 ], "overlap_volume": 147508, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.98, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0931", "Project Name": "Kielty Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Transferred ARB Project", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "WEST VIRGINIA", "Project Site Location": "192 Lick Rd, Delbarton, WV", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 266038, "Total Credits Retired": 118530, "issued_by_vintage": { "2024": 118530, "2025": 147508 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2112", "Project Name": "Kielty Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "WEST VIRGINIA", "Project Site Location": "Delbarton", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment,LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 147508, "Total Credits Retired": 147508, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 147508 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Kielty Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "value_b": "Kielty Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "value_b": "Keyrock Environment,LLC" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / WEST VIRGINIA / 192 Lick Rd, Delbarton, WV", "value_b": "United States / WEST VIRGINIA / Delbarton" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture", "value_b": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects" } ], "differences": [ "ACR0931 gives full street address '192 Lick Rd, Delbarton, WV'; CAR2112 gives only 'Delbarton'" ], "reason": "Both records share name (Kielty Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project), developer (Keyrock Environment LLC), country / state / site (United States / WEST VIRGINIA / 192 Lick Rd, Delbarton, WV), scope / type (Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture).", "reason_from_model": false, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0xd66ff3005fa991befc5892df1f8e8e82635229bd515ca52041906e490ec78b8c", "proof": [ "0xe920c3b0a565d04360663f8eb96b1261a3da08390218cd89f55f432657027067", "0x868265bac7ac59bb52658de00e92d25c66d4aa262aee8f4c6abfa13fe588fe70", "0x6d006c2326b635c83608b0bd731310605279f452dda4c9769a6cc37d220c1931", "0xdb19012e2f4e412a2a7bf28af2faa99a258cd06f3e917a93d45f7d13bda226a2", "0x331bf28c39d17059910460b7b9dfd4d3fe3c6357bb5e0adb86b05d214c4a3cef", "0xc429896de000cd047f8e2054e1b0c49ea585d5364171a5664edaf942690fb367" ] }, { "id": "GS1017~VCS1231", "a": "GS1017", "b": "VCS1231", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "Türkiye", "screen_score": 0.7367, "name_sim": 0.9303, "overlap_vintages": [ 2018, 2019, 2020, 2021, 2022, 2023 ], "overlap_volume": 145461, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.88, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS1017", "Project Name": "Mordogan Wind Farm Project Turkey", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "Türkiye", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Ayen Enerji A. S.", "Total Credits Issued": 206679, "Total Credits Retired": 32933, "issued_by_vintage": { "2018": 27182, "2019": 37441, "2020": 43411, "2021": 48421, "2022": 46180, "2023": 4044 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS1231", "Project Name": "Mordogan Wind Power Project, Turkey", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-I.D. Grid connected renewable electricity generation", "Country": "Türkiye", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "EGENDA EGE ENERJI URETIM A.S (PP)", "Total Credits Issued": 214495, "Total Credits Retired": 99386, "issued_by_vintage": { "2016": 15588, "2017": 27047, "2018": 26624, "2019": 24898, "2020": 28488, "2021": 30536, "2022": 30871, "2023": 24762, "2024": 5681 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Mordogan Wind Farm Project Turkey", "value_b": "Mordogan Wind Power Project, Turkey" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "Türkiye / None / None", "value_b": "Türkiye / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Wind", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Wind" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "value_b": "AMS-I.D. Grid connected renewable electricity generation" } ], "differences": [ "Developer: Ayen Enerji A. S. vs EGENDA EGE ENERJI URETIM A.S", "Methodology: ACM0002 vs AMS-I.D.", "Registry: GOLD vs VCS" ], "reason": "Both listings describe the Mordogan Wind Farm/Power Project in Turkey at the same location (Mordogan/Karaburun, Izmir), with the same scope and methodology, and the developer change from Ayen Enerji to EGENDA EGE ENERJI likely reflects a corporate transfer of the same physical asset.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0xe920c3b0a565d04360663f8eb96b1261a3da08390218cd89f55f432657027067", "proof": [ "0xd66ff3005fa991befc5892df1f8e8e82635229bd515ca52041906e490ec78b8c", "0x868265bac7ac59bb52658de00e92d25c66d4aa262aee8f4c6abfa13fe588fe70", "0x6d006c2326b635c83608b0bd731310605279f452dda4c9769a6cc37d220c1931", "0xdb19012e2f4e412a2a7bf28af2faa99a258cd06f3e917a93d45f7d13bda226a2", "0x331bf28c39d17059910460b7b9dfd4d3fe3c6357bb5e0adb86b05d214c4a3cef", "0xc429896de000cd047f8e2054e1b0c49ea585d5364171a5664edaf942690fb367" ] }, { "id": "GS7628~VCS2244", "a": "GS7628", "b": "VCS2244", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.7, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [ 2018, 2019 ], "overlap_volume": 91977, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.95, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS7628", "Project Name": "Wind farm at Lalpur Gujarat", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Orange Renewable Power Pvt Ltd", "Total Credits Issued": 329164, "Total Credits Retired": 1810, "issued_by_vintage": { "2018": 11184, "2019": 95799, "2020": 74542, "2021": 75218, "2022": 72421 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS2244", "Project Name": "Lalpur wind farm in Gujarat", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Late to Verify", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Tadas Wind Energy Private Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 275169, "Total Credits Retired": 275168, "issued_by_vintage": { "2016": 12082, "2017": 92898, "2018": 89396, "2019": 80793 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Wind", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Wind" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "value_b": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS7628 vs VCS VCS2244", "Name: Wind farm at Lalpur Gujarat vs Lalpur wind farm in Gujarat", "Developer: Orange Renewable Power Pvt Ltd vs Tadas Wind Energy Private Limited", "Status: Gold Standard Certified Project vs Late to verify" ], "reason": "Both listings describe a Renewable Energy / Wind project in India / None / None using Methodology ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x5e7278fee5b55e6cb61e29ba5fc96b7f7e74cc325b1653113c81b0b1e1baa200", "proof": [ "0x8372778bba1f8390056bf45ea9f206c7172ce03617eaf4e35f35098d358baef2", "0x534bebd5954135771702a69f8926acf36c649f3f27b8c5e0d0db815626c6f902", "0xd16ffd627c22b46cafb9bbf38a864b229f8ece7a3d1229668667351cfda4cb67", "0xdb19012e2f4e412a2a7bf28af2faa99a258cd06f3e917a93d45f7d13bda226a2", "0x331bf28c39d17059910460b7b9dfd4d3fe3c6357bb5e0adb86b05d214c4a3cef", "0xc429896de000cd047f8e2054e1b0c49ea585d5364171a5664edaf942690fb367" ] }, { "id": "GS10808~VCS1683", "a": "GS10808", "b": "VCS1683", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "Senegal", "screen_score": 0.5497, "name_sim": 0.7267, "overlap_vintages": [ 2021, 2022, 2023, 2024 ], "overlap_volume": 72941, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS10808", "Project Name": "Grid-connected Solar PV project in Kahone", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Solar - Centralized", "Methodology / Protocol": null, "Country": "Senegal", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "AERA Group", "Total Credits Issued": 114433, "Total Credits Retired": 32173, "issued_by_vintage": { "2021": 22456, "2022": 30140, "2023": 24727, "2024": 37110 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS1683", "Project Name": "Kahone Solar PV Plant", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Solar - Centralized", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "Senegal", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "ENERGY RESOURCES SENEGAL SA", "Total Credits Issued": 129378, "Total Credits Retired": 63961, "issued_by_vintage": { "2018": 14393, "2019": 17642, "2020": 14716, "2021": 17210, "2022": 18642, "2023": 18773, "2024": 18316, "2025": 9686 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "Senegal / None / None", "value_b": "Senegal / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Solar - Centralized", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Solar - Centralized" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS10808 vs VCS VCS1683", "Name: Grid-connected Solar PV project in Kahone vs Kahone Solar PV Plant", "Developer: AERA Group vs ENERGY RESOURCES SENEGAL SA", "Credits issued by vintage: 2021:22456, 2022:30140, 2023:24727, 2024:37110 vs 2018:14393, 2019:17642, 2020:14716, 2021:17" ], "reason": "Both listings describe a Renewable Energy / Solar - Centralized project located in Senegal.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x8372778bba1f8390056bf45ea9f206c7172ce03617eaf4e35f35098d358baef2", "proof": [ "0x5e7278fee5b55e6cb61e29ba5fc96b7f7e74cc325b1653113c81b0b1e1baa200", "0x534bebd5954135771702a69f8926acf36c649f3f27b8c5e0d0db815626c6f902", "0xd16ffd627c22b46cafb9bbf38a864b229f8ece7a3d1229668667351cfda4cb67", "0xdb19012e2f4e412a2a7bf28af2faa99a258cd06f3e917a93d45f7d13bda226a2", "0x331bf28c39d17059910460b7b9dfd4d3fe3c6357bb5e0adb86b05d214c4a3cef", "0xc429896de000cd047f8e2054e1b0c49ea585d5364171a5664edaf942690fb367" ] }, { "id": "GS513~VCS135", "a": "GS513", "b": "VCS135", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "China", "screen_score": 0.5053, "name_sim": 0.646, "overlap_vintages": [ 2008 ], "overlap_volume": 70908, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS513", "Project Name": "Hebei Shangyi Manjing West Wind Farm VER Project", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "China", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Carbon Resource Management Ltd.", "Total Credits Issued": 74562, "Total Credits Retired": 74562, "issued_by_vintage": { "2008": 74562 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS135", "Project Name": "Shangyi Manjing Windfarm Project", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Late to Verify", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "China", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Guohua (Hebei) Renewable Energy Co Ltd.", "Total Credits Issued": 184738, "Total Credits Retired": 177327, "issued_by_vintage": { "2008": 70908, "2009": 80992, "2010": 32838 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "China / None / None", "value_b": "China / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Wind", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Wind" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "value_b": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS513 vs VCS VCS135", "Name: Hebei Shangyi Manjing West Wind Farm VER Project vs Shangyi Manjing Windfarm Project", "Developer: Carbon Resource Management Ltd. vs Guohua (Hebei) Renewable Energy Co Ltd.", "Status: Gold Standard Certified Project vs Late to verify" ], "reason": "Both listings describe a Renewable Energy / Wind project in China using Methodology ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x722b7bd7cc9145844dbf2a39e0350ca404caef33e4275940901b34863df6078a", "proof": [ "0x51d473bf70f7564b506262a37606ab9bcdfabaf142663ec6fc93dcd37f9ef3e0", "0x625c3e0437f5b4fa4d0ebdeaad4f0b98266317576bf09040e19c86a3d96d4180", "0xd16ffd627c22b46cafb9bbf38a864b229f8ece7a3d1229668667351cfda4cb67", "0xdb19012e2f4e412a2a7bf28af2faa99a258cd06f3e917a93d45f7d13bda226a2", "0x331bf28c39d17059910460b7b9dfd4d3fe3c6357bb5e0adb86b05d214c4a3cef", "0xc429896de000cd047f8e2054e1b0c49ea585d5364171a5664edaf942690fb367" ] }, { "id": "GS3015~VCS900", "a": "GS3015", "b": "VCS900", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "Viet Nam", "screen_score": 0.7, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [ 2014 ], "overlap_volume": 53186, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS3015", "Project Name": "Za Hung Hydropower Project", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Hydropower", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "Viet Nam", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Vietnam Carbon Assets Ltd.", "Total Credits Issued": 819090, "Total Credits Retired": 90321, "issued_by_vintage": { "2013": 73544, "2014": 63791, "2015": 60792, "2016": 69031, "2017": 97114, "2018": 51435, "2019": 69140, "2020": 105947, "2021": 111837, "2022": 116459 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS900", "Project Name": "Za Hung Hydropower Project", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Late to Verify", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Hydropower", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "Viet Nam", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Za Hung Joint Stock Company", "Total Credits Issued": 204517, "Total Credits Retired": 204417, "issued_by_vintage": { "2010": 79885, "2011": 71446, "2014": 53186 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Za Hung Hydropower Project", "value_b": "Za Hung Hydropower Project" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "Viet Nam / None / None", "value_b": "Viet Nam / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Hydropower", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Hydropower" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "value_b": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS3015 vs VCS VCS900", "Developer: Vietnam Carbon Assets Ltd. vs Za Hung Joint Stock Company", "Status: Gold Standard Certified Project vs Late to verify", "Credits issued by vintage: 2013-2022 vs 2010-2014" ], "reason": "Both listings describe the Za Hung Hydropower Project in Viet Nam using the ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources methodology.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x51d473bf70f7564b506262a37606ab9bcdfabaf142663ec6fc93dcd37f9ef3e0", "proof": [ "0x722b7bd7cc9145844dbf2a39e0350ca404caef33e4275940901b34863df6078a", "0x625c3e0437f5b4fa4d0ebdeaad4f0b98266317576bf09040e19c86a3d96d4180", "0xd16ffd627c22b46cafb9bbf38a864b229f8ece7a3d1229668667351cfda4cb67", "0xdb19012e2f4e412a2a7bf28af2faa99a258cd06f3e917a93d45f7d13bda226a2", "0x331bf28c39d17059910460b7b9dfd4d3fe3c6357bb5e0adb86b05d214c4a3cef", "0xc429896de000cd047f8e2054e1b0c49ea585d5364171a5664edaf942690fb367" ] }, { "id": "CAR400~VCS1528", "a": "CAR400", "b": "VCS1528", "registry_a": "CAR", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.5633, "name_sim": 0.7515, "overlap_vintages": [ 2014 ], "overlap_volume": 45730, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": true, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "CAR400", "Project Name": "South Jordan Landfill Gas Destruction Project", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Waste Management", "Type": "Landfill Methane", "Methodology / Protocol": "CAR U.S. Landfill Protocol", "Country": "United States", "State": "UTAH", "Project Site Location": "South Jordan", "Project Developer": "Anew Environmental, LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 2053918, "Total Credits Retired": 1520516, "issued_by_vintage": { "2009": 38622, "2010": 92414, "2011": 138699, "2012": 136521, "2013": 140053, "2014": 153858, "2015": 74626, "2018": 199888, "2019": 195962, "2020": 198757, "2021": 211183, "2022": 212352, "2023": 218257, "2024": 42726 }, "notes": "Project reached its NMOC threshold, moved project to completed. The project developer through v10 was Element Markets Emissions, LLC" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS1528", "Project Name": "Granger South Jordan Landfill Gas Destruction Project - CER Conversion", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Units transferred from approved GHG program", "Scope": "Waste Management", "Type": "Landfill Methane", "Methodology / Protocol": "CAR U.S. Landfill Protocol", "Country": "United States", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Credits transferred from approved GHG program", "Total Credits Issued": 45730, "Total Credits Retired": 45730, "issued_by_vintage": { "2014": 45730 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Waste Management / Landfill Methane", "value_b": "Waste Management / Landfill Methane" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "CAR U.S. Landfill Protocol", "value_b": "CAR U.S. Landfill Protocol" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: CAR CAR400 vs VCS VCS1528", "Name: South Jordan Landfill Gas Destruction Project vs Granger South Jordan Landfill Gas Destruction Project - CERBER", "Developer: Anew Environmental, LLC vs Credits transferred from approved GHG program", "Status: Completed vs Units Transferred from Approved GHG Program" ], "reason": "Both listings describe a Waste Management / Landfill Methane project using the CAR U.S. Landfill Protocol.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0xcbcc783cc07a2d60a61f6ce63a5e11f16fe08dec59645a8bb81f44a2648affc9", "proof": [ "0xcdd7afc570a6e408c4e7629e9acad8f82dede28eb8cc1dfb6f309041c3030093", "0x7fa3fe0efea12a87d7f0fee994cce78ff96065ead27aa003f1b7b0bbda9efc31", "0x628e5086855d718312ee09bdd64d661f27fa87abfe9be48a8fb075c327ee1d3f", "0xb847a304bb8bb31dc33073f42648a1c824fe18ba9043693e0a8d78670b0a1065", "0x331bf28c39d17059910460b7b9dfd4d3fe3c6357bb5e0adb86b05d214c4a3cef", "0xc429896de000cd047f8e2054e1b0c49ea585d5364171a5664edaf942690fb367" ] }, { "id": "GS1588~VCS1887", "a": "GS1588", "b": "VCS1887", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "China", "screen_score": 0.7, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [ 2014, 2016 ], "overlap_volume": 36248, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": true, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS1588", "Project Name": "Nanyang Danjiang River Solar Cooker Project Phase II", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-I.C. Thermal energy production with or without electricity", "Country": "China", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Sirreon Technology & Development (Beijing) Co.Ltd", "Total Credits Issued": 672665, "Total Credits Retired": 103448, "issued_by_vintage": { "2013": 86299, "2014": 71390, "2016": 67776, "2017": 88323, "2018": 88890, "2019": 76519, "2020": 71071, "2021": 62201, "2022": 60196 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS1887", "Project Name": "Nanyang Danjiang River Solar Cooker Project Phase II", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Late to Verify", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-I.C. Thermal energy production with or without electricity", "Country": "China", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Credits transferred from approved GHG program", "Total Credits Issued": 137267, "Total Credits Retired": 137267, "issued_by_vintage": { "2014": 17171, "2015": 101019, "2016": 19077 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Nanyang Danjiang River Solar Cooker Project Phase II", "value_b": "Nanyang Danjiang River Solar Cooker Project Phase II" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "China / None / None", "value_b": "China / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Household & Community / Cookstoves", "value_b": "Household & Community / Cookstoves" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "AMS-I.C. Thermal energy production with or without electricity", "value_b": "AMS-I.C. Thermal energy production with or without electricity" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS1588 vs VCS VCS1887", "Developer: Sirreon Technology & Development (Beijing) Co.Ltd vs Credits transferred from approved GHG program", "Status: Gold Standard Certified Project vs Late to verify", "Credits issued by vintage: 2013:86299, 2014:71390, 2016:67776, 2017:88323, 2018:88890, 2019:76519, 2020:71071, 2021:6220" ], "reason": "Both listings describe the Nanyang Danjiang River Solar Cooker Project Phase II located in China under the Household & Community / Cookstoves scope using the AMS-I.C. Thermal energy production with or without electricity methodology.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0xcdd7afc570a6e408c4e7629e9acad8f82dede28eb8cc1dfb6f309041c3030093", "proof": [ "0xcbcc783cc07a2d60a61f6ce63a5e11f16fe08dec59645a8bb81f44a2648affc9", "0x7fa3fe0efea12a87d7f0fee994cce78ff96065ead27aa003f1b7b0bbda9efc31", "0x628e5086855d718312ee09bdd64d661f27fa87abfe9be48a8fb075c327ee1d3f", "0xb847a304bb8bb31dc33073f42648a1c824fe18ba9043693e0a8d78670b0a1065", "0x331bf28c39d17059910460b7b9dfd4d3fe3c6357bb5e0adb86b05d214c4a3cef", "0xc429896de000cd047f8e2054e1b0c49ea585d5364171a5664edaf942690fb367" ] }, { "id": "GS1378~VCS1886", "a": "GS1378", "b": "VCS1886", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "China", "screen_score": 0.7, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [ 2014, 2016 ], "overlap_volume": 30551, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": true, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS1378", "Project Name": "Nanyang Danjiang River Solar Cooker Project Phase I", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-I.C. Thermal energy production with or without electricity", "Country": "China", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Sirreon Technology & Development (Beijing) Co.Ltd", "Total Credits Issued": 532005, "Total Credits Retired": 51680, "issued_by_vintage": { "2013": 83174, "2014": 68224, "2016": 67116, "2017": 86216, "2018": 4800, "2019": 75807, "2020": 68747, "2021": 60715, "2022": 17206 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS1886", "Project Name": "Nanyang Danjiang River Solar Cooker Project Phase I", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Late to Verify", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-I.C. Thermal energy production with or without electricity", "Country": "China", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Credits transferred from approved GHG program", "Total Credits Issued": 129914, "Total Credits Retired": 129914, "issued_by_vintage": { "2014": 10856, "2015": 99363, "2016": 19695 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Nanyang Danjiang River Solar Cooker Project Phase I", "value_b": "Nanyang Danjiang River Solar Cooker Project Phase I" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "China / None / None", "value_b": "China / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Household & Community / Cookstoves", "value_b": "Household & Community / Cookstoves" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "AMS-I.C. Thermal energy production with or without electricity", "value_b": "AMS-I.C. Thermal energy production with or without electricity" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS1378 vs VCS VCS1886", "Developer: Sirreon Technology & Development (Beijing) Co.Ltd vs Credits transferred from approved GHG program", "Status: Gold Standard Certified Project vs Late to verify", "Credits issued by vintage: 2013:83174, 2014:68224, 2016:67116, 2017:86216, 2018:4800, 2019:75807, 2020:68747, 2021:60715" ], "reason": "Both listings describe the Nanyang Danjiang River Solar Cooker Project Phase I located in China under the Household & Community / Cookstoves scope using the AMS-I.C. Thermal energy production with or without electricity methodology.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x95d0fe3608c8962fc0df7015e39a86db4b3e25ab83c56c5b2a31c6f15536487d", "proof": [ "0xb972d2c48357d3d031cee6dd09bf0398383e565d8ce069890fbe0961521cef39", "0xe7e129b951d390f4dc3f764d54ba1fd4224e5053c631d96a86aea618da54b811", "0x628e5086855d718312ee09bdd64d661f27fa87abfe9be48a8fb075c327ee1d3f", "0xb847a304bb8bb31dc33073f42648a1c824fe18ba9043693e0a8d78670b0a1065", "0x331bf28c39d17059910460b7b9dfd4d3fe3c6357bb5e0adb86b05d214c4a3cef", "0xc429896de000cd047f8e2054e1b0c49ea585d5364171a5664edaf942690fb367" ] }, { "id": "CAR495~VCS80", "a": "CAR495", "b": "VCS80", "registry_a": "CAR", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.7, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [ 2009 ], "overlap_volume": 25180, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.95, "transfer_mentioned": true, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "CAR495", "Project Name": "Greenville County Landfill Gas Utilization Project", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Waste Management", "Type": "Landfill Methane", "Methodology / Protocol": "CAR U.S. Landfill Protocol", "Country": "United States", "State": "SOUTH CAROLINA", "Project Site Location": "Greenville County; Greer", "Project Developer": "Anew Environmental, LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 939240, "Total Credits Retired": 650523, "issued_by_vintage": { "2009": 83458, "2010": 96497, "2011": 94957, "2012": 83662, "2013": 75303, "2014": 73231, "2015": 74718, "2016": 84168, "2017": 44758, "2018": 18200, "2019": 47319, "2020": 48407, "2021": 58992, "2022": 33881, "2023": 12689, "2024": 9000 }, "notes": "Project developer in v1 was Greenville Gas Producers, LLC and The project Developer through v10 was Element Markets Emissions, LLC" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS80", "Project Name": "Greenville County Landfill Gas Utilization Project", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Late to Verify", "Scope": "Waste Management", "Type": "Landfill Methane", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0001 Flaring or use of landfill gas", "Country": "United States", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Greenville Gas Producers, LLC (PP)", "Total Credits Issued": 151922, "Total Credits Retired": 142154, "issued_by_vintage": { "2007": 24357, "2008": 102385, "2009": 25180 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Greenville County Landfill Gas Utilization Project", "value_b": "Greenville County Landfill Gas Utilization Project" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / SOUTH CAROLINA / Greenville County; Greer", "value_b": "United States / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Waste Management / Landfill Methane", "value_b": "Waste Management / Landfill Methane" }, { "field": "Developer (original)", "value_a": "Greenville Gas Producers, LLC", "value_b": "Greenville Gas Producers, LLC (PP)" } ], "differences": [ "CAR495 lists current developer as Anew Environmental, LLC; VCS80 lists Greenville Gas Producers, LLC", "CAR495 specifies state South Carolina and site Greenville County; Greer; VCS80 has no state or site", "Different methodologies: CAR U.S. Landfill Protocol vs ACM0001" ], "reason": "Both listings share the identical project name 'Greenville County Landfill Gas Utilization Project', the same location (Greenville County, South Carolina), the same project type (landfill methane), and the same original developer (Greenville Gas Producers, LLC), confirming they are the same physical asset registered in two registries.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0xb972d2c48357d3d031cee6dd09bf0398383e565d8ce069890fbe0961521cef39", "proof": [ "0x95d0fe3608c8962fc0df7015e39a86db4b3e25ab83c56c5b2a31c6f15536487d", "0xe7e129b951d390f4dc3f764d54ba1fd4224e5053c631d96a86aea618da54b811", "0x628e5086855d718312ee09bdd64d661f27fa87abfe9be48a8fb075c327ee1d3f", "0xb847a304bb8bb31dc33073f42648a1c824fe18ba9043693e0a8d78670b0a1065", "0x331bf28c39d17059910460b7b9dfd4d3fe3c6357bb5e0adb86b05d214c4a3cef", "0xc429896de000cd047f8e2054e1b0c49ea585d5364171a5664edaf942690fb367" ] }, { "id": "GS4124~VCS1886", "a": "GS4124", "b": "VCS1886", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "China", "screen_score": 0.5546, "name_sim": 0.7356, "overlap_vintages": [ 2014 ], "overlap_volume": 10856, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": true, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS4124", "Project Name": "Nanyang Danjiang River Solar Cooker Project Phase I (GS1378 CER to VER conversion)", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-I.C. Thermal energy production with or without electricity", "Country": "China", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Sirreon Technology & Development (Beijing) Co.Ltd", "Total Credits Issued": 107412, "Total Credits Retired": 107412, "issued_by_vintage": { "2012": 61700, "2014": 45712 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS1886", "Project Name": "Nanyang Danjiang River Solar Cooker Project Phase I", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Late to Verify", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-I.C. Thermal energy production with or without electricity", "Country": "China", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Credits transferred from approved GHG program", "Total Credits Issued": 129914, "Total Credits Retired": 129914, "issued_by_vintage": { "2014": 10856, "2015": 99363, "2016": 19695 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "China / None / None", "value_b": "China / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Household & Community / Cookstoves", "value_b": "Household & Community / Cookstoves" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "AMS-I.C. Thermal energy production with or without electricity", "value_b": "AMS-I.C. Thermal energy production with or without electricity" }, { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Nanyang Danjiang River Solar Cooker Project Phase I (GS1378 CER to VER转换)", "value_b": "Nanyang Danjiang River Solar Cooker Project Phase I" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS4124 vs VCS VCS1886", "Developer: Sirreon Technology & Development (Beijing) Co.Ltd vs Credits transferred from approved GHG program", "Status: Gold Standard Certified Project vs Late to verify", "Credits issued by vintage: 2012:61700, 2014:45712 vs 2014:10856, 2015:99363, 2016:19695" ], "reason": "Both listings describe the Nanyang Danjiang River Solar Cooker Project Phase I located in China under the Household & Community / Cookstoves scope using the AMS-I.C. Thermal energy production with or without electricity methodology.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x807fa5c364820a89cd231229c4cf8d525ab1f77fd81a5846604a28d29d61ff1f", "proof": [ "0x859abd8e655e1efb27642b5002095df89bbdf24316f4ecfd448f66fce1681393", "0x766dfb3b37e554e718972007f0d480379663d5e458da9c8842d45bda47cf65ab", "0xb674bce8fa80087a320b3ea4e538320338889263f1a4b9baf17a3dc77ddeff93", "0xb847a304bb8bb31dc33073f42648a1c824fe18ba9043693e0a8d78670b0a1065", "0x331bf28c39d17059910460b7b9dfd4d3fe3c6357bb5e0adb86b05d214c4a3cef", "0xc429896de000cd047f8e2054e1b0c49ea585d5364171a5664edaf942690fb367" ] }, { "id": "GS1371~VCS783", "a": "GS1371", "b": "VCS783", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "Thailand", "screen_score": 0.7, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [ 2014 ], "overlap_volume": 10000, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS1371", "Project Name": "Bangkok Kamphaeng Saen East: Landfill Gas to Electricity Project", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Waste Management", "Type": "Landfill Methane", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0001 Flaring or use of landfill gas", "Country": "Thailand", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Sindicatum Carbon Capital International Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 903086, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2012": 246904, "2013": 350762, "2014": 305420 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS783", "Project Name": "Bangkok Kamphaeng Saen East: Landfill Gas to Electricity Project", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Withdrawn", "Scope": "Waste Management", "Type": "Landfill Methane", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0001 Flaring or use of landfill gas", "Country": "Thailand", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Bangkok Green Power Co., Ltd.", "Total Credits Issued": 146381, "Total Credits Retired": 100500, "issued_by_vintage": { "2011": 136381, "2014": 10000 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Bangkok Kamphaeng Saen East: Landfill Gas to Electricity Project", "value_b": "Bangkok Kamphaeng Saen East: Landfill Gas to Electricity Project" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "Thailand / None / None", "value_b": "Thailand / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Waste Management / Landfill Methane", "value_b": "Waste Management / Landfill Methane" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ACM0001 Flaring or use of landfill gas", "value_b": "ACM0001 Flaring or use of landfill gas" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS1371 vs VCS VCS783", "Developer: Sindicatum Carbon Capital International Limited vs Bangkok Green Power Co., Ltd.", "Status: Gold Standard Certified Project vs Withdrawn", "Credits issued by vintage: 2012:246904, 2013:350762, 2014:305420 vs 2011:136381, 2014:10000" ], "reason": "Both listings describe the Bangkok Kamphaeng Saen East: Landfill Gas to Electricity Project in Thailand using the ACM0001 Flaring or use of landfill gas methodology for Waste Management / Landfill Methane.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x859abd8e655e1efb27642b5002095df89bbdf24316f4ecfd448f66fce1681393", "proof": [ "0x807fa5c364820a89cd231229c4cf8d525ab1f77fd81a5846604a28d29d61ff1f", "0x766dfb3b37e554e718972007f0d480379663d5e458da9c8842d45bda47cf65ab", "0xb674bce8fa80087a320b3ea4e538320338889263f1a4b9baf17a3dc77ddeff93", "0xb847a304bb8bb31dc33073f42648a1c824fe18ba9043693e0a8d78670b0a1065", "0x331bf28c39d17059910460b7b9dfd4d3fe3c6357bb5e0adb86b05d214c4a3cef", "0xc429896de000cd047f8e2054e1b0c49ea585d5364171a5664edaf942690fb367" ] }, { "id": "GS5064~VCS1692", "a": "GS5064", "b": "VCS1692", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.7, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [ 2017 ], "overlap_volume": 8687, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS5064", "Project Name": "15 MW Wind Power Project by RSPL Ltd (EKIESL-CDM-May-16-04)", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-I.D. Grid connected renewable electricity generation", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "EKI Energy Services Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 58004, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2017": 16938, "2018": 28775, "2019": 12291 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS1692", "Project Name": "15 MW Wind Power Project by RSPL Ltd (EKIESL-CDM-May-16-04)", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Withdrawn", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-I.D. Grid connected renewable electricity generation", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "RSPL Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 30887, "Total Credits Retired": 30887, "issued_by_vintage": { "2015": 61, "2016": 22139, "2017": 8687 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "15 MW Wind Power Project by RSPL Ltd (EKIESL-CDM-May-16-04)", "value_b": "15 MW Wind Power Project by RSPL Ltd (EKIESL-CDM-May-16-04)" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Wind", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Wind" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "AMS-I.D. Grid connected renewable electricity generation", "value_b": "AMS-I.D. Grid connected renewable electricity generation" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS5064 vs VCS VCS1692", "Developer: EKI Energy Services Limited vs RSPL Limited", "Status: Gold Standard Certified Project vs Withdrawn", "Credits issued by vintage: 2017:16938, 2018:28775, 2019:12291 vs 2015:61, 2016:22139, 2017:8687" ], "reason": "Both listings share the same project name, country, scope, and methodology.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x8138d10bfec5651be2d1eeee5a50251bbfb2412b4840ece8a1d50ca634553ef1", "proof": [ "0xb302eb7580d39de263042b18660b8a39b124f2e3c2cb885a093f9e3d47228965", "0x30c0f3c2d55998df12d8c01c8ff739b371ddce8fb1b51e0465e54b537fe1cb5f", "0xb674bce8fa80087a320b3ea4e538320338889263f1a4b9baf17a3dc77ddeff93", "0xb847a304bb8bb31dc33073f42648a1c824fe18ba9043693e0a8d78670b0a1065", "0x331bf28c39d17059910460b7b9dfd4d3fe3c6357bb5e0adb86b05d214c4a3cef", "0xc429896de000cd047f8e2054e1b0c49ea585d5364171a5664edaf942690fb367" ] }, { "id": "GS2405~VCS370", "a": "GS2405", "b": "VCS370", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.8333, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [ 2013, 2017 ], "overlap_volume": 7619, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.95, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS2405", "Project Name": "GRID CONNECTED BUNDLED WIND POWER PROJECT IN GUJARAT MANAGED BY ENERCON (INDIA) LIMITED", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Wind World (India) Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 95393, "Total Credits Retired": 95353, "issued_by_vintage": { "2013": 18585, "2014": 22867, "2015": 26776, "2016": 25125, "2017": 2040 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS370", "Project Name": "Grid connected bundled wind power project in Gujarat managed by Enercon (India) Limited", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Wind World (India) Ltd. (PP)", "Total Credits Issued": 240584, "Total Credits Retired": 239012, "issued_by_vintage": { "2008": 24194, "2009": 26003, "2010": 24109, "2011": 23940, "2012": 24978, "2013": 5579, "2017": 21085, "2018": 23270, "2019": 23973, "2020": 19654, "2021": 23799 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "GRID CONNECTED BUNDLED WIND POWER PROJECT IN GUJARAT MANAGED BY ENERCON (INDIA) LIMITED", "value_b": "Grid connected bundled wind power project in Gujarat managed by Enercon (India) Limited" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Wind World (India) Limited", "value_b": "Wind World (India) Ltd. (PP)" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Wind", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Wind" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "value_b": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources" } ], "differences": [ "GS registry: GOLD; VCS registry: VCS", "GS name is all-caps; VCS name uses title case" ], "reason": "Both listings share the identical project name, the same developer (Wind World India Ltd.), the same country (India/Gujarat), the same scope (Renewable Energy/Wind), and the same methodology (ACM0002), confirming they describe the same physical wind farm.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0xb302eb7580d39de263042b18660b8a39b124f2e3c2cb885a093f9e3d47228965", "proof": [ "0x8138d10bfec5651be2d1eeee5a50251bbfb2412b4840ece8a1d50ca634553ef1", "0x30c0f3c2d55998df12d8c01c8ff739b371ddce8fb1b51e0465e54b537fe1cb5f", "0xb674bce8fa80087a320b3ea4e538320338889263f1a4b9baf17a3dc77ddeff93", "0xb847a304bb8bb31dc33073f42648a1c824fe18ba9043693e0a8d78670b0a1065", "0x331bf28c39d17059910460b7b9dfd4d3fe3c6357bb5e0adb86b05d214c4a3cef", "0xc429896de000cd047f8e2054e1b0c49ea585d5364171a5664edaf942690fb367" ] }, { "id": "CAR498~VCS1527", "a": "CAR498", "b": "VCS1527", "registry_a": "CAR", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.5807, "name_sim": 0.7467, "overlap_vintages": [ 2014 ], "overlap_volume": 4270, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": true, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "CAR498", "Project Name": "Wolf Creek Landfill", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Waste Management", "Type": "Landfill Methane", "Methodology / Protocol": "CAR U.S. Landfill Protocol", "Country": "United States", "State": "GEORGIA", "Project Site Location": "Twiggs County, Dry Branch", "Project Developer": "Sustainable Energy Solutions LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 1165003, "Total Credits Retired": 888840, "issued_by_vintage": { "2010": 78927, "2011": 91196, "2012": 109593, "2013": 127349, "2014": 109562, "2015": 118625, "2016": 104749, "2017": 169274, "2018": 137746, "2019": 117982 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS1527", "Project Name": "Wolf Creek Landfill - CER Conversion", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Units transferred from approved GHG program", "Scope": "Waste Management", "Type": "Landfill Methane", "Methodology / Protocol": "CAR U.S. Landfill Protocol", "Country": "United States", "State": "GEORGIA", "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Credits transferred from approved GHG program", "Total Credits Issued": 4270, "Total Credits Retired": 4270, "issued_by_vintage": { "2014": 4270 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Wolf Creek Landfill", "value_b": "Wolf Creek Landfill - CER Conversion" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / GEORGIA / Twiggs County, Dry Branch", "value_b": "United States / GEORGIA / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Waste Management / Landfill Methane", "value_b": "Waste Management / Landfill Methane" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "CAR U.S. Landfill Protocol", "value_b": "CAR U.S. Landfill Protocol" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: CAR CAR498 vs VCS VCS1527", "Developer: Sustainable Energy Solutions LLC vs Credits transferred from approved GHG program", "Status: Completed vs Units Transferred from Approved GHG Program", "Credits issued by vintage: 2010-2019 list vs 2014:4270" ], "reason": "Both listings describe a Waste Management / Landfill Methane project using the CAR U.S. Landfill Protocol located in United States / GEORGIA.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0xf4387d63f837a2ab93cbaf9b83b05db89dbc714f4539b71b901ffc633adcec43", "proof": [ "0xc01f15783b874e1535b3b15bb2548c868882060835fe58f8c85b3eb5b98315d9", "0x686ab401b446b6fad97497be4cd93bfb3c9eb4f6ac082875600daaf38f696abe", "0x831987281bbc09a956cc1fdfced30dac6452faac45cf9f27306a1da61a7e06b2", "0x9fcfd75149951ed100eb7062777ed5ca7598d74b8532d4cab1ef8c5f204c183e", "0xcd712d9ff5917a7db3b93258b6c50b7f1dd345d0c490fbcbc6ca985132249977", "0xc429896de000cd047f8e2054e1b0c49ea585d5364171a5664edaf942690fb367" ] }, { "id": "GS23339~VCS3881", "a": "GS23339", "b": "VCS3881", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "Togo", "screen_score": 0.8333, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [ 2024 ], "overlap_volume": 1542, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.98, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS23339", "Project Name": "Empowering Communities Through Improved Cookstoves", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": null, "Country": "Togo", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Carbon Kind Ltd", "Total Credits Issued": 17594, "Total Credits Retired": 933, "issued_by_vintage": { "2024": 13603, "2025": 3991 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS3881", "Project Name": "EMPOWERING COMMUNITIES THROUGH IMPROVED COOKSTOVES", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Withdrawn", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "VMR0006 Energy Efficiency and Fuel Switch Measures in Thermal Applications", "Country": "Togo", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Carbon Kind Ltd (PP)", "Total Credits Issued": 3671, "Total Credits Retired": 3671, "issued_by_vintage": { "2023": 2129, "2024": 1542 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Empowering Communities Through Improved Cookstoves", "value_b": "EMPOWERING COMMUNITIES THROUGH IMPROVED COOKSTOVES" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Carbon Kind Ltd", "value_b": "Carbon Kind Ltd (PP)" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "Togo / None / None", "value_b": "Togo / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Household & Community / Cookstoves", "value_b": "Household & Community / Cookstoves" } ], "differences": [ "GS registry: GOLD; VCS registry: VCS", "GS methodology not listed; VCS methodology: VMR0006" ], "reason": "Both listings share the identical project name, the same developer (Carbon Kind Ltd), the same country (Togo), and the same scope (Household & Community / Cookstoves), confirming they describe the same cookstove distribution programme.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0xc01f15783b874e1535b3b15bb2548c868882060835fe58f8c85b3eb5b98315d9", "proof": [ "0xf4387d63f837a2ab93cbaf9b83b05db89dbc714f4539b71b901ffc633adcec43", "0x686ab401b446b6fad97497be4cd93bfb3c9eb4f6ac082875600daaf38f696abe", "0x831987281bbc09a956cc1fdfced30dac6452faac45cf9f27306a1da61a7e06b2", "0x9fcfd75149951ed100eb7062777ed5ca7598d74b8532d4cab1ef8c5f204c183e", "0xcd712d9ff5917a7db3b93258b6c50b7f1dd345d0c490fbcbc6ca985132249977", "0xc429896de000cd047f8e2054e1b0c49ea585d5364171a5664edaf942690fb367" ] }, { "id": "GS6051~VCS1879", "a": "GS6051", "b": "VCS1879", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "Sri Lanka", "screen_score": 0.6203, "name_sim": 0.855, "overlap_vintages": [ 2016 ], "overlap_volume": 1228, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": true, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS6051", "Project Name": "Adavikanda Kuruwita Division Mini Hydro Power Project", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Hydropower", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-I.D. Grid connected renewable electricity generation", "Country": "Sri Lanka", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Alternate Power Systems (Pvt) Ltd", "Total Credits Issued": 14802, "Total Credits Retired": 7401, "issued_by_vintage": { "2016": 1228, "2017": 13574 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS1879", "Project Name": "Adavikanda, Kuruwita Division Mini Hydro Power Project - CER Conversion", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Units transferred from approved GHG program", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Hydropower", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-I.D. Grid connected renewable electricity generation", "Country": "Sri Lanka", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Credits transferred from approved GHG program", "Total Credits Issued": 20000, "Total Credits Retired": 19995, "issued_by_vintage": { "2016": 20000 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "Sri Lanka / None / None", "value_b": "Sri Lanka / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Hydropower", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Hydropower" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "AMS-I.D. Grid connected renewable electricity generation", "value_b": "AMS-I.D. Grid connected renewable electricity generation" }, { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Adavikanda Kuruwita Division Mini Hydro Power Project", "value_b": "Adavikanda, Kuruwita Division Mini Hydro Power Project - CER Conversion" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS6051 vs VCS VCS1879", "Developer: Alternate Power Systems (Pvt) Ltd vs Credits transferred from approved GHG program", "Status: Gold Standard Certified Project vs Units Transferred from Approved GHG Program", "Credits issued by vintage: 2016:1228, 2017:13574 vs 2016:20000" ], "reason": "Both listings describe a Renewable Energy / Hydropower project in Sri Lanka using the AMS-I.D. Grid connected renewable electricity generation methodology.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x66afab47ccd6ce7de208814072d4dadb977c051638b11c9d975b8a8346286e8d", "proof": [ "0x576f5fe588548942033c3e31f2fe69ce644e3a1031f051c4ac2f2a022b0fb434", "0x2fffde0d8e5e5ad5b2e4b8c983d030d75aa1663f1d2fd7c4cde467b216ad8a5f", "0x831987281bbc09a956cc1fdfced30dac6452faac45cf9f27306a1da61a7e06b2", "0x9fcfd75149951ed100eb7062777ed5ca7598d74b8532d4cab1ef8c5f204c183e", "0xcd712d9ff5917a7db3b93258b6c50b7f1dd345d0c490fbcbc6ca985132249977", "0xc429896de000cd047f8e2054e1b0c49ea585d5364171a5664edaf942690fb367" ] }, { "id": "GS452~VCS1703", "a": "GS452", "b": "VCS1703", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "China", "screen_score": 0.6477, "name_sim": 0.9049, "overlap_vintages": [ 2010 ], "overlap_volume": 722, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": true, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS452", "Project Name": "*Huadian Ningxia Ningdong Yangjiayao 45MW Wind-farm Project", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "China", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Climate Impact Partners Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 182783, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2008": 52106, "2009": 82097, "2010": 48580 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS1703", "Project Name": "Huadian Ningxia Ningdong Yangjiayao 45MW Wind-farm Project - CER Conversion", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Units transferred from approved GHG program", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "China", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Credits transferred from approved GHG program", "Total Credits Issued": 722, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2010": 722 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Huadian Ningxia Ningdong Yangjiayao 45MW Wind-farm Project", "value_b": "Huadian Ningxia Ningdong Yangjiayao 45MW Wind-farm Project - CER Conversion" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "China / None / None", "value_b": "China / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Wind", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Wind" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "value_b": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS452 vs VCS VCS1703", "Developer: Climate Impact Partners Limited vs Credits transferred from approved GHG program", "Status: Gold Standard Certified Project vs Units Transferred from Approved GHG Program", "Credits issued by vintage: 2008:52106, 2009:82097, 2010:48580 vs 2010:722" ], "reason": "Both listings describe the Huadian Ningxia Ningdong Yangjiayao 45MW Wind-farm Project located in China using Methodology ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x576f5fe588548942033c3e31f2fe69ce644e3a1031f051c4ac2f2a022b0fb434", "proof": [ "0x66afab47ccd6ce7de208814072d4dadb977c051638b11c9d975b8a8346286e8d", "0x2fffde0d8e5e5ad5b2e4b8c983d030d75aa1663f1d2fd7c4cde467b216ad8a5f", "0x831987281bbc09a956cc1fdfced30dac6452faac45cf9f27306a1da61a7e06b2", "0x9fcfd75149951ed100eb7062777ed5ca7598d74b8532d4cab1ef8c5f204c183e", "0xcd712d9ff5917a7db3b93258b6c50b7f1dd345d0c490fbcbc6ca985132249977", "0xc429896de000cd047f8e2054e1b0c49ea585d5364171a5664edaf942690fb367" ] }, { "id": "ACR0234~CAR1582", "a": "ACR0234", "b": "CAR1582", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.9667, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [ 2020 ], "overlap_volume": 718, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.98, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0234", "Project Name": "Alliance Dairy", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Terminated", "Scope": "Agriculture", "Type": "Manure Methane Digester", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Capturing and Destroying Methane from Manure Management Systems", "Country": "United States", "State": "FLORIDA", "Project Site Location": "Trenton", "Project Developer": "3Degrees Group, Inc.", "Total Credits Issued": 84219, "Total Credits Retired": 84219, "issued_by_vintage": { "2015": 12382, "2016": 14787, "2017": 14054, "2018": 15864, "2019": 10809, "2020": 16323 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR1582", "Project Name": "Alliance Dairy", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Agriculture", "Type": "Manure Methane Digester", "Methodology / Protocol": "CAR U.S. Livestock Protocol", "Country": "United States", "State": "FLORIDA", "Project Site Location": "Trenton, FL", "Project Developer": "3Degrees Group, Inc", "Total Credits Issued": 33665, "Total Credits Retired": 12978, "issued_by_vintage": { "2020": 718, "2021": 21989, "2022": 10958 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Alliance Dairy", "value_b": "Alliance Dairy" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "3Degrees Group, Inc.", "value_b": "3Degrees Group, Inc" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / FLORIDA / Trenton", "value_b": "United States / FLORIDA / Trenton, FL" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Agriculture / Manure Methane Digester", "value_b": "Agriculture / Manure Methane Digester" } ], "differences": [ "Different methodologies (ARB Compliance Offset Protocol vs CAR U.S. Livestock Protocol)", "Different registries (ACR vs CAR)" ], "reason": "Identical project name (Alliance Dairy), same developer (3Degrees Group), and same site (Trenton, Florida) with the same scope confirm these are the same physical dairy digester facility registered in two registries.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0xfea492c1512d96f34a53b5e513860d926e9c09cb57c0162158e49e3ff779a834", "proof": [ "0x21cc7818e9a7e6754035edddb8f8b8710aa82a4e9a6ad3886cf9ded3e5a7a56a", "0x4097daf126eaeb5d14f7e0b7ec9d38fcd07adc740cdb1657a7524f7254f2da31", "0x29be3c66d8cd154298d8e29be3962a159461bc5c3d92042a666ed12076a777c8", "0x9fcfd75149951ed100eb7062777ed5ca7598d74b8532d4cab1ef8c5f204c183e", "0xcd712d9ff5917a7db3b93258b6c50b7f1dd345d0c490fbcbc6ca985132249977", "0xc429896de000cd047f8e2054e1b0c49ea585d5364171a5664edaf942690fb367" ] }, { "id": "ACR0258~CAR992", "a": "ACR0258", "b": "CAR992", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 1, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.99, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0258", "Project Name": "EOS ARB ODS 2013-1", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances Banks", "Country": "United States", "State": "ARKANSAS", "Project Site Location": "El Dorado", "Project Developer": "EOS Climate Inc", "Total Credits Issued": 0, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": {}, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR992", "Project Name": "EOS ARB ODS 2013-1", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances Banks", "Country": "United States", "State": "ARKANSAS", "Project Site Location": "El Dorado", "Project Developer": "EOS Climate Inc.", "Total Credits Issued": 107542, "Total Credits Retired": 107542, "issued_by_vintage": { "2013": 107542 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "EOS ARB ODS 2013-1", "value_b": "EOS ARB ODS 2013-1" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "EOS Climate Inc", "value_b": "EOS Climate Inc." }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / ARKANSAS / El Dorado", "value_b": "United States / ARKANSAS / El Dorado" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "value_b": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances Banks", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances Banks" } ], "differences": [ "Different registries (ACR vs CAR)" ], "reason": "Identical project name (EOS ARB ODS 2013-1), same developer (EOS Climate Inc), same site (El Dorado, Arkansas), same scope and methodology confirm these are the same ODS destruction project registered in two registries.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x21cc7818e9a7e6754035edddb8f8b8710aa82a4e9a6ad3886cf9ded3e5a7a56a", "proof": [ "0xfea492c1512d96f34a53b5e513860d926e9c09cb57c0162158e49e3ff779a834", "0x4097daf126eaeb5d14f7e0b7ec9d38fcd07adc740cdb1657a7524f7254f2da31", "0x29be3c66d8cd154298d8e29be3962a159461bc5c3d92042a666ed12076a777c8", "0x9fcfd75149951ed100eb7062777ed5ca7598d74b8532d4cab1ef8c5f204c183e", "0xcd712d9ff5917a7db3b93258b6c50b7f1dd345d0c490fbcbc6ca985132249977", "0xc429896de000cd047f8e2054e1b0c49ea585d5364171a5664edaf942690fb367" ] }, { "id": "ACR0542~CAR2090", "a": "ACR0542", "b": "CAR2090", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 1, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.99, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0542", "Project Name": "Orient 6 Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Transferred ARB Project", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "ILLINOIS", "Project Site Location": "Waltonville", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 85622, "Total Credits Retired": 57719, "issued_by_vintage": { "2020": 10532, "2021": 12745, "2022": 19398, "2023": 26817, "2024": 16130 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2090", "Project Name": "Orient 6 Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "ILLINOIS", "Project Site Location": "Waltonville", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment,LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 45760, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 29696, "2026": 16064 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Orient 6 Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "value_b": "Orient 6 Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "value_b": "Keyrock Environment,LLC" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / ILLINOIS / Waltonville", "value_b": "United States / ILLINOIS / Waltonville" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture", "value_b": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects" } ], "differences": [ "Different registries (ACR vs CAR)" ], "reason": "Identical project name (Orient 6 Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project), same developer (Keyrock Environment LLC), same site (Waltonville, Illinois), same scope and methodology confirm these are the same mine methane project registered in two registries.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x9ac390b96bf40c84bdda2e89ab2499c4853ea8365d56a686a9e88acd4d2fc855", "proof": [ "0x61bb9033e120d9204ca78d992d7222f9f2507ada97a15bd7ae909c95bf5159a8", "0x2f129ffdbf865f198674d970682132fdceb3800ff7163565a4573b03612b5b86", "0x29be3c66d8cd154298d8e29be3962a159461bc5c3d92042a666ed12076a777c8", "0x9fcfd75149951ed100eb7062777ed5ca7598d74b8532d4cab1ef8c5f204c183e", "0xcd712d9ff5917a7db3b93258b6c50b7f1dd345d0c490fbcbc6ca985132249977", "0xc429896de000cd047f8e2054e1b0c49ea585d5364171a5664edaf942690fb367" ] }, { "id": "ACR0546~CAR2089", "a": "ACR0546", "b": "CAR2089", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 1, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.99, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0546", "Project Name": "Middle Fork Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Transferred ARB Project", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "ILLINOIS", "Project Site Location": "Benton", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 78936, "Total Credits Retired": 40944, "issued_by_vintage": { "2020": 10640, "2021": 8285, "2022": 16484, "2023": 18875, "2024": 24652 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2089", "Project Name": "Middle Fork Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "ILLINOIS", "Project Site Location": "Benton", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment,LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 39724, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 27227, "2026": 12497 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Middle Fork Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "value_b": "Middle Fork Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "value_b": "Keyrock Environment,LLC" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / ILLINOIS / Benton", "value_b": "United States / ILLINOIS / Benton" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture", "value_b": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects" } ], "differences": [ "Different registries (ACR vs CAR)" ], "reason": "Identical project name (Middle Fork Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project), same developer (Keyrock Environment LLC), same site (Benton, Illinois), same scope and methodology confirm these are the same mine methane project registered in two registries.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x61bb9033e120d9204ca78d992d7222f9f2507ada97a15bd7ae909c95bf5159a8", "proof": [ "0x9ac390b96bf40c84bdda2e89ab2499c4853ea8365d56a686a9e88acd4d2fc855", "0x2f129ffdbf865f198674d970682132fdceb3800ff7163565a4573b03612b5b86", "0x29be3c66d8cd154298d8e29be3962a159461bc5c3d92042a666ed12076a777c8", "0x9fcfd75149951ed100eb7062777ed5ca7598d74b8532d4cab1ef8c5f204c183e", "0xcd712d9ff5917a7db3b93258b6c50b7f1dd345d0c490fbcbc6ca985132249977", "0xc429896de000cd047f8e2054e1b0c49ea585d5364171a5664edaf942690fb367" ] }, { "id": "ACR0560~CAR2054", "a": "ACR0560", "b": "CAR2054", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 1, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.99, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0560", "Project Name": "Mine 84 Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Transferred ARB Project", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "PENNSYLVANIA", "Project Site Location": "Bethlehem Township", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 410590, "Total Credits Retired": 169309, "issued_by_vintage": { "2021": 70251, "2022": 103750, "2023": 113598, "2024": 122991 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2054", "Project Name": "Mine 84 Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "PENNSYLVANIA", "Project Site Location": "Bethlehem Township", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment,LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 434951, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 183994, "2026": 250957 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Mine 84 Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "value_b": "Mine 84 Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "value_b": "Keyrock Environment,LLC" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / PENNSYLVANIA / Bethlehem Township", "value_b": "United States / PENNSYLVANIA / Bethlehem Township" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture", "value_b": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects" } ], "differences": [ "Different registries (ACR vs CAR)" ], "reason": "Identical project name (Mine 84 Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project), same developer (Keyrock Environment LLC), same site (Bethlehem Township, Pennsylvania), same scope and methodology confirm these are the same mine methane project registered in two registries.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x8d6370fe8794732696023b871bafba70733058649fa0f047f6385be0053cda07", "proof": [ "0xaa20a50b154ae9be3cd49784dd4b5a6e00a7d91e70bdba1ba80806776a784055", "0x240f13d4abdb7e9bdef30783822640d72c5b07ce7bc7c642eb39249093c9e34a", "0xbbeda2c304755af3235434959c85673728f0ac921a5518d0d43c4a5340009a08", "0x67184bba6ff771f4220595e703e837398ae7d7893fe22ac1aee4cd6ab3977c29", "0xcd712d9ff5917a7db3b93258b6c50b7f1dd345d0c490fbcbc6ca985132249977", "0xc429896de000cd047f8e2054e1b0c49ea585d5364171a5664edaf942690fb367" ] }, { "id": "ACR0578~CAR2092", "a": "ACR0578", "b": "CAR2092", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 1, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.99, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0578", "Project Name": "New Era Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Transferred ARB Project", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "ILLINOIS", "Project Site Location": "Galatia", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 461227, "Total Credits Retired": 82012, "issued_by_vintage": { "2021": 94880, "2022": 77171, "2023": 68914, "2024": 220262 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2092", "Project Name": "New Era Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "ILLINOIS", "Project Site Location": "Galatia", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment,LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 220149, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 220149 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "New Era Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "value_b": "New Era Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "value_b": "Keyrock Environment,LLC" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / ILLINOIS / Galatia", "value_b": "United States / ILLINOIS / Galatia" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture", "value_b": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects" } ], "differences": [ "Different registries (ACR vs CAR)" ], "reason": "Identical project name (New Era Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project), same developer (Keyrock Environment LLC), same site (Galatia, Illinois), same scope and methodology confirm these are the same mine methane project registered in two registries.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0xaa20a50b154ae9be3cd49784dd4b5a6e00a7d91e70bdba1ba80806776a784055", "proof": [ "0x8d6370fe8794732696023b871bafba70733058649fa0f047f6385be0053cda07", "0x240f13d4abdb7e9bdef30783822640d72c5b07ce7bc7c642eb39249093c9e34a", "0xbbeda2c304755af3235434959c85673728f0ac921a5518d0d43c4a5340009a08", "0x67184bba6ff771f4220595e703e837398ae7d7893fe22ac1aee4cd6ab3977c29", "0xcd712d9ff5917a7db3b93258b6c50b7f1dd345d0c490fbcbc6ca985132249977", "0xc429896de000cd047f8e2054e1b0c49ea585d5364171a5664edaf942690fb367" ] }, { "id": "ACR0669~CAR2113", "a": "ACR0669", "b": "CAR2113", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 1, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.99, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0669", "Project Name": "New Future Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Transferred ARB Project", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "ILLINOIS", "Project Site Location": "Galatia", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 174700, "Total Credits Retired": 112158, "issued_by_vintage": { "2022": 62598, "2023": 49560, "2024": 62542 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2113", "Project Name": "New Future Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "ILLINOIS", "Project Site Location": "Galatia", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment,LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 73186, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 73186 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "New Future Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "value_b": "New Future Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "value_b": "Keyrock Environment,LLC" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / ILLINOIS / Galatia", "value_b": "United States / ILLINOIS / Galatia" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture", "value_b": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects" } ], "differences": [ "Different registries (ACR vs CAR)" ], "reason": "Identical project name (New Future Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project), same developer (Keyrock Environment LLC), same site (Galatia, Illinois), same scope and methodology confirm these are the same mine methane project registered in two registries.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0xb47e56982866ea6003d7ca43fca60feb9827f8432e244863bfb7d65cfd2c042d", "proof": [ "0x35a36cd2dcd472ede1aebf730203ea2cd4ad0ceb27cb20d4836c93a14995b797", "0x94cff0a4f2a1e46689279187d38d18530e553145de051c536e7e95b9359cccda", "0xbbeda2c304755af3235434959c85673728f0ac921a5518d0d43c4a5340009a08", "0x67184bba6ff771f4220595e703e837398ae7d7893fe22ac1aee4cd6ab3977c29", "0xcd712d9ff5917a7db3b93258b6c50b7f1dd345d0c490fbcbc6ca985132249977", "0xc429896de000cd047f8e2054e1b0c49ea585d5364171a5664edaf942690fb367" ] }, { "id": "ACR0694~CAR2218", "a": "ACR0694", "b": "CAR2218", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 1, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.99, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0694", "Project Name": "Oaktown Fuel 1 Mine Methane Incineration Project", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Transferred ARB Project", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "INDIANA", "Project Site Location": "Oaktown", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Energy LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 50238, "Total Credits Retired": 24947, "issued_by_vintage": { "2021": 14188, "2022": 14745, "2023": 10202, "2024": 11103 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2218", "Project Name": "Oaktown Fuel 1 Mine Methane Incineration Project", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "INDIANA", "Project Site Location": "Oaktown, IN", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Energy, LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 11452, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 11452 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Oaktown Fuel 1 Mine Methane Incineration Project", "value_b": "Oaktown Fuel 1 Mine Methane Incineration Project" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Keyrock Energy LLC", "value_b": "Keyrock Energy, LLC" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / INDIANA / Oaktown", "value_b": "United States / INDIANA / Oaktown, IN" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture", "value_b": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects" } ], "differences": [ "Different registries (ACR vs CAR)" ], "reason": "Identical project name (Oaktown Fuel 1 Mine Methane Incineration Project), same developer (Keyrock Energy LLC), same site (Oaktown, Indiana), same scope and methodology confirm these are the same mine methane project registered in two registries.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x35a36cd2dcd472ede1aebf730203ea2cd4ad0ceb27cb20d4836c93a14995b797", "proof": [ "0xb47e56982866ea6003d7ca43fca60feb9827f8432e244863bfb7d65cfd2c042d", "0x94cff0a4f2a1e46689279187d38d18530e553145de051c536e7e95b9359cccda", "0xbbeda2c304755af3235434959c85673728f0ac921a5518d0d43c4a5340009a08", "0x67184bba6ff771f4220595e703e837398ae7d7893fe22ac1aee4cd6ab3977c29", "0xcd712d9ff5917a7db3b93258b6c50b7f1dd345d0c490fbcbc6ca985132249977", "0xc429896de000cd047f8e2054e1b0c49ea585d5364171a5664edaf942690fb367" ] }, { "id": "ACR0746~CAR2057", "a": "ACR0746", "b": "CAR2057", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 1, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.99, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0746", "Project Name": "Beckley Pocahontas Mine Methane Incineration Project", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Transferred ARB Project", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "WEST VIRGINIA", "Project Site Location": "Beckley", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Energy LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 119734, "Total Credits Retired": 43770, "issued_by_vintage": { "2022": 42364, "2023": 77370 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2057", "Project Name": "Beckley Pocahontas Mine Methane Incineration Project", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "WEST VIRGINIA", "Project Site Location": "Beckley", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Energy, LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 206533, "Total Credits Retired": 23041, "issued_by_vintage": { "2024": 67365, "2025": 43934, "2026": 95234 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Beckley Pocahontas Mine Methane Incineration Project", "value_b": "Beckley Pocahontas Mine Methane Incineration Project" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Keyrock Energy LLC", "value_b": "Keyrock Energy, LLC" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / WEST VIRGINIA / Beckley", "value_b": "United States / WEST VIRGINIA / Beckley" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture", "value_b": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects" } ], "differences": [ "Different registries (ACR vs CAR)" ], "reason": "Identical project name (Beckley Pocahontas Mine Methane Incineration Project), same developer (Keyrock Energy LLC), same site (Beckley, West Virginia), same scope and methodology confirm these are the same mine methane project registered in two registries.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0xf0482e1229cb8baab00d6abe997619465ec8b5efbb38fa1988b1b6b3163ffef2", "proof": [ "0x6a02fd5906c91edd50358ae293d29f09755875c2d016af8e7d03875e78bd641b", "0x34f4605783a10ac62680dc091dbfd066f2bb278371ee8acda8a959a678f053b3", "0xae7071ed373c33282ff7b6275884c92f334f58d75c564b3879e5891ce01f5f4e", "0x67184bba6ff771f4220595e703e837398ae7d7893fe22ac1aee4cd6ab3977c29", "0xcd712d9ff5917a7db3b93258b6c50b7f1dd345d0c490fbcbc6ca985132249977", "0xc429896de000cd047f8e2054e1b0c49ea585d5364171a5664edaf942690fb367" ] }, { "id": "ACR0761~CAR2091", "a": "ACR0761", "b": "CAR2091", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 1, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.99, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0761", "Project Name": "Federal 2 Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Transferred ARB Project", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "WEST VIRGINIA", "Project Site Location": "Fairview", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 768166, "Total Credits Retired": 398929, "issued_by_vintage": { "2022": 115415, "2023": 321388, "2024": 331363 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2091", "Project Name": "Federal 2 Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "WEST VIRGINIA", "Project Site Location": "Fairview", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment,LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 337485, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 337485 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Federal 2 Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "value_b": "Federal 2 Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "value_b": "Keyrock Environment,LLC" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / WEST VIRGINIA / Fairview", "value_b": "United States / WEST VIRGINIA / Fairview" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture", "value_b": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects" } ], "differences": [ "Different registries (ACR vs CAR)" ], "reason": "Identical project name (Federal 2 Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project), same developer (Keyrock Environment LLC), same site (Fairview, West Virginia), same scope and methodology confirm these are the same mine methane project registered in two registries.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x6a02fd5906c91edd50358ae293d29f09755875c2d016af8e7d03875e78bd641b", "proof": [ "0xf0482e1229cb8baab00d6abe997619465ec8b5efbb38fa1988b1b6b3163ffef2", "0x34f4605783a10ac62680dc091dbfd066f2bb278371ee8acda8a959a678f053b3", "0xae7071ed373c33282ff7b6275884c92f334f58d75c564b3879e5891ce01f5f4e", "0x67184bba6ff771f4220595e703e837398ae7d7893fe22ac1aee4cd6ab3977c29", "0xcd712d9ff5917a7db3b93258b6c50b7f1dd345d0c490fbcbc6ca985132249977", "0xc429896de000cd047f8e2054e1b0c49ea585d5364171a5664edaf942690fb367" ] }, { "id": "ACR0771~CAR2088", "a": "ACR0771", "b": "CAR2088", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 1, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.99, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0771", "Project Name": "Lowry Mine Methane Incineration Project", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Transferred ARB Project", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "PENNSYLVANIA", "Project Site Location": "Homer City", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Energy LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 162245, "Total Credits Retired": 79445, "issued_by_vintage": { "2022": 49718, "2023": 59230, "2024": 53297 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2088", "Project Name": "Lowry Mine Methane Incineration Project", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "PENNSYLVANIA", "Project Site Location": "Homer City", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Energy, LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 36220, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 36220 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Lowry Mine Methane Incineration Project", "value_b": "Lowry Mine Methane Incineration Project" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Keyrock Energy LLC", "value_b": "Keyrock Energy, LLC" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / PENNSYLVANIA / Homer City", "value_b": "United States / PENNSYLVANIA / Homer City" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture", "value_b": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects" } ], "differences": [ "Different registries (ACR vs CAR)" ], "reason": "Identical project name (Lowry Mine Methane Incineration Project), same developer (Keyrock Energy LLC), same site (Homer City, Pennsylvania), same scope and methodology confirm these are the same mine methane project registered in two registries.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x8679d5e16c27751e8703fc561cda35d38f44a899bd4f74c96850ae70fd5f7482", "proof": [ "0x475b8330b7cc9ab60202a8c90f5ac3b32f5ee05233348d5e42e354715f0e322c", "0xc1198f213be628e1151945f3ca8b512c88387c80a41eb9ff27b9806d78b3f8c4", "0xae7071ed373c33282ff7b6275884c92f334f58d75c564b3879e5891ce01f5f4e", "0x67184bba6ff771f4220595e703e837398ae7d7893fe22ac1aee4cd6ab3977c29", "0xcd712d9ff5917a7db3b93258b6c50b7f1dd345d0c490fbcbc6ca985132249977", "0xc429896de000cd047f8e2054e1b0c49ea585d5364171a5664edaf942690fb367" ] }, { "id": "ACR0807~CAR2058", "a": "ACR0807", "b": "CAR2058", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 1, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.99, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0807", "Project Name": "Shoal Creek Mine Methane Incineration Project", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Transferred ARB Project", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "ALABAMA", "Project Site Location": "Northport", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Energy LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 120166, "Total Credits Retired": 92567, "issued_by_vintage": { "2023": 65859, "2024": 54307 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2058", "Project Name": "Shoal Creek Mine Methane Incineration Project", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "ALABAMA", "Project Site Location": "Northport", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Energy, LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 191553, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 71264, "2026": 120289 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Shoal Creek Mine Methane Incineration Project", "value_b": "Shoal Creek Mine Methane Incineration Project" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Keyrock Energy LLC", "value_b": "Keyrock Energy, LLC" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / ALABAMA / Northport", "value_b": "United States / ALABAMA / Northport" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture", "value_b": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects" } ], "differences": [], "reason": "Identical project name 'Shoal Creek Mine Methane Incineration Project', same developer Keyrock Energy LLC, same state Alabama, same site Northport, and same methodology.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x475b8330b7cc9ab60202a8c90f5ac3b32f5ee05233348d5e42e354715f0e322c", "proof": [ "0x8679d5e16c27751e8703fc561cda35d38f44a899bd4f74c96850ae70fd5f7482", "0xc1198f213be628e1151945f3ca8b512c88387c80a41eb9ff27b9806d78b3f8c4", "0xae7071ed373c33282ff7b6275884c92f334f58d75c564b3879e5891ce01f5f4e", "0x67184bba6ff771f4220595e703e837398ae7d7893fe22ac1aee4cd6ab3977c29", "0xcd712d9ff5917a7db3b93258b6c50b7f1dd345d0c490fbcbc6ca985132249977", "0xc429896de000cd047f8e2054e1b0c49ea585d5364171a5664edaf942690fb367" ] }, { "id": "ACR0841~CAR2056", "a": "ACR0841", "b": "CAR2056", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 1, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.99, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0841", "Project Name": "American Eagle Mine Methane Incineration Project", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Transferred ARB Project", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "WEST VIRGINIA", "Project Site Location": "Cabin Creek", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Energy LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 293279, "Total Credits Retired": 118003, "issued_by_vintage": { "2023": 113844, "2024": 179435 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2056", "Project Name": "American Eagle Mine Methane Incineration Project", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "WEST VIRGINIA", "Project Site Location": "Cabin Creek", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Energy, LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 516161, "Total Credits Retired": 7000, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 260294, "2026": 255867 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "American Eagle Mine Methane Incineration Project", "value_b": "American Eagle Mine Methane Incineration Project" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Keyrock Energy LLC", "value_b": "Keyrock Energy, LLC" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / WEST VIRGINIA / Cabin Creek", "value_b": "United States / WEST VIRGINIA / Cabin Creek" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture", "value_b": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects" } ], "differences": [], "reason": "Identical project name 'American Eagle Mine Methane Incineration Project', same developer Keyrock Energy LLC, same state West Virginia, same site Cabin Creek, and same methodology.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0xea60c3d2cb881d1ded31d718261ad4dac84e758cd2b6e7fb66259dc097b80cf0", "proof": [ "0xfb7a07897f55f90ca119bfca78cf8966d15b3875ee07690b8fe9fc15f839bf9e", "0xbd2888273525410304f700284151e0daff4e4289846f8acf5c452f59a2d8ac26", "0xed0d147a234e06e7123adf69d2502de34dfc1a6b12c02dd9d192c57832549b17", "0x8b18b8c767945930d6ca45ba3825aac5cd06f5385b8ef79c119a2d0a9fe823dd", "0xa2620eebe01e77695710df74a55d94a1542d04974f082d2d7ffd94876141ce23", "0x3c6adb2582d2ad52455a9d3c6c8037c9fbdb02cc59381830948d83ab588d4943" ] }, { "id": "ACR0235~CAR957", "a": "ACR0235", "b": "CAR957", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.975, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.99, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0235", "Project Name": "Synergy Biogas, LLC", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Listed - Active ARB Project", "Scope": "Agriculture", "Type": "Manure Methane Digester", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Capturing and Destroying Methane from Manure Management Systems", "Country": "United States", "State": "NEW YORK", "Project Site Location": "Wyoming", "Project Developer": "3Degrees Group, Inc.", "Total Credits Issued": 48409, "Total Credits Retired": 55429, "issued_by_vintage": { "2015": 6904, "2016": 8081, "2017": 7020, "2018": 6257, "2019": 6216, "2020": 5107, "2021": 8824 }, "notes": "The project developer through v10 was Camco EAM, LLC" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR957", "Project Name": "Synergy Biogas, LLC", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Agriculture", "Type": "Manure Methane Digester", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Capturing and Destroying Methane from Manure Management Systems", "Country": "United States", "State": "NEW YORK", "Project Site Location": "Wyoming, NY", "Project Developer": "3Degrees Group, Inc", "Total Credits Issued": 35140, "Total Credits Retired": 24670, "issued_by_vintage": { "2013": 7001, "2014": 7924, "2024": 9745, "2025": 10470 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Synergy Biogas, LLC", "value_b": "Synergy Biogas, LLC" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "3Degrees Group, Inc.", "value_b": "3Degrees Group, Inc" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / NEW YORK / Wyoming", "value_b": "United States / NEW YORK / Wyoming, NY" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Agriculture / Manure Methane Digester", "value_b": "Agriculture / Manure Methane Digester" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Capturing and Destroying Methane from Manure Management Systems", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Capturing and Destroying Methane from Manure Management Systems" } ], "differences": [], "reason": "Identical project name 'Synergy Biogas, LLC', same developer 3Degrees Group Inc., same state New York, same site Wyoming, and same methodology.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0xfb7a07897f55f90ca119bfca78cf8966d15b3875ee07690b8fe9fc15f839bf9e", "proof": [ "0xea60c3d2cb881d1ded31d718261ad4dac84e758cd2b6e7fb66259dc097b80cf0", "0xbd2888273525410304f700284151e0daff4e4289846f8acf5c452f59a2d8ac26", "0xed0d147a234e06e7123adf69d2502de34dfc1a6b12c02dd9d192c57832549b17", "0x8b18b8c767945930d6ca45ba3825aac5cd06f5385b8ef79c119a2d0a9fe823dd", "0xa2620eebe01e77695710df74a55d94a1542d04974f082d2d7ffd94876141ce23", "0x3c6adb2582d2ad52455a9d3c6c8037c9fbdb02cc59381830948d83ab588d4943" ] }, { "id": "ACR0572~CAR2253", "a": "ACR0572", "b": "CAR2253", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.9667, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.99, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0572", "Project Name": "Pattiki 2 Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Transferred ARB Project", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "ILLINOIS", "Project Site Location": "Crossville", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 179064, "Total Credits Retired": 110455, "issued_by_vintage": { "2020": 13824, "2021": 32325, "2022": 35680, "2023": 30181, "2024": 67054 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2253", "Project Name": "Pattiki 2 Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "ILLINOIS", "Project Site Location": "Crossville, IL", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment,LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 93013, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 93013 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Pattiki 2 Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "value_b": "Pattiki 2 Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "value_b": "Keyrock Environment,LLC" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / ILLINOIS / Crossville", "value_b": "United States / ILLINOIS / Crossville, IL" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture", "value_b": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects" } ], "differences": [], "reason": "Identical project name 'Pattiki 2 Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project', same developer Keyrock Environment LLC, same state Illinois, same site Crossville, and same methodology.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0xc90bc394f0bc323ce0bcd9f050c4a8aa2c0a3054438e641d0408cb9f37188930", "proof": [ "0x8e737ba4379ce6398d1f6b3b23d0d12362310541ac222977536f0c47a8cb5834", "0x951de8e4a18f946db13f905e3201c2e5372cf520969e5ea6e016976ad240af00", "0xed0d147a234e06e7123adf69d2502de34dfc1a6b12c02dd9d192c57832549b17", "0x8b18b8c767945930d6ca45ba3825aac5cd06f5385b8ef79c119a2d0a9fe823dd", "0xa2620eebe01e77695710df74a55d94a1542d04974f082d2d7ffd94876141ce23", "0x3c6adb2582d2ad52455a9d3c6c8037c9fbdb02cc59381830948d83ab588d4943" ] }, { "id": "ACR0607~CAR2255", "a": "ACR0607", "b": "CAR2255", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.9667, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.99, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0607", "Project Name": "Deep Mine 26 Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Transferred ARB Project", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "VIRGINIA", "Project Site Location": "Clintwood", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 239292, "Total Credits Retired": 104998, "issued_by_vintage": { "2020": 17318, "2021": 32294, "2022": 28722, "2023": 51262, "2024": 109696 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2255", "Project Name": "Deep Mine 26 Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "VIRGINIA", "Project Site Location": "Clintwood, VA", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment,LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 78357, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 78357 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Deep Mine 26 Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "value_b": "Deep Mine 26 Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "value_b": "Keyrock Environment,LLC" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / VIRGINIA / Clintwood", "value_b": "United States / VIRGINIA / Clintwood, VA" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture", "value_b": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects" } ], "differences": [], "reason": "Identical project name 'Deep Mine 26 Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project', same developer Keyrock Environment LLC, same state Virginia, same site Clintwood, and same methodology.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x8e737ba4379ce6398d1f6b3b23d0d12362310541ac222977536f0c47a8cb5834", "proof": [ "0xc90bc394f0bc323ce0bcd9f050c4a8aa2c0a3054438e641d0408cb9f37188930", "0x951de8e4a18f946db13f905e3201c2e5372cf520969e5ea6e016976ad240af00", "0xed0d147a234e06e7123adf69d2502de34dfc1a6b12c02dd9d192c57832549b17", "0x8b18b8c767945930d6ca45ba3825aac5cd06f5385b8ef79c119a2d0a9fe823dd", "0xa2620eebe01e77695710df74a55d94a1542d04974f082d2d7ffd94876141ce23", "0x3c6adb2582d2ad52455a9d3c6c8037c9fbdb02cc59381830948d83ab588d4943" ] }, { "id": "ACR0808~CAR2217", "a": "ACR0808", "b": "CAR2217", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.9667, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.99, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0808", "Project Name": "Rend Lake Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Transferred ARB Project", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "ILLINOIS", "Project Site Location": "Bonnie", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 152429, "Total Credits Retired": 85699, "issued_by_vintage": { "2023": 112376, "2024": 40053 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2217", "Project Name": "Rend Lake Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "ILLINOIS", "Project Site Location": "Bonnie, IL", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment,LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 32223, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 32223 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Rend Lake Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "value_b": "Rend Lake Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "value_b": "Keyrock Environment,LLC" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / ILLINOIS / Bonnie", "value_b": "United States / ILLINOIS / Bonnie, IL" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture", "value_b": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects" } ], "differences": [], "reason": "Identical project name 'Rend Lake Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project', same developer Keyrock Environment LLC, same state Illinois, same site Bonnie, and same methodology.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x3cf1a30e2ccf286206f6a86d4c282a7434c47c0713e12e1a2f174679c2a51b1d", "proof": [ "0xa801d2ec673b26b1e3b2c810ad017774160c22f8ceb625d044fa770a803d7677", "0x34ce0a0dfa76db146659323d4e89c6eef56d8c4122eab7282e9411ba5117f359", "0xc14e893fc41e6bf87a35e4a932fec14e00d68468b14b0ef262b1dc37a563ad31", "0x8b18b8c767945930d6ca45ba3825aac5cd06f5385b8ef79c119a2d0a9fe823dd", "0xa2620eebe01e77695710df74a55d94a1542d04974f082d2d7ffd94876141ce23", "0x3c6adb2582d2ad52455a9d3c6c8037c9fbdb02cc59381830948d83ab588d4943" ] }, { "id": "ACR0674~CAR2135", "a": "ACR0674", "b": "CAR2135", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.96, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.98, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0674", "Project Name": "Affinity Mine Methane Incineration Project", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Transferred ARB Project", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "WEST VIRGINIA", "Project Site Location": "Crab Orchard", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Energy LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 152243, "Total Credits Retired": 128592, "issued_by_vintage": { "2021": 55569, "2022": 41618, "2023": 32075, "2024": 22981 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2135", "Project Name": "Affinity Mine Methane Incineration Project", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "WEST VIRGINIA", "Project Site Location": "Crab Orchad", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Energy, LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 32794, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 32794 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Affinity Mine Methane Incineration Project", "value_b": "Affinity Mine Methane Incineration Project" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Keyrock Energy LLC", "value_b": "Keyrock Energy, LLC" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / WEST VIRGINIA / Crab Orchard", "value_b": "United States / WEST VIRGINIA / Crab Orchad" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture", "value_b": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects" } ], "differences": [ "Site name has minor typo in CAR2135: 'Crab Orchad' vs 'Crab Orchard'" ], "reason": "Identical project name 'Affinity Mine Methane Incineration Project', same developer Keyrock Energy LLC, same state West Virginia, same site Crab Orchard (minor typo 'Orchad' in CAR), and same methodology.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0xa801d2ec673b26b1e3b2c810ad017774160c22f8ceb625d044fa770a803d7677", "proof": [ "0x3cf1a30e2ccf286206f6a86d4c282a7434c47c0713e12e1a2f174679c2a51b1d", "0x34ce0a0dfa76db146659323d4e89c6eef56d8c4122eab7282e9411ba5117f359", "0xc14e893fc41e6bf87a35e4a932fec14e00d68468b14b0ef262b1dc37a563ad31", "0x8b18b8c767945930d6ca45ba3825aac5cd06f5385b8ef79c119a2d0a9fe823dd", "0xa2620eebe01e77695710df74a55d94a1542d04974f082d2d7ffd94876141ce23", "0x3c6adb2582d2ad52455a9d3c6c8037c9fbdb02cc59381830948d83ab588d4943" ] }, { "id": "ACR0806~CAR2167", "a": "ACR0806", "b": "CAR2167", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.95, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.97, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0806", "Project Name": "Bonny Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Transferred ARB Project", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "WEST VIRGINIA", "Project Site Location": "Mount Hope", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 181487, "Total Credits Retired": 106521, "issued_by_vintage": { "2022": 49803, "2023": 57293, "2024": 74391 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2167", "Project Name": "Bonny Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "WEST VIRGINIA", "Project Site Location": "Near Mt. Hope", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment,LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 86782, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 86782 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Bonny Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "value_b": "Bonny Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "value_b": "Keyrock Environment,LLC" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / WEST VIRGINIA / Mount Hope", "value_b": "United States / WEST VIRGINIA / Near Mt. Hope" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture", "value_b": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects" } ], "differences": [ "Site listed as 'Mount Hope' in ACR0806 vs 'Near Mt. Hope' in CAR2167" ], "reason": "Identical project name 'Bonny Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project', same developer Keyrock Environment LLC, same state West Virginia, and sites 'Mount Hope' vs 'Near Mt. Hope' refer to the same locality.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x8a86ba52438d9698df35330f83f5287b20751cc6bdc1cd6cdae80f49382bb1f4", "proof": [ "0x2dff03fcc6125fcce790b71bf5e0dca9ed61f8817b2fd61e5483505ec000bbf1", "0xe54fcc7044b02fcb4340f7765be0076b4cddc85b405a7cf8ec3a82fc1bad1270", "0xc14e893fc41e6bf87a35e4a932fec14e00d68468b14b0ef262b1dc37a563ad31", "0x8b18b8c767945930d6ca45ba3825aac5cd06f5385b8ef79c119a2d0a9fe823dd", "0xa2620eebe01e77695710df74a55d94a1542d04974f082d2d7ffd94876141ce23", "0x3c6adb2582d2ad52455a9d3c6c8037c9fbdb02cc59381830948d83ab588d4943" ] }, { "id": "ACR0743~CAR2055", "a": "ACR0743", "b": "CAR2055", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.9333, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.98, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0743", "Project Name": "Urling Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Transferred ARB Project", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "PENNSYLVANIA", "Project Site Location": "Shelocta", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 21850, "Total Credits Retired": 15841, "issued_by_vintage": { "2022": 3665, "2023": 9378, "2024": 8807 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2055", "Project Name": "Urling Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "PENNSYLVANIA", "Project Site Location": "Shelcota", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment,LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 12081, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 5937, "2026": 6144 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Urling Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "value_b": "Urling Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "value_b": "Keyrock Environment,LLC" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / PENNSYLVANIA / Shelocta", "value_b": "United States / PENNSYLVANIA / Shelcota" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture", "value_b": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects" } ], "differences": [ "Site name has minor typo in CAR2055: 'Shelcota' vs 'Shelocta'" ], "reason": "Identical project name 'Urling Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project', same developer Keyrock Environment LLC, same state Pennsylvania, and sites 'Shelocta' vs 'Shelcota' are the same locality with a minor typo.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x2dff03fcc6125fcce790b71bf5e0dca9ed61f8817b2fd61e5483505ec000bbf1", "proof": [ "0x8a86ba52438d9698df35330f83f5287b20751cc6bdc1cd6cdae80f49382bb1f4", "0xe54fcc7044b02fcb4340f7765be0076b4cddc85b405a7cf8ec3a82fc1bad1270", "0xc14e893fc41e6bf87a35e4a932fec14e00d68468b14b0ef262b1dc37a563ad31", "0x8b18b8c767945930d6ca45ba3825aac5cd06f5385b8ef79c119a2d0a9fe823dd", "0xa2620eebe01e77695710df74a55d94a1542d04974f082d2d7ffd94876141ce23", "0x3c6adb2582d2ad52455a9d3c6c8037c9fbdb02cc59381830948d83ab588d4943" ] }, { "id": "ACR1009~CAR2111", "a": "ACR1009", "b": "CAR2111", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.9333, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.97, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR1009", "Project Name": "Green Valley Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Transferred ARB Project", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "ILLINOIS", "Project Site Location": "6010 State Line Rd, Paris Township", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 31850, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2024": 31850 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2111", "Project Name": "Green Valley Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "ILLINOIS", "Project Site Location": "Paris", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment,LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 159383, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 159383 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Green Valley Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "value_b": "Green Valley Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "value_b": "Keyrock Environment,LLC" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / ILLINOIS / 6010 State Line Rd, Paris Township", "value_b": "United States / ILLINOIS / Paris" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture", "value_b": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects" } ], "differences": [ "ACR1009 gives full address '6010 State Line Rd, Paris Township'; CAR2111 gives only 'Paris'" ], "reason": "Both records share name (Green Valley Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project), developer (Keyrock Environment LLC), country / state / site (United States / ILLINOIS / 6010 State Line Rd, Paris Township), scope / type (Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture).", "reason_from_model": false, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x72974009f80051396e73a45353e095d4bed3c2445230de4c1233de0263ee76a1", "proof": [ "0x8a059d46e72832761caaba22e5dd6386d1ef8fd31b174177bbe967ce76c1304c", "0x6aed0111fc0a264d42496dfb2441e650a7639ad55fd4bb4f3f399e731de88367", "0x74a44b7d15fbcfc8817f5788868d0893630dc9c31d46cb85996903206269791c", "0xbdf88e70f9cc15470df024c39a4fd510f561023f2d2cb908fe6fc9e728052bb5", "0xa2620eebe01e77695710df74a55d94a1542d04974f082d2d7ffd94876141ce23", "0x3c6adb2582d2ad52455a9d3c6c8037c9fbdb02cc59381830948d83ab588d4943" ] }, { "id": "CAR448~VCS1680", "a": "CAR448", "b": "VCS1680", "registry_a": "CAR", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.925, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "CAR448", "Project Name": "Tri-Community Recycling and Sanitary Landfill", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Waste Management", "Type": "Landfill Methane", "Methodology / Protocol": "CAR U.S. Landfill Protocol", "Country": "United States", "State": "MAINE", "Project Site Location": "Fort Fairfield, ME", "Project Developer": "3Degrees Group, Inc", "Total Credits Issued": 4091, "Total Credits Retired": 319, "issued_by_vintage": { "2010": 4091 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS1680", "Project Name": "Tri-Community Recycling and Sanitary Landfill Project", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Pipeline listing (under development) approved", "Scope": "Waste Management", "Type": "Landfill Methane", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0001 Flaring or use of landfill gas", "Country": "United States", "State": "MAINE", "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "3Degrees Group, Inc..", "Total Credits Issued": 0, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": {}, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "3Degrees Group, Inc", "value_b": "3Degrees Group, Inc.." }, { "field": "Country / State", "value_a": "United States / MAINE", "value_b": "United States / MAINE" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Waste Management / Landfill Methane", "value_b": "Waste Management / Landfill Methane" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: CAR CAR448 vs VCS VCS1680", "Name: Tri-Community Recycling and Sanitary Landfill vs Tri-Community Recycling and Sanitary Landfill Project", "Methodology: CAR U.S. Landfill Protocol vs ACM0001 Flaring or use of landfill gas", "Status: Completed vs Under development" ], "reason": "Both listings describe a Waste Management / Landfill Methane project in United States / MAINE developed by 3Degrees Group, Inc.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x8a059d46e72832761caaba22e5dd6386d1ef8fd31b174177bbe967ce76c1304c", "proof": [ "0x72974009f80051396e73a45353e095d4bed3c2445230de4c1233de0263ee76a1", "0x6aed0111fc0a264d42496dfb2441e650a7639ad55fd4bb4f3f399e731de88367", "0x74a44b7d15fbcfc8817f5788868d0893630dc9c31d46cb85996903206269791c", "0xbdf88e70f9cc15470df024c39a4fd510f561023f2d2cb908fe6fc9e728052bb5", "0xa2620eebe01e77695710df74a55d94a1542d04974f082d2d7ffd94876141ce23", "0x3c6adb2582d2ad52455a9d3c6c8037c9fbdb02cc59381830948d83ab588d4943" ] }, { "id": "GS826~VCS1829", "a": "GS826", "b": "VCS1829", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.9, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS826", "Project Name": "Biomass based power project in Punjab India", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Listed", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Biomass", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-I.D. Grid connected renewable electricity generation", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Dee Development Engineers Pvt. Ltd.", "Total Credits Issued": 0, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": {}, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS1829", "Project Name": "Biomass based power project in Punjab, India", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Pipeline listing (under development) approved", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Biomass", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-I.D. Grid connected renewable electricity generation", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Dee Development Engineers Pvt. Ltd.", "Total Credits Issued": 0, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": {}, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Dee Development Engineers Pvt. Ltd.", "value_b": "Dee Development Engineers Pvt. Ltd." }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Biomass", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Biomass" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "AMS-I.D. Grid connected renewable electricity generation", "value_b": "AMS-I.D. Grid connected renewable electricity generation" }, { "field": "Credits issued by vintage", "value_a": "none", "value_b": "none" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS826 vs VCS VCS1829", "Name: Biomass based power project in Punjab India vs Biomass based power project in Punjab, India", "Status: Listed vs Under development" ], "reason": "Both listings describe a Biomass based power project in India developed by Dee Development Engineers Pvt. Ltd. using the AMS-I.D. Grid connected renewable electricity generation methodology.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x39fa567cd2fb3a9618967fc57bc011ff19df090c758d5b665c429ee46773f16d", "proof": [ "0x645d9d4f75ec1dc8710092e213adbd5b7cf7146a4e09ff9d3bf10b1f878f8f0e", "0xc97d0510343e599e747a23f1369b8e1fbce0729d8534b3a02c7d58157049f28b", "0x74a44b7d15fbcfc8817f5788868d0893630dc9c31d46cb85996903206269791c", "0xbdf88e70f9cc15470df024c39a4fd510f561023f2d2cb908fe6fc9e728052bb5", "0xa2620eebe01e77695710df74a55d94a1542d04974f082d2d7ffd94876141ce23", "0x3c6adb2582d2ad52455a9d3c6c8037c9fbdb02cc59381830948d83ab588d4943" ] }, { "id": "GS12382~VCS4032", "a": "GS12382", "b": "VCS4032", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.9, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS12382", "Project Name": "Improved agricultural practices for Rice cultivation in India", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Agriculture", "Type": "Rice Emission Reductions", "Methodology / Protocol": null, "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Kosher Climate India Pvt Ltd.", "Total Credits Issued": 0, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": {}, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS4032", "Project Name": "Improved Agricultural Practices for Rice Cultivation in India", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Withdrawn", "Scope": "Agriculture", "Type": "Rice Emission Reductions", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-III.AU. Methane emission reduction by adjusted water management practice in rice cultivation", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Kosher Climate India Pvt. Ltd.", "Total Credits Issued": 0, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": {}, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Kosher Climate India Pvt Ltd.", "value_b": "Kosher Climate India Pvt. Ltd." }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Agriculture / Rice Emission Reductions", "value_b": "Agriculture / Rice Emission Reductions" }, { "field": "Credits issued by vintage", "value_a": "none", "value_b": "none" }, { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Improved agricultural practices for Rice cultivation in India", "value_b": "Improved Agricultural Practices for Rice Cultivation in India" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS12382 vs VCS VCS4032", "Status: Gold Standard Certified Project vs Withdrawn", "Methodology: Not listed in A vs AMS-III.AU. Methane emission reduction by adjusted water management practice in rice耕" ], "reason": "Both listings describe a project by Kosher Climate India Pvt Ltd. in India involving Agriculture / Rice Emission Reductions.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x645d9d4f75ec1dc8710092e213adbd5b7cf7146a4e09ff9d3bf10b1f878f8f0e", "proof": [ "0x39fa567cd2fb3a9618967fc57bc011ff19df090c758d5b665c429ee46773f16d", "0xc97d0510343e599e747a23f1369b8e1fbce0729d8534b3a02c7d58157049f28b", "0x74a44b7d15fbcfc8817f5788868d0893630dc9c31d46cb85996903206269791c", "0xbdf88e70f9cc15470df024c39a4fd510f561023f2d2cb908fe6fc9e728052bb5", "0xa2620eebe01e77695710df74a55d94a1542d04974f082d2d7ffd94876141ce23", "0x3c6adb2582d2ad52455a9d3c6c8037c9fbdb02cc59381830948d83ab588d4943" ] }, { "id": "GS12028~VCS4209", "a": "GS12028", "b": "VCS4209", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "Brazil", "screen_score": 0.8714, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.99, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS12028", "Project Name": "Oeste de Caucaia Landfill Project Activity", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Listed", "Scope": "Waste Management", "Type": "Landfill Methane", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0001 Flaring or use of landfill gas", "Country": "Brazil", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "GNR FORTALEZA VALORIZACAO DE BIOGAS LTDA", "Total Credits Issued": 0, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": {}, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS4209", "Project Name": "Oeste de Caucaia Landfill Project Activity", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Waste Management", "Type": "Landfill Methane", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0001 Flaring or use of landfill gas", "Country": "Brazil", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "GNR FORTALEZA VALORIZACAO DE BIOGAS LTDA (PP)", "Total Credits Issued": 0, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": {}, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Oeste de Caucaia Landfill Project Activity", "value_b": "Oeste de Caucaia Landfill Project Activity" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "GNR FORTALEZA VALORIZACAO DE BIOGAS LTDA", "value_b": "GNR FORTALEZA VALORIZACAO DE BIOGAS LTDA (PP)" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "Brazil / None / None", "value_b": "Brazil / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Waste Management / Landfill Methane", "value_b": "Waste Management / Landfill Methane" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ACM0001 Flaring or use of landfill gas", "value_b": "ACM0001 Flaring or use of landfill gas" } ], "differences": [ "GS registry: GOLD; VCS registry: VCS" ], "reason": "Both listings share the identical project name 'Oeste de Caucaia Landfill Project Activity', the same developer (GNR FORTALEZA VALORIZACAO DE BIOGAS LTDA), the same country (Brazil), and the same methodology (ACM0001), confirming they describe the same landfill gas facility.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x5c16799418b2e81377f46b939e4f37936b685407b8e450a3f7c3821ad2fdf84f", "proof": [ "0x317b24b0d4239ce74cae33f51792cf785da1718c9461ae885449e1b426fd2742", "0x70384df3985d6297826009aeec3784cdb0df06dcb68e5f6b855dc1544aaf4406", "0x04f1b885498c9154c47d6770d9dac83072b8dcbd7ad0cfe64693f7153f464af1", "0xbdf88e70f9cc15470df024c39a4fd510f561023f2d2cb908fe6fc9e728052bb5", "0xa2620eebe01e77695710df74a55d94a1542d04974f082d2d7ffd94876141ce23", "0x3c6adb2582d2ad52455a9d3c6c8037c9fbdb02cc59381830948d83ab588d4943" ] }, { "id": "GS23203~VCS2349", "a": "GS23203", "b": "VCS2349", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "Kenya", "screen_score": 0.8667, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.99, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS23203", "Project Name": "Installation of high efficiency wood burning cookstoves in Kenya", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Listed", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "Other", "Country": "Kenya", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Bridge Carbon Africa Stoves Development Private Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 0, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": {}, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS2349", "Project Name": "Installation of high efficiency wood burning cookstoves in Kenya", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "VM0050 Energy Efficiency and Fuel-Switch Measures in Cookstoves", "Country": "Kenya", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Bridge Carbon Africa Stoves Development Private Limited (PP)", "Total Credits Issued": 480466, "Total Credits Retired": 196015, "issued_by_vintage": { "2020": 106, "2021": 24251, "2022": 331705, "2023": 113463, "2024": 8777, "2025": 2164 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Installation of high efficiency wood burning cookstoves in Kenya", "value_b": "Installation of high efficiency wood burning cookstoves in Kenya" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Bridge Carbon Africa Stoves Development Private Limited", "value_b": "Bridge Carbon Africa Stoves Development Private Limited (PP)" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "Kenya / None / None", "value_b": "Kenya / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Household & Community / Cookstoves", "value_b": "Household & Community / Cookstoves" } ], "differences": [ "GS registry: GOLD; VCS registry: VCS", "GS methodology: Other; VCS methodology: VM0050" ], "reason": "Both listings share the identical project name 'Installation of high efficiency wood burning cookstoves in Kenya', the same developer (Bridge Carbon Africa Stoves Development Private Limited), and the same country (Kenya), confirming they describe the same cookstove programme.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x317b24b0d4239ce74cae33f51792cf785da1718c9461ae885449e1b426fd2742", "proof": [ "0x5c16799418b2e81377f46b939e4f37936b685407b8e450a3f7c3821ad2fdf84f", "0x70384df3985d6297826009aeec3784cdb0df06dcb68e5f6b855dc1544aaf4406", "0x04f1b885498c9154c47d6770d9dac83072b8dcbd7ad0cfe64693f7153f464af1", "0xbdf88e70f9cc15470df024c39a4fd510f561023f2d2cb908fe6fc9e728052bb5", "0xa2620eebe01e77695710df74a55d94a1542d04974f082d2d7ffd94876141ce23", "0x3c6adb2582d2ad52455a9d3c6c8037c9fbdb02cc59381830948d83ab588d4943" ] }, { "id": "GS23207~VCS2522", "a": "GS23207", "b": "VCS2522", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "Thailand", "screen_score": 0.8667, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.95, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS23207", "Project Name": "Installation of high efficiency wood burning cookstoves in Thailand", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Listed", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "Other", "Country": "Thailand", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Bridge Carbon SGT Asia Stoves Private Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 0, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": {}, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS2522", "Project Name": "Installation of high efficiency wood burning cookstoves in Thailand", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "VMR0006 Energy Efficiency and Fuel Switch Measures in Thermal Applications", "Country": "Thailand", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Bridge Carbon SGT Asia Stoves Private Limited (PP)", "Total Credits Issued": 217099, "Total Credits Retired": 117111, "issued_by_vintage": { "2021": 10022, "2022": 207077 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Installation of high efficiency wood burning cookstoves in Thailand", "value_b": "Installation of high efficiency wood burning cookstoves in Thailand" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Bridge Carbon SGT Asia Stoves Private Limited", "value_b": "Bridge Carbon SGT Asia Stoves Private Limited (PP)" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "Thailand / None / None", "value_b": "Thailand / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Household & Community / Cookstoves", "value_b": "Household & Community / Cookstoves" } ], "differences": [ "Registry: GOLD vs VCS", "Methodology: Other vs VMR0006 Energy Efficiency and Fuel Switch Measures in Thermal Applications" ], "reason": "Identical project name, developer, country, scope/type, and activity description (ICS cookstoves in Thailand) across both registries indicate the same physical programme.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0xe73a205bf0fc0bcef4a01993b87a772e1cf6429fca12758abea08b1b9e981cce", "proof": [ "0xad576ddfb446626bc32ba6beba7c9bfc29e60aba821e99a1752d44767e5e8ff3", "0x2fd78b03a775a5de9b2ebb68a2dcea7a6d4a8a59657b022f82348a664ae4c154", "0x04f1b885498c9154c47d6770d9dac83072b8dcbd7ad0cfe64693f7153f464af1", "0xbdf88e70f9cc15470df024c39a4fd510f561023f2d2cb908fe6fc9e728052bb5", "0xa2620eebe01e77695710df74a55d94a1542d04974f082d2d7ffd94876141ce23", "0x3c6adb2582d2ad52455a9d3c6c8037c9fbdb02cc59381830948d83ab588d4943" ] }, { "id": "GS23204~VCS2350", "a": "GS23204", "b": "VCS2350", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "Uganda", "screen_score": 0.8667, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.95, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS23204", "Project Name": "Installation of high efficiency wood burning cookstoves in Uganda", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Listed", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "Other", "Country": "Uganda", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Bridge Carbon Africa Stoves Development Private Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 0, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": {}, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS2350", "Project Name": "Installation of high efficiency wood burning cookstoves in Uganda", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Verification approval requested", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "VMR0006 Energy Efficiency and Fuel Switch Measures in Thermal Applications", "Country": "Uganda", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Bridge Carbon Africa Stoves Development Private Limited (PP)", "Total Credits Issued": 31545, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2021": 95, "2022": 31450 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Installation of high efficiency wood burning cookstoves in Uganda", "value_b": "Installation of high efficiency wood burning cookstoves in Uganda" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Bridge Carbon Africa Stoves Development Private Limited", "value_b": "Bridge Carbon Africa Stoves Development Private Limited (PP)" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "Uganda / None / None", "value_b": "Uganda / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Household & Community / Cookstoves", "value_b": "Household & Community / Cookstoves" } ], "differences": [ "Registry: GOLD vs VCS", "Methodology: Other vs VMR0006 Energy Efficiency and Fuel Switch Measures in Thermal Applications" ], "reason": "Identical project name, developer, country, and scope/type (ICS cookstoves in Uganda) confirm the same physical programme registered in both GOLD and VCS.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0xad576ddfb446626bc32ba6beba7c9bfc29e60aba821e99a1752d44767e5e8ff3", "proof": [ "0xe73a205bf0fc0bcef4a01993b87a772e1cf6429fca12758abea08b1b9e981cce", "0x2fd78b03a775a5de9b2ebb68a2dcea7a6d4a8a59657b022f82348a664ae4c154", "0x04f1b885498c9154c47d6770d9dac83072b8dcbd7ad0cfe64693f7153f464af1", "0xbdf88e70f9cc15470df024c39a4fd510f561023f2d2cb908fe6fc9e728052bb5", "0xa2620eebe01e77695710df74a55d94a1542d04974f082d2d7ffd94876141ce23", "0x3c6adb2582d2ad52455a9d3c6c8037c9fbdb02cc59381830948d83ab588d4943" ] }, { "id": "GS23208~VCS2523", "a": "GS23208", "b": "VCS2523", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "Viet Nam", "screen_score": 0.8667, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.95, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS23208", "Project Name": "Installation of high efficiency wood burning cookstoves in Vietnam", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Listed", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "Other", "Country": "Viet Nam", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Bridge Carbon SGT Asia Stoves Private Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 0, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": {}, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS2523", "Project Name": "Installation of high efficiency wood burning cookstoves in Vietnam", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "VMR0006 Energy Efficiency and Fuel Switch Measures in Thermal Applications", "Country": "Viet Nam", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Bridge Carbon SGT Asia Stoves Private Limited (PP)", "Total Credits Issued": 206369, "Total Credits Retired": 121180, "issued_by_vintage": { "2021": 3138, "2022": 203231 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Installation of high efficiency wood burning cookstoves in Vietnam", "value_b": "Installation of high efficiency wood burning cookstoves in Vietnam" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Bridge Carbon SGT Asia Stoves Private Limited", "value_b": "Bridge Carbon SGT Asia Stoves Private Limited (PP)" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "Viet Nam / None / None", "value_b": "Viet Nam / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Household & Community / Cookstoves", "value_b": "Household & Community / Cookstoves" } ], "differences": [ "Registry: GOLD vs VCS", "Methodology: Other vs VMR0006 Energy Efficiency and Fuel Switch Measures in Thermal Applications" ], "reason": "Identical project name, developer, country, and scope/type (ICS cookstoves in Vietnam) confirm the same physical programme registered in both GOLD and VCS.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x8b2c9caec7bfb73a12f1b40831823820a5ca4c186bff3ae5c8c254994c5ce9f6", "proof": [ "0x1e3595f20778057611d1dd884e9b549a61d27548bed1daf950c379414747f18a", "0x0a82473eae79044a31d2084f1d041ce33ab45a8e8814a1aa5f7c9994c145d4a0", "0xe405c6413b36590f180296e261a5e6323b511676581d8fb0c638c68089210acb", "0xd560802f52946cc0756b62c5336316c0a3c31855b0708e4683fa4dd6ee24c9f5", "0x163e59c27b2e72be7326b433f70ffc284e89bc1f4e638d6aee2160e3ca0eaef1", "0x3c6adb2582d2ad52455a9d3c6c8037c9fbdb02cc59381830948d83ab588d4943" ] }, { "id": "GS828~VCS831", "a": "GS828", "b": "VCS831", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "Nicaragua", "screen_score": 0.85, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.95, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS828", "Project Name": "Amayo Phase II Wind Power Project", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": null, "Country": "Nicaragua", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Consorcio Eólico Amayo S.A.", "Total Credits Issued": 685812, "Total Credits Retired": 171833, "issued_by_vintage": { "2014": 62627, "2015": 59954, "2016": 65418, "2017": 57524, "2018": 83102, "2019": 122594, "2020": 52219, "2021": 54167, "2022": 48764, "2023": 51026, "2024": 17305, "2025": 11112 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS831", "Project Name": "Amayo Phase II Wind Power Project", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Late to Verify", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "Nicaragua", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Consorcio Eólico Amayo (Fase II) S.A.", "Total Credits Issued": 77544, "Total Credits Retired": 77444, "issued_by_vintage": { "2011": 77544 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Amayo Phase II Wind Power Project", "value_b": "Amayo Phase II Wind Power Project" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "Nicaragua / None / None", "value_b": "Nicaragua / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Wind", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Wind" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS828 vs VCS VCS831", "Developer: Consorcio Eólico Amayo S.A. vs Consorcio Eólico Amayo (Fase II) S.A.", "Status: Gold Standard Certified Project vs Late to verify", "Credits issued by vintage: 2014-2023 vs 2011" ], "reason": "Both listings describe the Amayo Phase II Wind Power Project located in Nicaragua under the Scope / Type of Renewable Energy / Wind.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x1e3595f20778057611d1dd884e9b549a61d27548bed1daf950c379414747f18a", "proof": [ "0x8b2c9caec7bfb73a12f1b40831823820a5ca4c186bff3ae5c8c254994c5ce9f6", "0x0a82473eae79044a31d2084f1d041ce33ab45a8e8814a1aa5f7c9994c145d4a0", "0xe405c6413b36590f180296e261a5e6323b511676581d8fb0c638c68089210acb", "0xd560802f52946cc0756b62c5336316c0a3c31855b0708e4683fa4dd6ee24c9f5", "0x163e59c27b2e72be7326b433f70ffc284e89bc1f4e638d6aee2160e3ca0eaef1", "0x3c6adb2582d2ad52455a9d3c6c8037c9fbdb02cc59381830948d83ab588d4943" ] }, { "id": "ACR0232~CAR402", "a": "ACR0232", "b": "CAR402", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.84, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.95, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0232", "Project Name": "The Dry Creek Dairy Biofactory Project", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Terminated", "Scope": "Agriculture", "Type": "Manure Methane Digester", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Capturing and Destroying Methane from Manure Management Systems", "Country": "United States", "State": "IDAHO", "Project Site Location": "Hansen", "Project Developer": "Camco Offsets I, LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 298204, "Total Credits Retired": 298204, "issued_by_vintage": { "2015": 43254, "2016": 50088, "2017": 55174, "2018": 53275, "2019": 59299, "2020": 37114 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR402", "Project Name": "The Dry Creek Dairy BioFactory® Project", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Agriculture", "Type": "Manure Methane Digester", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Capturing and Destroying Methane from Manure Management Systems", "Country": "United States", "State": "IDAHO", "Project Site Location": "Hansen", "Project Developer": "Camco International Group, Inc.", "Total Credits Issued": 148563, "Total Credits Retired": 148563, "issued_by_vintage": { "2008": 3792, "2009": 7919, "2010": 41037, "2011": 33024, "2012": 3359, "2013": 29905, "2014": 29527 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "The Dry Creek Dairy Biofactory Project", "value_b": "The Dry Creek Dairy BioFactory® Project" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / IDAHO / Hansen", "value_b": "United States / IDAHO / Hansen" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Agriculture / Manure Methane Digester", "value_b": "Agriculture / Manure Methane Digester" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Capturing and Destroying Methane from Manure Management Systems", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Capturing and Destroying Methane from Manure Management Systems" }, { "field": "Registry", "value_a": "ACR", "value_b": "CAR" } ], "differences": [ "Developer name: Camco Offsets I, LLC vs Camco International Group, Inc.", "Registry: ACR vs CAR" ], "reason": "Both listings describe the same dairy digester facility at Hansen, Idaho under nearly identical names, same scope, same methodology, and the same developer corporate family (Camco Offsets I, LLC vs Camco International Group, Inc.).", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x0bb528ff5b9ea8d7908d66253f95b9eed0fa066826486435a4d1ab4cecc5e336", "proof": [ "0xd72736b5bfd26c759c0507df182b83072d4f9e5c76d4ea461d7bd325de7f7fd2", "0x94f886af52e3ad4b12c40fbb03b8bf27d0c6239bd07e1dc0dd23da301c9fb684", "0xe405c6413b36590f180296e261a5e6323b511676581d8fb0c638c68089210acb", "0xd560802f52946cc0756b62c5336316c0a3c31855b0708e4683fa4dd6ee24c9f5", "0x163e59c27b2e72be7326b433f70ffc284e89bc1f4e638d6aee2160e3ca0eaef1", "0x3c6adb2582d2ad52455a9d3c6c8037c9fbdb02cc59381830948d83ab588d4943" ] }, { "id": "GS4194~VCS1239", "a": "GS4194", "b": "VCS1239", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.8333, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.98, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS4194", "Project Name": "Utilization of Biomass in Bricks Manufacturing By Ozone Envirotech Pvt. Ltd. (OEPL)", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Listed", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Brick Manufacturing Emission Reductions", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-III.Z. Fuel switch, process improvement and energy efficiency in brick manufacture", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Ozone Envirotech Private Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 0, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": {}, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS1239", "Project Name": "Utilization of Biomass in Bricks Manufacturing By Ozone Envirotech Pvt. Ltd. (OEPL)", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Pipeline listing (under development) approved", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Brick Manufacturing Emission Reductions", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-III.Z. Fuel switch, process improvement and energy efficiency in brick manufacture", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Ozone Envirotech Private Limited (PP)", "Total Credits Issued": 0, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": {}, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Utilization of Biomass in Bricks Manufacturing By Ozone Envirotech Pvt. Ltd. (OEPL)", "value_b": "Utilization of Biomass in Bricks Manufacturing By Ozone Envirotech Pvt. Ltd. (OEPL)" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Ozone Envirotech Private Limited", "value_b": "Ozone Envirotech Private Limited (PP)" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Industrial & Commercial / Brick Manufacturing Emission Reductions", "value_b": "Industrial & Commercial / Brick Manufacturing Emission Reductions" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "AMS-III.Z. Fuel switch, process improvement and energy efficiency in brick manufacture", "value_b": "AMS-III.Z. Fuel switch, process improvement and energy efficiency in brick manufacture" } ], "differences": [ "Registry: GOLD vs VCS", "Developer label: 'Ozone Envirotech Private Limited' vs 'Ozone Envirotech Private Limited (PP)'" ], "reason": "Both records share name (Utilization of Biomass in Bricks Manufacturing By Ozone Envirotech Pvt. Ltd. (OEPL)), developer (Ozone Envirotech Private Limited), country / state / site (India / None / None), scope / type (Industrial & Commercial / Brick Manufacturing Emission Reductions).", "reason_from_model": false, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0xd72736b5bfd26c759c0507df182b83072d4f9e5c76d4ea461d7bd325de7f7fd2", "proof": [ "0x0bb528ff5b9ea8d7908d66253f95b9eed0fa066826486435a4d1ab4cecc5e336", "0x94f886af52e3ad4b12c40fbb03b8bf27d0c6239bd07e1dc0dd23da301c9fb684", "0xe405c6413b36590f180296e261a5e6323b511676581d8fb0c638c68089210acb", "0xd560802f52946cc0756b62c5336316c0a3c31855b0708e4683fa4dd6ee24c9f5", "0x163e59c27b2e72be7326b433f70ffc284e89bc1f4e638d6aee2160e3ca0eaef1", "0x3c6adb2582d2ad52455a9d3c6c8037c9fbdb02cc59381830948d83ab588d4943" ] }, { "id": "GS6279~VCS1819", "a": "GS6279", "b": "VCS1819", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.8333, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.98, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS6279", "Project Name": "19.2 MWp Solar Power Project by HZL at Debari and Dariba Rajasthan", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Solar - Centralized", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Hindustan Zinc Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 58096, "Total Credits Retired": 28989, "issued_by_vintage": { "2019": 20076, "2020": 38020 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS1819", "Project Name": "19.2 MWp Solar Power Project by HZL at Debari and Dariba, Rajasthan", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Withdrawn", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Solar - Centralized", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Hindustan Zinc Limited (PP)", "Total Credits Issued": 46473, "Total Credits Retired": 46473, "issued_by_vintage": { "2017": 20721, "2018": 25752 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "19.2 MWp Solar Power Project by HZL at Debari and Dariba Rajasthan", "value_b": "19.2 MWp Solar Power Project by HZL at Debari and Dariba, Rajasthan" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Hindustan Zinc Limited", "value_b": "Hindustan Zinc Limited (PP)" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Solar - Centralized", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Solar - Centralized" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "value_b": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources" } ], "differences": [ "Registry: GOLD vs VCS", "Name punctuation: 'Dariba Rajasthan' vs 'Dariba, Rajasthan'" ], "reason": "Identical developer (Hindustan Zinc Limited), capacity (19.2 MWp), sites (Debari and Dariba, Rajasthan), scope, and methodology confirm the same solar power asset.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x1666b7ca34d6e3adf75ecf1570ce66c4e448739999029395f214a476c0dcab98", "proof": [ "0x410d13556a45ea9838a67d622f9a6561166b9a6807f48ced502e9a444e04c90b", "0x44e2b68a8df4bfaf629f316a46e1ed4a931cc767dc0adc1ef120a9a39f7c1182", "0x7bd547aaa02a753c166286d082b1f1b339eedab300fc43aebbc68dbb56376f16", "0xd560802f52946cc0756b62c5336316c0a3c31855b0708e4683fa4dd6ee24c9f5", "0x163e59c27b2e72be7326b433f70ffc284e89bc1f4e638d6aee2160e3ca0eaef1", "0x3c6adb2582d2ad52455a9d3c6c8037c9fbdb02cc59381830948d83ab588d4943" ] }, { "id": "GS6747~VCS1134", "a": "GS6747", "b": "VCS1134", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.8333, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.98, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS6747", "Project Name": "52.50 MW Wind energy farm at Mokla Rajasthan by HZL", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": null, "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Hindustan Zinc Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 365994, "Total Credits Retired": 85642, "issued_by_vintage": { "2017": 55243, "2018": 96045, "2019": 118504, "2020": 96202 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS1134", "Project Name": "52.50 MW Wind energy farm at Mokla Rajasthan by HZL", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Withdrawn", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Hindustan Zinc Limited (PP)", "Total Credits Issued": 417675, "Total Credits Retired": 343978, "issued_by_vintage": { "2011": 54123, "2012": 81984, "2013": 70048, "2014": 73338, "2015": 73697, "2016": 64485 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "52.50 MW Wind energy farm at Mokla Rajasthan by HZL", "value_b": "52.50 MW Wind energy farm at Mokla Rajasthan by HZL" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Hindustan Zinc Limited", "value_b": "Hindustan Zinc Limited (PP)" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Wind", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Wind" } ], "differences": [ "Registry: GOLD vs VCS", "GS listing lacks explicit methodology field; VCS lists ACM0002" ], "reason": "Identical project name (52.50 MW Wind energy farm at Mokla Rajasthan by HZL), developer, country, and scope type confirm the same wind farm asset.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x410d13556a45ea9838a67d622f9a6561166b9a6807f48ced502e9a444e04c90b", "proof": [ "0x1666b7ca34d6e3adf75ecf1570ce66c4e448739999029395f214a476c0dcab98", "0x44e2b68a8df4bfaf629f316a46e1ed4a931cc767dc0adc1ef120a9a39f7c1182", "0x7bd547aaa02a753c166286d082b1f1b339eedab300fc43aebbc68dbb56376f16", "0xd560802f52946cc0756b62c5336316c0a3c31855b0708e4683fa4dd6ee24c9f5", "0x163e59c27b2e72be7326b433f70ffc284e89bc1f4e638d6aee2160e3ca0eaef1", "0x3c6adb2582d2ad52455a9d3c6c8037c9fbdb02cc59381830948d83ab588d4943" ] }, { "id": "GS6748~VCS1136", "a": "GS6748", "b": "VCS1136", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.8333, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.98, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS6748", "Project Name": "25.5 MW Wind Energy Farm at Nandurbar Maharashtra by HZL", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": null, "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Hindustan Zinc Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 351512, "Total Credits Retired": 171449, "issued_by_vintage": { "2017": 84693, "2018": 108162, "2019": 94451, "2020": 64206 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS1136", "Project Name": "25.5 MW Wind Energy Farm at Nandurbar Maharashtra by HZL", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Withdrawn", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Hindustan Zinc Limited (PP)", "Total Credits Issued": 271222, "Total Credits Retired": 223718, "issued_by_vintage": { "2011": 4321, "2012": 57767, "2013": 57700, "2014": 47662, "2015": 47504, "2016": 56268 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "25.5 MW Wind Energy Farm at Nandurbar Maharashtra by HZL", "value_b": "25.5 MW Wind Energy Farm at Nandurbar Maharashtra by HZL" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Hindustan Zinc Limited", "value_b": "Hindustan Zinc Limited (PP)" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Wind", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Wind" } ], "differences": [ "Registry: GOLD vs VCS", "GS listing lacks explicit methodology field; VCS lists ACM0002" ], "reason": "Identical project name (25.5 MW Wind Energy Farm at Nandurbar Maharashtra by HZL), developer, country, and scope confirm the same wind farm asset.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x2ae987dccbcfdf3fe5d3ff0790825f3e8ba94ebff3dfb2ef1ef64db213ebd33e", "proof": [ "0x5a06f7bcaae2386887b5aed68ad815d8b5ce2fa4154307bbbcb39ba0453f2ce5", "0x6a8cd2ed04bc38cb6db92febbc59e511af093251c5dd2be108960e4745817487", "0x7bd547aaa02a753c166286d082b1f1b339eedab300fc43aebbc68dbb56376f16", "0xd560802f52946cc0756b62c5336316c0a3c31855b0708e4683fa4dd6ee24c9f5", "0x163e59c27b2e72be7326b433f70ffc284e89bc1f4e638d6aee2160e3ca0eaef1", "0x3c6adb2582d2ad52455a9d3c6c8037c9fbdb02cc59381830948d83ab588d4943" ] }, { "id": "GS6853~VCS344", "a": "GS6853", "b": "VCS344", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.8333, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.97, "transfer_mentioned": true, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS6853", "Project Name": "Wind power project by HZL in Gujarat.", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Hindustan Zinc Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 665193, "Total Credits Retired": 209390, "issued_by_vintage": { "2017": 41895, "2018": 255976, "2019": 219560, "2020": 147762 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS344", "Project Name": "Wind power project by HZL in Gujarat.", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Withdrawn", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Hindustan Zinc Limited (PP)", "Total Credits Issued": 622581, "Total Credits Retired": 622581, "issued_by_vintage": { "2009": 217755, "2013": 17905, "2014": 126821, "2015": 133381, "2016": 126719 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Wind power project by HZL in Gujarat.", "value_b": "Wind power project by HZL in Gujarat." }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Hindustan Zinc Limited", "value_b": "Hindustan Zinc Limited (PP)" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Wind", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Wind" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "value_b": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources" } ], "differences": [ "Registry: GOLD vs VCS", "GS description mentions pre-CDM VCS credits, indicating prior VCS registration" ], "reason": "Identical project name, developer (Hindustan Zinc Limited), country, scope, and methodology; GS listing explicitly states 'The project has started to avail pre CDM VCS Credits' indicating a documented cross-registry relationship.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x5a06f7bcaae2386887b5aed68ad815d8b5ce2fa4154307bbbcb39ba0453f2ce5", "proof": [ "0x2ae987dccbcfdf3fe5d3ff0790825f3e8ba94ebff3dfb2ef1ef64db213ebd33e", "0x6a8cd2ed04bc38cb6db92febbc59e511af093251c5dd2be108960e4745817487", "0x7bd547aaa02a753c166286d082b1f1b339eedab300fc43aebbc68dbb56376f16", "0xd560802f52946cc0756b62c5336316c0a3c31855b0708e4683fa4dd6ee24c9f5", "0x163e59c27b2e72be7326b433f70ffc284e89bc1f4e638d6aee2160e3ca0eaef1", "0x3c6adb2582d2ad52455a9d3c6c8037c9fbdb02cc59381830948d83ab588d4943" ] }, { "id": "GS6855~VCS1135", "a": "GS6855", "b": "VCS1135", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.8333, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.98, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS6855", "Project Name": "27.3 MW Wind energy farm at Mokla Rajasthan by HZL", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Hindustan Zinc Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 200437, "Total Credits Retired": 97442, "issued_by_vintage": { "2017": 12282, "2018": 68714, "2019": 63677, "2020": 55764 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS1135", "Project Name": "27.3 MW Wind energy farm at Mokla Rajasthan by HZL", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Withdrawn", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Hindustan Zinc Limited (PP)", "Total Credits Issued": 194745, "Total Credits Retired": 122059, "issued_by_vintage": { "2011": 2516, "2012": 42344, "2013": 43177, "2014": 36025, "2015": 36661, "2016": 34022 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "27.3 MW Wind energy farm at Mokla Rajasthan by HZL", "value_b": "27.3 MW Wind energy farm at Mokla Rajasthan by HZL" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Hindustan Zinc Limited", "value_b": "Hindustan Zinc Limited (PP)" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Wind", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Wind" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "value_b": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources" } ], "differences": [ "Registry: GOLD vs VCS" ], "reason": "Identical project name (27.3 MW Wind energy farm at Mokla Rajasthan by HZL), developer, country, scope, and methodology confirm the same wind farm asset.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x76529c63a9bf9d93f3355c3144e649aa8f4571bb3f2e6596a09645a1fcb369f6", "proof": [ "0xb95a26b178a828773babb59801592db97e855a98d2fc07fe320daa85c07ef442", "0x8e14872cff149280c47da5b8815476059dc8172cdb216d4d8a71f51ab6fa8a5c", "0x1626b67b660647b69669c7a452bab852e9e017a143365d855179961d193618c2", "0x7007cdee3096edacb1585b1d524b0b878bc988c099085d2c33ebf76a1db45d97", "0x163e59c27b2e72be7326b433f70ffc284e89bc1f4e638d6aee2160e3ca0eaef1", "0x3c6adb2582d2ad52455a9d3c6c8037c9fbdb02cc59381830948d83ab588d4943" ] }, { "id": "GS6856~VCS1138", "a": "GS6856", "b": "VCS1138", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.8333, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.98, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS6856", "Project Name": "9 MW Wind Energy Farm at Jodhpur Rajasthan by HZL", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": null, "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Hindustan Zinc Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 44008, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2017": 5792, "2018": 14678, "2019": 13424, "2020": 10114 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS1138", "Project Name": "9 MW Wind Energy Farm at Jodhpur Rajasthan by HZL", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Withdrawn", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-I.D. Grid connected renewable electricity generation", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Hindustan Zinc Limited (PP)", "Total Credits Issued": 78971, "Total Credits Retired": 78971, "issued_by_vintage": { "2011": 2355, "2012": 17047, "2013": 14539, "2014": 15291, "2015": 15883, "2016": 13856 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "9 MW Wind Energy Farm at Jodhpur Rajasthan by HZL", "value_b": "9 MW Wind Energy Farm at Jodhpur Rajasthan by HZL" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Hindustan Zinc Limited", "value_b": "Hindustan Zinc Limited (PP)" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Wind", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Wind" } ], "differences": [ "Registry: GOLD vs VCS", "GS listing lacks explicit methodology field; VCS lists AMS-I.D." ], "reason": "Identical project name (9 MW Wind Energy Farm at Jodhpur Rajasthan by HZL), developer, country, and scope confirm the same wind farm asset.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0xb95a26b178a828773babb59801592db97e855a98d2fc07fe320daa85c07ef442", "proof": [ "0x76529c63a9bf9d93f3355c3144e649aa8f4571bb3f2e6596a09645a1fcb369f6", "0x8e14872cff149280c47da5b8815476059dc8172cdb216d4d8a71f51ab6fa8a5c", "0x1626b67b660647b69669c7a452bab852e9e017a143365d855179961d193618c2", "0x7007cdee3096edacb1585b1d524b0b878bc988c099085d2c33ebf76a1db45d97", "0x163e59c27b2e72be7326b433f70ffc284e89bc1f4e638d6aee2160e3ca0eaef1", "0x3c6adb2582d2ad52455a9d3c6c8037c9fbdb02cc59381830948d83ab588d4943" ] }, { "id": "GS6857~VCS1139", "a": "GS6857", "b": "VCS1139", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.8333, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.98, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS6857", "Project Name": "15 MW Wind energy farm at Gopalpura Karnataka by HZL", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-I.D. Grid connected renewable electricity generation", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Hindustan Zinc Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 100497, "Total Credits Retired": 34740, "issued_by_vintage": { "2017": 4856, "2018": 19158, "2019": 36468, "2020": 19934, "2021": 17516, "2022": 2565 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS1139", "Project Name": "15 MW Wind energy farm at Gopalpura, Karnataka by HZL", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Withdrawn", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-I.D. Grid connected renewable electricity generation", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Hindustan Zinc Limited (PP)", "Total Credits Issued": 129185, "Total Credits Retired": 129185, "issued_by_vintage": { "2011": 19544, "2012": 23571, "2013": 23145, "2014": 21315, "2015": 19241, "2016": 22369 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Hindustan Zinc Limited", "value_b": "Hindustan Zinc Limited (PP)" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Wind", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Wind" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "AMS-I.D. Grid connected renewable electricity generation", "value_b": "AMS-I.D. Grid connected renewable electricity generation" } ], "differences": [ "Registry: GOLD vs VCS", "Name punctuation: 'Gopalpura Karnataka' vs 'Gopalpura, Karnataka'" ], "reason": "Identical developer (Hindustan Zinc Limited), capacity (15 MW), site (Gopalpura, Karnataka), scope, and methodology confirm the same wind farm asset.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0xf7ba638c5a395a203ace5e20d1766fc135ac050ad888b73147e5b55201e75a5d", "proof": [ "0xf707593f8e17bce028df36caaa03f18edb9883d9949faa7533c77e953f526b1a", "0xd662353db7c7b40edcb2214612295c2fbd478eeb78d78c2840b38f0ce9cad734", "0x1626b67b660647b69669c7a452bab852e9e017a143365d855179961d193618c2", "0x7007cdee3096edacb1585b1d524b0b878bc988c099085d2c33ebf76a1db45d97", "0x163e59c27b2e72be7326b433f70ffc284e89bc1f4e638d6aee2160e3ca0eaef1", "0x3c6adb2582d2ad52455a9d3c6c8037c9fbdb02cc59381830948d83ab588d4943" ] }, { "id": "GS6858~VCS1137", "a": "GS6858", "b": "VCS1137", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.8333, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.98, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS6858", "Project Name": "21 MW Wind energy farm at Palladam TamilNadu by HZL", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Hindustan Zinc Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 125706, "Total Credits Retired": 26633, "issued_by_vintage": { "2017": 14030, "2018": 53877, "2019": 30774, "2020": 27025 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS1137", "Project Name": "21 MW Wind energy farm at Palladam, TamilNadu by HZL", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Withdrawn", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Hindustan Zinc Limited (PP)", "Total Credits Issued": 173385, "Total Credits Retired": 137949, "issued_by_vintage": { "2011": 233, "2012": 43315, "2013": 31797, "2014": 33839, "2015": 25423, "2016": 38778 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Hindustan Zinc Limited", "value_b": "Hindustan Zinc Limited (PP)" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Wind", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Wind" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "value_b": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources" } ], "differences": [ "Registry: GOLD vs VCS", "Name punctuation: 'Palladam TamilNadu' vs 'Palladam, TamilNadu'" ], "reason": "Identical developer (Hindustan Zinc Limited), capacity (21 MW), site (Palladam, TamilNadu), scope, and methodology confirm the same wind farm asset.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0xf707593f8e17bce028df36caaa03f18edb9883d9949faa7533c77e953f526b1a", "proof": [ "0xf7ba638c5a395a203ace5e20d1766fc135ac050ad888b73147e5b55201e75a5d", "0xd662353db7c7b40edcb2214612295c2fbd478eeb78d78c2840b38f0ce9cad734", "0x1626b67b660647b69669c7a452bab852e9e017a143365d855179961d193618c2", "0x7007cdee3096edacb1585b1d524b0b878bc988c099085d2c33ebf76a1db45d97", "0x163e59c27b2e72be7326b433f70ffc284e89bc1f4e638d6aee2160e3ca0eaef1", "0x3c6adb2582d2ad52455a9d3c6c8037c9fbdb02cc59381830948d83ab588d4943" ] }, { "id": "GS23142~ISOprj_1K7F70BKD1S04GWB", "a": "GS23142", "b": "ISOprj_1K7F70BKD1S04GWB", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "ISO", "country": "Papua New Guinea", "screen_score": 0.8333, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.97, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS23142", "Project Name": "Morobe Markham Reforestation Project", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Listed", "Scope": "Forestry & Land Use", "Type": "Afforestation/Reforestation", "Methodology / Protocol": "GS Methodology for Afforestation/Reforestation GHG Emissions Reduction and Sequestration", "Country": "Papua New Guinea", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Morobe Markham LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 0, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": {}, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "ISOprj_1K7F70BKD1S04GWB", "Project Name": "Morobe Markham Reforestation", "Voluntary Registry": "ISO", "Voluntary Status": "Under validation", "Scope": "Forestry & Land Use", "Type": "Afforestation/Reforestation", "Methodology / Protocol": "Reforestation", "Country": "Papua New Guinea", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Morobe Markham Reforestation", "Total Credits Issued": 0, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": {}, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Morobe Markham Reforestation Project", "value_b": "Morobe Markham Reforestation" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "Papua New Guinea / None / None", "value_b": "Papua New Guinea / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Forestry & Land Use / Afforestation/Reforestation", "value_b": "Forestry & Land Use / Afforestation/Reforestation" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Morobe Markham LLC", "value_b": "Morobe Markham Reforestation" }, { "field": "Description (opening)", "value_a": "The Morobe Markham Reforestation project is a first-of-its-kind reforestation project in the Markham Valley of Morobe Province, Papua New Guinea.", "value_b": "The Morobe Markham Reforestation project is a first-of-its-kind reforestation project in the Markham Valley of Morobe Province, Papua New Guinea." } ], "differences": [ "Registry: GOLD vs ISO", "Developer name: 'Morobe Markham LLC' vs 'Morobe Markham Reforestation'", "Methodology: GS Methodology for Afforestation/Reforestation GHG Emissions Reduction and Sequestration vs Reforestation" ], "reason": "Both listings describe the Morobe Markham Reforestation project in the Markham Valley of Morobe Province, Papua New Guinea, with nearly identical descriptions, the same developer partnership (Morobe Markham LLC, PNG Carbon Estate, Nature Focus Capital), and the same scope and country.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0xe3c383a7fe1fc5b020dbb91ee0735fe598f9e7810de50aec6ae6089eedb707c7", "proof": [ "0xfd8f02e430737e2d048a68c5cee35f5a8f07cb48bd853b7ea3fc73d7c1c95cb5", "0x85bbb642ac7c204bd17c272bbe871f06f271cf3325e48cbc8fb1ca535f4d1a26", "0x8f1a809a9fe1f713c9cc98474df7cb6e3b5630b8ae372483aabfc67bbcca7c34", "0x7007cdee3096edacb1585b1d524b0b878bc988c099085d2c33ebf76a1db45d97", "0x163e59c27b2e72be7326b433f70ffc284e89bc1f4e638d6aee2160e3ca0eaef1", "0x3c6adb2582d2ad52455a9d3c6c8037c9fbdb02cc59381830948d83ab588d4943" ] }, { "id": "GS6091~VCS1307", "a": "GS6091", "b": "VCS1307", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.82, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.97, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS6091", "Project Name": "Biomass Based Steam Generation Plant by Farmgate Agro Milch Private Limited", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Listed", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Biomass", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-I.C. Thermal energy production with or without electricity", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Farmgate Agro Milch Private Limited \"GSF\"", "Total Credits Issued": 0, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": {}, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS1307", "Project Name": "Biomass Based Steam Generation Plant Farmgate Agro Milch", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Under validation (Public comment period closed)", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Biomass", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-I.C. Thermal energy production with or without electricity", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "FARMGATE AGRO MILCH PRIVATE LIMITED (PP)", "Total Credits Issued": 0, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": {}, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Farmgate Agro Milch Private Limited \"GSF\"", "value_b": "FARMGATE AGRO MILCH PRIVATE LIMITED (PP)" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Biomass", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Biomass" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "AMS-I.C. Thermal energy production with or without electricity", "value_b": "AMS-I.C. Thermal energy production with or without electricity" } ], "differences": [ "Registry: GOLD vs VCS", "Name: 'Biomass Based Steam Generation Plant by Farmgate Agro Milch Private Limited' vs 'Biomass Based Steam Generation Plant Farmgate Agro Milch'" ], "reason": "Same developer (Farmgate Agro Milch Private Limited), country, scope, and methodology; GS listing specifies the plant at HSIDC Industrial Area, Kundali, Sonepat, Haryana, and both describe a biomass-based steam generation plant for the same milk plant.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0xfd8f02e430737e2d048a68c5cee35f5a8f07cb48bd853b7ea3fc73d7c1c95cb5", "proof": [ "0xe3c383a7fe1fc5b020dbb91ee0735fe598f9e7810de50aec6ae6089eedb707c7", "0x85bbb642ac7c204bd17c272bbe871f06f271cf3325e48cbc8fb1ca535f4d1a26", "0x8f1a809a9fe1f713c9cc98474df7cb6e3b5630b8ae372483aabfc67bbcca7c34", "0x7007cdee3096edacb1585b1d524b0b878bc988c099085d2c33ebf76a1db45d97", "0x163e59c27b2e72be7326b433f70ffc284e89bc1f4e638d6aee2160e3ca0eaef1", "0x3c6adb2582d2ad52455a9d3c6c8037c9fbdb02cc59381830948d83ab588d4943" ] }, { "id": "GS12319~VCS4129", "a": "GS12319", "b": "VCS4129", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.82, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.97, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS12319", "Project Name": "Project Sathya Improved Cookstoves and Livelihood", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Design", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": null, "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "CARBON IMPACT CAPITAL PTE. LTD.", "Total Credits Issued": 0, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": {}, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS4129", "Project Name": "Project Sathya Improved Cookstoves and Livelihood", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Withdrawn", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "VMR0006 Energy Efficiency and Fuel Switch Measures in Thermal Applications", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Carbon Impact Capital (PP)", "Total Credits Issued": 0, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": {}, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Project Sathya Improved Cookstoves and Livelihood", "value_b": "Project Sathya Improved Cookstoves and Livelihood" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Household & Community / Cookstoves", "value_b": "Household & Community / Cookstoves" } ], "differences": [ "Registry: GOLD vs VCS", "Developer label: 'CARBON IMPACT CAPITAL PTE. LTD.' vs 'Carbon Impact Capital (PP)'", "GS lacks explicit methodology field; VCS lists VMR0006" ], "reason": "Both records share name (Project Sathya Improved Cookstoves and Livelihood), country / state / site (India / None / None), scope / type (Household & Community / Cookstoves).", "reason_from_model": false, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false, "leaf": "0x85bbb642ac7c204bd17c272bbe871f06f271cf3325e48cbc8fb1ca535f4d1a26", "proof": [ "0x92369c331d33d49b5bf9f405a642b356d4ae894a5da63c89d4b4226d21fd9ef4", "0x8f1a809a9fe1f713c9cc98474df7cb6e3b5630b8ae372483aabfc67bbcca7c34", "0x7007cdee3096edacb1585b1d524b0b878bc988c099085d2c33ebf76a1db45d97", "0x163e59c27b2e72be7326b433f70ffc284e89bc1f4e638d6aee2160e3ca0eaef1", "0x3c6adb2582d2ad52455a9d3c6c8037c9fbdb02cc59381830948d83ab588d4943" ] } ], "review": [ { "id": "ACR0176~CAR1029", "a": "ACR0176", "b": "CAR1029", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.9288, "name_sim": 0.916, "overlap_vintages": [ 2013 ], "overlap_volume": 113438, "verdict": "unclear", "confidence": 0.55, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0176", "Project Name": "ECC ODS Destruction 2013", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances Banks", "Country": "United States", "State": "ARKANSAS", "Project Site Location": "El Dorado", "Project Developer": "Environmental Credit Corp.", "Total Credits Issued": 255227, "Total Credits Retired": 254284, "issued_by_vintage": { "2013": 255227 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR1029", "Project Name": "ECC ODS Destruction 11-2013", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances Banks", "Country": "United States", "State": "ARKANSAS", "Project Site Location": "El Dorado, AR", "Project Developer": "Environmental Credit Corp.", "Total Credits Issued": 113438, "Total Credits Retired": 113438, "issued_by_vintage": { "2013": 113438 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "unclear", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Environmental Credit Corp.", "value_b": "Environmental Credit Corp." }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / ARKANSAS / El Dorado", "value_b": "United States / ARKANSAS / El Dorado" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "value_b": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances Banks", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances Banks" } ], "differences": [ "ACR name: 'ECC ODS Destruction 2013' vs CAR name: 'ECC ODS Destruction 11-2013'", "Different registry IDs (ACR0176 vs CAR1029)" ], "reason": "Both records share developer (Environmental Credit Corp.), country / state / site (United States / ARKANSAS / El Dorado), scope / type (Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction), methodology (ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances Banks).", "reason_from_model": false, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "ACR0537~CAR2114", "a": "ACR0537", "b": "CAR2114", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.925, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "unclear", "confidence": 0.6, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0537", "Project Name": "Wabash Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Transferred ARB Project", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "ILLINOIS", "Project Site Location": "Mt. Carmel", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 218712, "Total Credits Retired": 68151, "issued_by_vintage": { "2020": 48826, "2021": 18225, "2023": 5562, "2024": 146099 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2114", "Project Name": "Wabash Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "ILLINOIS", "Project Site Location": "Keensburg", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment,LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 286753, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 286753 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "unclear", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Wabash Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "value_b": "Wabash Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "value_b": "Keyrock Environment,LLC" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture", "value_b": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects" } ], "differences": [ "Site listed as 'Mt. Carmel' in ACR0537 vs 'Keensburg' in CAR2114 — different towns in Wabash County, IL" ], "reason": "Both records share name (Wabash Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project), developer (Keyrock Environment LLC), scope / type (Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture), methodology (ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects).", "reason_from_model": false, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false }, { "id": "ACR0372~CAR990", "a": "ACR0372", "b": "CAR990", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.8829, "name_sim": 0.787, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "unclear", "confidence": 0.55, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0372", "Project Name": "EOS 2013 Domestic (EOS ACR 372)", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "CAR U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances Protocol", "Country": "United States", "State": "ARKANSAS", "Project Site Location": "El Dorado", "Project Developer": "EOS Climate Inc", "Total Credits Issued": 0, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": {}, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR990", "Project Name": "EOS 2013 Domestic", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances Banks", "Country": "United States", "State": "ARKANSAS", "Project Site Location": "El Dorado", "Project Developer": "EOS Climate Inc.", "Total Credits Issued": 366749, "Total Credits Retired": 366749, "issued_by_vintage": { "2013": 325668, "2014": 41081 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "unclear", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "EOS Climate Inc", "value_b": "EOS Climate Inc." }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / ARKANSAS / El Dorado", "value_b": "United States / ARKANSAS / El Dorado" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "value_b": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction" } ], "differences": [ "Name: 'EOS 2013 Domestic (EOS ACR 372)' vs 'EOS 2013 Domestic'", "Methodology: CAR U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances Protocol vs ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances Banks", "Registry: ACR vs CAR" ], "reason": "Both are EOS Climate ODS destruction projects at the same El Dorado, AR site for the same year (2013), but they use different methodologies (CAR U.S. ODS Protocol vs ARB Compliance Offset Protocol) and have slightly different names, making it unclear whether they represent the same batch.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "ACR0578~CAR2113", "a": "ACR0578", "b": "CAR2113", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.874, "name_sim": 0.7709, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.88, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0578", "Project Name": "New Era Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Transferred ARB Project", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "ILLINOIS", "Project Site Location": "Galatia", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 461227, "Total Credits Retired": 82012, "issued_by_vintage": { "2021": 94880, "2022": 77171, "2023": 68914, "2024": 220262 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2113", "Project Name": "New Future Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "ILLINOIS", "Project Site Location": "Galatia", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment,LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 73186, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 73186 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "value_b": "Keyrock Environment,LLC" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / ILLINOIS / Galatia", "value_b": "United States / ILLINOIS / Galatia" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture", "value_b": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects" } ], "differences": [ "Name: 'New Era Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project' vs 'New Future Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project'", "Registry: ACR vs CAR" ], "reason": "Both are mine methane capture projects by Keyrock Environment at the same Galatia, IL site using the same methodology, with names 'New Era' and 'New Future' swapped between registries, strongly suggesting the same physical mine asset listed under transposed names.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "ACR0669~CAR2092", "a": "ACR0669", "b": "CAR2092", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.874, "name_sim": 0.7709, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.88, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0669", "Project Name": "New Future Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Transferred ARB Project", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "ILLINOIS", "Project Site Location": "Galatia", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 174700, "Total Credits Retired": 112158, "issued_by_vintage": { "2022": 62598, "2023": 49560, "2024": 62542 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2092", "Project Name": "New Era Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "ILLINOIS", "Project Site Location": "Galatia", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment,LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 220149, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 220149 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "value_b": "Keyrock Environment,LLC" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / ILLINOIS / Galatia", "value_b": "United States / ILLINOIS / Galatia" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture", "value_b": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects" } ], "differences": [ "Name: 'New Future Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project' vs 'New Era Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project'", "Registry: ACR vs CAR" ], "reason": "Both are mine methane capture projects by Keyrock Environment at the same Galatia, IL site using the same methodology, with names 'New Future' and 'New Era' swapped between registries, strongly suggesting the same physical mine asset listed under transposed names.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "ACR0383~CAR2318", "a": "ACR0383", "b": "CAR2318", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.8662, "name_sim": 0.7567, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "unclear", "confidence": 0.45, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0383", "Project Name": "Tradewater ODS 7", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances Banks", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater, LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 138972, "Total Credits Retired": 138972, "issued_by_vintage": { "2017": 138972 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2318", "Project Name": "Tradewater ODS 70", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Listed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ECY Compliance Offset Protocol: Ozone Depleting Substances Projects (ODS)", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 0, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": {}, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "unclear", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Tradewater, LLC", "value_b": "Tradewater LLC" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / OHIO / East Liverpool", "value_b": "United States / OHIO / East Liverpool" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "value_b": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction" } ], "differences": [ "Name: Tradewater ODS 7 vs Tradewater ODS 70", "Methodology: ARB Compliance Offset Protocol vs ECY Compliance Offset Protocol", "Refrigerants: R-11 and R-12 vs unspecified" ], "reason": "Both records share developer (Tradewater, LLC), country / state / site (United States / OHIO / East Liverpool), scope / type (Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction).", "reason_from_model": false, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "ACR0385~CAR2318", "a": "ACR0385", "b": "CAR2318", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.8662, "name_sim": 0.7567, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "unclear", "confidence": 0.45, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0385", "Project Name": "Tradewater ODS 8", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances Banks", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater, LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 138331, "Total Credits Retired": 138331, "issued_by_vintage": { "2017": 138331 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2318", "Project Name": "Tradewater ODS 70", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Listed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ECY Compliance Offset Protocol: Ozone Depleting Substances Projects (ODS)", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 0, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": {}, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "unclear", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Tradewater, LLC", "value_b": "Tradewater LLC" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / OHIO / East Liverpool", "value_b": "United States / OHIO / East Liverpool" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "value_b": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction" } ], "differences": [ "Name: Tradewater ODS 8 vs Tradewater ODS 70", "Methodology: ARB Compliance Offset Protocol vs ECY Compliance Offset Protocol", "Refrigerant: R-12 vs unspecified" ], "reason": "Both records share developer (Tradewater, LLC), country / state / site (United States / OHIO / East Liverpool), scope / type (Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction).", "reason_from_model": false, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "ACR0644~CAR2254", "a": "ACR0644", "b": "CAR2254", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.8543, "name_sim": 0.8714, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "unclear", "confidence": 0.55, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0644", "Project Name": "Willow Lake Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Transferred ARB Project", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "ILLINOIS", "Project Site Location": "Equality", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 276175, "Total Credits Retired": 89635, "issued_by_vintage": { "2021": 33491, "2022": 73501, "2023": 97223, "2024": 71960 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2254", "Project Name": "Willow Lake Mine Methane Recovery Project", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Industrial & Commercial", "Type": "Mine Methane Capture", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "ILLINOIS", "Project Site Location": "Eldorado, IL", "Project Developer": "Keyrock Environment,LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 54283, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 54283 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "unclear", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Keyrock Environment LLC", "value_b": "Keyrock Environment,LLC" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site (State)", "value_a": "United States / ILLINOIS / Equality", "value_b": "United States / ILLINOIS / Eldorado, IL" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture", "value_b": "Industrial & Commercial / Mine Methane Capture" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Mine Methane Capture Projects" } ], "differences": [ "Name: 'Willow Lake Abandoned Mine Methane Recovery Project' vs 'Willow Lake Mine Methane Recovery Project'", "Site: Equality vs Eldorado, IL", "Registry: ACR vs CAR" ], "reason": "Both are Keyrock Environment mine methane capture projects in Illinois using the same methodology, but the site names differ (Equality vs Eldorado, IL) and the project names differ slightly ('Abandoned' in A but not B), making it unclear whether they refer to the same mine.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false }, { "id": "ACR0873~CAR1616", "a": "ACR0873", "b": "CAR1616", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.8477, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "unclear", "confidence": 0.55, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0873", "Project Name": "Mississippi River Islands Forest Conservation Project", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Active: Registered", "Scope": "Forestry & Land Use", "Type": "Improved Forest Management", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACR Improved Forest Management (IFM) on Non-Federal U.S. Forestlands", "Country": "United States", "State": "KENTUCKY, ILLINOIS", "Project Site Location": "Island 8, Wolf Island Bar, Burnham Island", "Project Developer": "U.S. Venture, Inc.", "Total Credits Issued": 462802, "Total Credits Retired": 46686, "issued_by_vintage": { "2022": 53510, "2023": 180417, "2024": 156604, "2025": 72271 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR1616", "Project Name": "Mississippi River Islands Forest Conservation Project", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Forestry & Land Use", "Type": "Avoided Forest Conversion", "Methodology / Protocol": "CAR U.S. Forest Protocol", "Country": "United States", "State": "KENTUCKY", "Project Site Location": "Fulton County, KY; Hickman County, KY; Alexander County, IL", "Project Developer": "U.S. Venture, Inc.", "Total Credits Issued": 0, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": {}, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "unclear", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Mississippi River Islands Forest Conservation Project", "value_b": "Mississippi River Islands Forest Conservation Project" }, { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "U.S. Venture, Inc.", "value_b": "U.S. Venture, Inc." }, { "field": "Country", "value_a": "United States", "value_b": "United States" }, { "field": "Scope", "value_a": "Forestry & Land Use", "value_b": "Forestry & Land Use" }, { "field": "State", "value_a": "KENTUCKY, ILLINOIS", "value_b": "KENTUCKY" } ], "differences": [ "Scope type: Improved Forest Management vs Avoided Forest Conversion", "Methodology: ACR IFM on Non-Federal U.S. Forestlands vs CAR U.S. Forest Protocol", "Site description: Island 8, Wolf Island Bar, Burnham Island vs Fulton County, KY; Hickman County, KY; Alexander County, IL", "Registry: ACR vs CAR" ], "reason": "Identical project name and developer at the same Mississippi River islands geography, but the scope types differ (Improved Forest Management vs Avoided Forest Conversion) and methodologies differ, leaving it unclear whether these are the same physical asset registered under different project types.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false }, { "id": "ACR0736~CAR2318", "a": "ACR0736", "b": "CAR2318", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.8393, "name_sim": 0.7079, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "unclear", "confidence": 0.45, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0736", "Project Name": "Tradewater US - ODS - #1", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACR Destruction of Ozone Depleting Substances and High-GWP Foam", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater, LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 31818, "Total Credits Retired": 30366, "issued_by_vintage": { "2022": 31818 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2318", "Project Name": "Tradewater ODS 70", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Listed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ECY Compliance Offset Protocol: Ozone Depleting Substances Projects (ODS)", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 0, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": {}, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "unclear", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Tradewater, LLC", "value_b": "Tradewater LLC" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / OHIO / East Liverpool", "value_b": "United States / OHIO / East Liverpool" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "value_b": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction" } ], "differences": [ "Name: Tradewater US - ODS - #1 vs Tradewater ODS 70", "Methodology: ACR Destruction of Ozone Depleting Substances and High-GWP Foam vs ECY Compliance Offset Protocol", "Refrigerants: R-11 and R-113 vs unspecified" ], "reason": "Both records share developer (Tradewater, LLC), country / state / site (United States / OHIO / East Liverpool), scope / type (Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction).", "reason_from_model": false, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "ACR0387~CAR2318", "a": "ACR0387", "b": "CAR2318", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.8386, "name_sim": 0.752, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "unclear", "confidence": 0.45, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0387", "Project Name": "Tradewater ODS 9", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances Banks", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool, OH", "Project Developer": "Tradewater, LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 129854, "Total Credits Retired": 129854, "issued_by_vintage": { "2017": 129854 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2318", "Project Name": "Tradewater ODS 70", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Listed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ECY Compliance Offset Protocol: Ozone Depleting Substances Projects (ODS)", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 0, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": {}, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "unclear", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Tradewater, LLC", "value_b": "Tradewater LLC" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / OHIO / East Liverpool, OH", "value_b": "United States / OHIO / East Liverpool" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "value_b": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction" } ], "differences": [ "Name: Tradewater ODS 9 vs Tradewater ODS 70", "Methodology: ARB Compliance Offset Protocol vs ECY Compliance Offset Protocol", "Refrigerant: R-12 vs unspecified" ], "reason": "Both records share developer (Tradewater, LLC), country / state / site (United States / OHIO / East Liverpool, OH), scope / type (Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction).", "reason_from_model": false, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "ACR0758~CAR2318", "a": "ACR0758", "b": "CAR2318", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.8386, "name_sim": 0.7065, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "unclear", "confidence": 0.45, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0758", "Project Name": "Tradewater US - ODS - #2", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACR Destruction of Ozone Depleting Substances and High-GWP Foam", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater, LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 24294, "Total Credits Retired": 24294, "issued_by_vintage": { "2022": 24294 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2318", "Project Name": "Tradewater ODS 70", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Listed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ECY Compliance Offset Protocol: Ozone Depleting Substances Projects (ODS)", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 0, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": {}, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "unclear", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Tradewater, LLC", "value_b": "Tradewater LLC" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / OHIO / East Liverpool", "value_b": "United States / OHIO / East Liverpool" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "value_b": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction" } ], "differences": [ "Name: Tradewater US - ODS - #2 vs Tradewater ODS 70", "Methodology: ACR Destruction of Ozone Depleting Substances and High-GWP Foam vs ECY Compliance Offset Protocol", "Refrigerant: R-11 vs unspecified" ], "reason": "Both records share developer (Tradewater, LLC), country / state / site (United States / OHIO / East Liverpool), scope / type (Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction).", "reason_from_model": false, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "ACR0468~CAR2318", "a": "ACR0468", "b": "CAR2318", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.8363, "name_sim": 0.7023, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "unclear", "confidence": 0.45, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0468", "Project Name": "Tradewater ODS 20", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances Banks", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater, LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 83032, "Total Credits Retired": 80212, "issued_by_vintage": { "2019": 83032 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2318", "Project Name": "Tradewater ODS 70", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Listed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ECY Compliance Offset Protocol: Ozone Depleting Substances Projects (ODS)", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 0, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": {}, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "unclear", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Tradewater, LLC", "value_b": "Tradewater LLC" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / OHIO / East Liverpool", "value_b": "United States / OHIO / East Liverpool" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "value_b": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction" } ], "differences": [ "Name: Tradewater ODS 20 vs Tradewater ODS 70", "Methodology: ARB Compliance Offset Protocol vs ECY Compliance Offset Protocol", "Refrigerant: R-12 vs unspecified" ], "reason": "Both records share developer (Tradewater, LLC), country / state / site (United States / OHIO / East Liverpool), scope / type (Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction).", "reason_from_model": false, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "GS12850~VCS3159", "a": "GS12850", "b": "VCS3159", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.8358, "name_sim": 0.9742, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "unclear", "confidence": 0.5, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS12850", "Project Name": "Distribution of energy efficient cookstove in India -5", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Listed", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "GS TPDDTEC Reduced emissions from cooking and heating – technologies and practices to displace decentralized thermal energy consumption", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "GRENEITY INFOCOM SERVICE PRIVATE LIMITED", "Total Credits Issued": 0, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": {}, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS3159", "Project Name": "Distribution of energy efficient cookstove in India-3", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Pipeline listing (under development) approved", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "VMR0006 Energy Efficiency and Fuel Switch Measures in Thermal Applications", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Greneity Infocom Service Pvt Ltd (PP)", "Total Credits Issued": 0, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": {}, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "unclear", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "GRENEITY INFOCOM SERVICE PRIVATE LIMITED", "value_b": "Greneity Infocom Service Pvt Ltd (PP)" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Household & Community / Cookstoves", "value_b": "Household & Community / Cookstoves" } ], "differences": [ "Name suffix: -5 vs -3 (different numbered phases)", "Registry: GOLD vs VCS", "Methodology: GS TPDDTEC vs VMR0006" ], "reason": "Both records share developer (GRENEITY INFOCOM SERVICE PRIVATE LIMITED), country / state / site (India / None / None), scope / type (Household & Community / Cookstoves).", "reason_from_model": false, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "GS1307~VCS346", "a": "GS1307", "b": "VCS346", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.8333, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS1307", "Project Name": "Wind power project by GFL in Gudhepanchgani", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Listed", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Gujarat Fluorochemicals Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 0, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": {}, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS346", "Project Name": "Wind power project by GFL in Gudhepanchgani", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Late to Verify", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Gujarat Fluorochemicals Limited (GFL)", "Total Credits Issued": 36976, "Total Credits Retired": 36976, "issued_by_vintage": { "2007": 29649, "2008": 7327 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "unclear", "shared_facts": [], "differences": [], "reason": "", "reason_from_model": false, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false }, { "id": "ACR1219~CAR2157", "a": "ACR1219", "b": "CAR2157", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.8011, "name_sim": 0.6384, "overlap_vintages": [ 2025 ], "overlap_volume": 19376, "verdict": "unclear", "confidence": 0.5, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR1219", "Project Name": "Tradewater US - ODS - #13", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACR Destruction of Ozone Depleting Substances and High-GWP Foam", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater, LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 19376, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 19376 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2157", "Project Name": "Tradewater ODS 64", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ECY Compliance Offset Protocol: Ozone Depleting Substances Projects (ODS)", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 51771, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 51771 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "unclear", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Tradewater, LLC", "value_b": "Tradewater LLC" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / OHIO / East Liverpool", "value_b": "United States / OHIO / East Liverpool" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "value_b": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction" } ], "differences": [ "Different project names/numbers (Tradewater US - ODS - #13 vs Tradewater ODS 64)", "Different methodologies (ACR Destruction of ODS vs ECY Compliance Offset Protocol ODS)", "Different registries (ACR vs CAR)" ], "reason": "Both records share developer (Tradewater, LLC), country / state / site (United States / OHIO / East Liverpool), scope / type (Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction).", "reason_from_model": false, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "ACR1219~CAR2153", "a": "ACR1219", "b": "CAR2153", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.7968, "name_sim": 0.6305, "overlap_vintages": [ 2025 ], "overlap_volume": 19376, "verdict": "unclear", "confidence": 0.5, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR1219", "Project Name": "Tradewater US - ODS - #13", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACR Destruction of Ozone Depleting Substances and High-GWP Foam", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater, LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 19376, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 19376 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2153", "Project Name": "Tradewater ODS 62", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ECY Compliance Offset Protocol: Ozone Depleting Substances Projects (ODS)", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 315246, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 315246 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "unclear", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Tradewater, LLC", "value_b": "Tradewater LLC" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / OHIO / East Liverpool", "value_b": "United States / OHIO / East Liverpool" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "value_b": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction" } ], "differences": [ "Different project names/numbers (Tradewater US - ODS - #13 vs Tradewater ODS 62)", "Different methodologies (ACR Destruction of ODS vs ECY Compliance Offset Protocol ODS)", "Different registries (ACR vs CAR)" ], "reason": "Both records share developer (Tradewater, LLC), country / state / site (United States / OHIO / East Liverpool), scope / type (Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction).", "reason_from_model": false, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "ACR0184~CAR992", "a": "ACR0184", "b": "CAR992", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.7955, "name_sim": 0.6282, "overlap_vintages": [ 2013 ], "overlap_volume": 107542, "verdict": "unclear", "confidence": 0.5, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0184", "Project Name": "EOS ACR 2013", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances Banks", "Country": "United States", "State": "ARKANSAS", "Project Site Location": "El Dorado", "Project Developer": "EOS Climate Inc", "Total Credits Issued": 249025, "Total Credits Retired": 249025, "issued_by_vintage": { "2013": 249025 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR992", "Project Name": "EOS ARB ODS 2013-1", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances Banks", "Country": "United States", "State": "ARKANSAS", "Project Site Location": "El Dorado", "Project Developer": "EOS Climate Inc.", "Total Credits Issued": 107542, "Total Credits Retired": 107542, "issued_by_vintage": { "2013": 107542 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "unclear", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "EOS Climate Inc", "value_b": "EOS Climate Inc." }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / ARKANSAS / El Dorado", "value_b": "United States / ARKANSAS / El Dorado" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "value_b": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances Banks", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances Banks" } ], "differences": [ "ACR name: 'EOS ACR 2013' vs CAR name: 'EOS ARB ODS 2013-1'", "ACR is a single project; CAR is one of multiple numbered sub-projects (2013-1, 2013-3, 2013-5)" ], "reason": "Both records share developer (EOS Climate Inc), country / state / site (United States / ARKANSAS / El Dorado), scope / type (Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction), methodology (ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances Banks).", "reason_from_model": false, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "ACR1219~CAR2152", "a": "ACR1219", "b": "CAR2152", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.7946, "name_sim": 0.6266, "overlap_vintages": [ 2025 ], "overlap_volume": 19376, "verdict": "unclear", "confidence": 0.5, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR1219", "Project Name": "Tradewater US - ODS - #13", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACR Destruction of Ozone Depleting Substances and High-GWP Foam", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater, LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 19376, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 19376 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2152", "Project Name": "Tradewater ODS 63", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ECY Compliance Offset Protocol: Ozone Depleting Substances Projects (ODS)", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 138000, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 138000 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "unclear", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Tradewater, LLC", "value_b": "Tradewater LLC" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / OHIO / East Liverpool", "value_b": "United States / OHIO / East Liverpool" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "value_b": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction" } ], "differences": [ "Different project names/numbers (Tradewater US - ODS - #13 vs Tradewater ODS 63)", "Different methodologies (ACR Destruction of ODS vs ECY Compliance Offset Protocol ODS)", "Different registries (ACR vs CAR)" ], "reason": "Both records share developer (Tradewater, LLC), country / state / site (United States / OHIO / East Liverpool), scope / type (Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction).", "reason_from_model": false, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "ACR1219~CAR2257", "a": "ACR1219", "b": "CAR2257", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.7946, "name_sim": 0.6266, "overlap_vintages": [ 2025 ], "overlap_volume": 19376, "verdict": "unclear", "confidence": 0.5, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR1219", "Project Name": "Tradewater US - ODS - #13", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACR Destruction of Ozone Depleting Substances and High-GWP Foam", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater, LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 19376, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 19376 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR2257", "Project Name": "Tradewater ODS 66", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ECY Compliance Offset Protocol: Ozone Depleting Substances Projects (ODS)", "Country": "United States", "State": "OHIO", "Project Site Location": "East Liverpool", "Project Developer": "Tradewater LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 87092, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2025": 87092 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "unclear", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Tradewater, LLC", "value_b": "Tradewater LLC" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / OHIO / East Liverpool", "value_b": "United States / OHIO / East Liverpool" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "value_b": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction" } ], "differences": [ "Different project names/numbers (Tradewater US - ODS - #13 vs Tradewater ODS 66)", "Different methodologies (ACR Destruction of ODS vs ECY Compliance Offset Protocol ODS)", "Different registries (ACR vs CAR)" ], "reason": "Both records share developer (Tradewater, LLC), country / state / site (United States / OHIO / East Liverpool), scope / type (Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction).", "reason_from_model": false, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "ACR0184~CAR995", "a": "ACR0184", "b": "CAR995", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.7929, "name_sim": 0.6235, "overlap_vintages": [ 2013 ], "overlap_volume": 122800, "verdict": "unclear", "confidence": 0.5, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0184", "Project Name": "EOS ACR 2013", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances Banks", "Country": "United States", "State": "ARKANSAS", "Project Site Location": "El Dorado", "Project Developer": "EOS Climate Inc", "Total Credits Issued": 249025, "Total Credits Retired": 249025, "issued_by_vintage": { "2013": 249025 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR995", "Project Name": "EOS ARB ODS 2013-3", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances Banks", "Country": "United States", "State": "ARKANSAS", "Project Site Location": "El Dorado", "Project Developer": "EOS Climate Inc.", "Total Credits Issued": 122800, "Total Credits Retired": 122800, "issued_by_vintage": { "2013": 122800 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "unclear", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "EOS Climate Inc", "value_b": "EOS Climate Inc." }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / ARKANSAS / El Dorado", "value_b": "United States / ARKANSAS / El Dorado" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "value_b": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances Banks", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances Banks" } ], "differences": [ "ACR name: 'EOS ACR 2013' vs CAR name: 'EOS ARB ODS 2013-3'", "ACR is a single project; CAR is one of multiple numbered sub-projects (2013-1, 2013-3, 2013-5)" ], "reason": "Both records share developer (EOS Climate Inc), country / state / site (United States / ARKANSAS / El Dorado), scope / type (Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction), methodology (ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances Banks).", "reason_from_model": false, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "ACR0184~CAR1000", "a": "ACR0184", "b": "CAR1000", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.7912, "name_sim": 0.6204, "overlap_vintages": [ 2013 ], "overlap_volume": 126155, "verdict": "unclear", "confidence": 0.5, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0184", "Project Name": "EOS ACR 2013", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances Banks", "Country": "United States", "State": "ARKANSAS", "Project Site Location": "El Dorado", "Project Developer": "EOS Climate Inc", "Total Credits Issued": 249025, "Total Credits Retired": 249025, "issued_by_vintage": { "2013": 249025 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR1000", "Project Name": "EOS ARB ODS 2013-5", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Chemical Processes", "Type": "Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances Banks", "Country": "United States", "State": "ARKANSAS", "Project Site Location": "El Dorado", "Project Developer": "EOS Climate Inc.", "Total Credits Issued": 126155, "Total Credits Retired": 126155, "issued_by_vintage": { "2013": 126155 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "unclear", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "EOS Climate Inc", "value_b": "EOS Climate Inc." }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "United States / ARKANSAS / El Dorado", "value_b": "United States / ARKANSAS / El Dorado" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction", "value_b": "Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances Banks", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances Banks" } ], "differences": [ "ACR name: 'EOS ACR 2013' vs CAR name: 'EOS ARB ODS 2013-5'", "ACR is a single project; CAR is one of multiple numbered sub-projects (2013-1, 2013-3, 2013-5)" ], "reason": "Both records share developer (EOS Climate Inc), country / state / site (United States / ARKANSAS / El Dorado), scope / type (Chemical Processes / Ozone Depleting Substances Recovery & Destruction), methodology (ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: Destruction of U.S. Ozone Depleting Substances Banks).", "reason_from_model": false, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "GS12292~VCS4229", "a": "GS12292", "b": "VCS4229", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.7899, "name_sim": 0.9211, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.95, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS12292", "Project Name": "Renew Sakhi Improved Cookstove", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Design", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": null, "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Renew Power Synergy Private Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 0, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": {}, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS4229", "Project Name": "RENEW SAKHI - IMPROVED COOKSTOVES - 01", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "VMR0006 Energy Efficiency and Fuel Switch Measures in Thermal Applications", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "ReNew Power Synergy Private Limited (PP)", "Total Credits Issued": 205769, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2023": 114100, "2024": 91669 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Renew Power Synergy Private Limited", "value_b": "ReNew Power Synergy Private Limited (PP)" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Household & Community / Cookstoves", "value_b": "Household & Community / Cookstoves" } ], "differences": [ "Registry: GOLD vs VCS", "Name: 'Renew Sakhi Improved Cookstove' vs 'RENEW SAKHI - IMPROVED COOKSTOVES - 01'", "GS lacks explicit methodology field; VCS lists VMR0006" ], "reason": "Same developer (ReNew Power Synergy Private Limited), country, scope, and technology (improved cookstoves PoA in rural India) confirm the same programme despite minor name variation.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "CAR920~VCS638", "a": "CAR920", "b": "VCS638", "registry_a": "CAR", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.7844, "name_sim": 0.7898, "overlap_vintages": [ 2012, 2013, 2014 ], "overlap_volume": 31543, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "CAR920", "Project Name": "Rockingham County NC Landfill Gas Project", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Completed", "Scope": "Waste Management", "Type": "Landfill Methane", "Methodology / Protocol": "CAR U.S. Landfill Protocol", "Country": "United States", "State": "NORTH CAROLINA", "Project Site Location": "Rockingham County, NC", "Project Developer": "Rockingham County", "Total Credits Issued": 31543, "Total Credits Retired": 13203, "issued_by_vintage": { "2012": 8640, "2013": 19181, "2014": 3722 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS638", "Project Name": "Rockingham County Landfill Gas Combustion Project", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Waste Management", "Type": "Landfill Methane", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0001 Flaring or use of landfill gas", "Country": "United States", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Rockingham County", "Total Credits Issued": 343139, "Total Credits Retired": 252268, "issued_by_vintage": { "2010": 23850, "2011": 29857, "2012": 41249, "2013": 33058, "2014": 33400, "2015": 66682, "2016": 20260, "2017": 16338, "2018": 12345, "2019": 17376, "2020": 13502, "2021": 8712, "2022": 8788, "2023": 17722 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Rockingham County", "value_b": "Rockingham County" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Waste Management / Landfill Methane", "value_b": "Waste Management / Landfill Methane" }, { "field": "Country", "value_a": "United States", "value_b": "United States" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: CAR CAR920 vs VCS VCS638", "Name: Rockingham County NC Landfill Gas Project vs Rockingham County Landfill Gas Combustion Project", "Methodology: CAR U.S. Landfill Protocol vs ACM0001 Flaring or use of landfill gas", "Status: Completed vs Registered" ], "reason": "Both listings describe a Waste Management / Landfill Methane project developed by Rockingham County in the United States.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "GS12293~VCS4229", "a": "GS12293", "b": "VCS4229", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.7841, "name_sim": 0.9105, "overlap_vintages": [ 2023 ], "overlap_volume": 100701, "verdict": "unclear", "confidence": 0.5, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS12293", "Project Name": "Renew Sakhi Improved Cookstove - 2", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": null, "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Renew Power Synergy Private Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 100701, "Total Credits Retired": 65768, "issued_by_vintage": { "2023": 100701 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS4229", "Project Name": "RENEW SAKHI - IMPROVED COOKSTOVES - 01", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "VMR0006 Energy Efficiency and Fuel Switch Measures in Thermal Applications", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "ReNew Power Synergy Private Limited (PP)", "Total Credits Issued": 205769, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2023": 114100, "2024": 91669 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "unclear", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Renew Power Synergy Private Limited", "value_b": "ReNew Power Synergy Private Limited (PP)" }, { "field": "Country", "value_a": "India", "value_b": "India" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Household & Community / Cookstoves", "value_b": "Household & Community / Cookstoves" } ], "differences": [ "GS12293 is phase/component '-2'; VCS4229 is component '-01'", "GS12293 mentions 42,000 households in Bihar; VCS4229 has no household count listed", "GS12293 uses no listed VCS methodology; VCS4229 uses VMR0006" ], "reason": "Both records share developer (Renew Power Synergy Private Limited), country (India), scope / type (Household & Community / Cookstoves).", "reason_from_model": false, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "GS7621~VCS701", "a": "GS7621", "b": "VCS701", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.7514, "name_sim": 0.9117, "overlap_vintages": [], "overlap_volume": 0, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.95, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS7621", "Project Name": "50.6 MW Wind Power Project in Gujarat by Powerica Limited", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": null, "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Powerica Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 262301, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2023": 132445, "2024": 129856 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS701", "Project Name": "Wind power project at Gujarat by Powerica Limited", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-I.D. Grid connected renewable electricity generation", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "POWERICA LIMITED (PP)", "Total Credits Issued": 244452, "Total Credits Retired": 244452, "issued_by_vintage": { "2010": 16388, "2013": 23415, "2014": 22222, "2015": 24722, "2016": 24079, "2017": 25163, "2018": 24926, "2019": 23052, "2020": 18915, "2021": 21273, "2022": 20297 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Powerica Limited", "value_b": "POWERICA LIMITED (PP)" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Wind", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Wind" } ], "differences": [ "Registry: GOLD vs VCS", "Name: '50.6 MW Wind Power Project in Gujarat by Powerica Limited' vs 'Wind power project at Gujarat by Powerica Limited'", "GS lacks explicit methodology field; VCS lists AMS-I.D." ], "reason": "Both records share developer (Powerica Limited), country / state / site (India / None / None), scope / type (Renewable Energy / Wind).", "reason_from_model": false, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "GS4426~VCS412", "a": "GS4426", "b": "VCS412", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.7451, "name_sim": 0.8395, "overlap_vintages": [ 2014, 2015, 2016, 2017, 2018, 2019, 2020, 2021 ], "overlap_volume": 615731, "verdict": "unclear", "confidence": 0.55, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS4426", "Project Name": "Wind Energy Project in Gujarat", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Wind World (India) Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 1040870, "Total Credits Retired": 326581, "issued_by_vintage": { "2014": 65197, "2015": 96753, "2016": 79666, "2017": 150931, "2018": 186142, "2019": 181908, "2020": 136864, "2021": 78679, "2022": 64730 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS412", "Project Name": "Bundled wind energy generation projects in Gujarat, India", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Wind World (India) Ltd. (PP)", "Total Credits Issued": 1259773, "Total Credits Retired": 1259773, "issued_by_vintage": { "2007": 78044, "2008": 91086, "2009": 90023, "2010": 84799, "2011": 97416, "2012": 89731, "2013": 86166, "2014": 84832, "2015": 94502, "2016": 86060, "2017": 76761, "2018": 77454, "2019": 81308, "2020": 62164, "2021": 79427 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "unclear", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Wind World (India) Limited", "value_b": "Wind World (India) Ltd. (PP)" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Wind", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Wind" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "value_b": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources" } ], "differences": [ "GS4426 is a single 50.4 MW project; VCS412 is a bundled project", "GS4426 specifies Kutch and Jamnagar districts; VCS412 site unspecified", "Registry: GOLD vs VCS" ], "reason": "Both records share developer (Wind World (India) Limited), country / state / site (India / None / None), scope / type (Renewable Energy / Wind), methodology (ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources).", "reason_from_model": false, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false }, { "id": "GS11210~VCS2673", "a": "GS11210", "b": "VCS2673", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "Nigeria", "screen_score": 0.7288, "name_sim": 0.81, "overlap_vintages": [ 2024 ], "overlap_volume": 6687, "verdict": "unclear", "confidence": 0.5, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS11210", "Project Name": "UpEnergy-Social and Climate Impact Programme- Cooking Devices VPA-8", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": null, "Country": "Nigeria", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "UpEnergy Group", "Total Credits Issued": 31969, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2024": 6687, "2025": 25282 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS2673", "Project Name": "UpEnergy-Social and Climate Impact Programme- Nigeria-1", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Verification approval requested", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "VM0050 Energy Efficiency and Fuel-Switch Measures in Cookstoves", "Country": "Nigeria", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "UpEnergy Group (PP)", "Total Credits Issued": 41647, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2022": 4812, "2023": 20067, "2024": 16768 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "unclear", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "UpEnergy Group", "value_b": "UpEnergy Group (PP)" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "Nigeria / None / None", "value_b": "Nigeria / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Household & Community / Cookstoves", "value_b": "Household & Community / Cookstoves" } ], "differences": [ "GS name: 'VPA-8'; VCS name: 'Nigeria-1'", "GS methodology not listed; VCS methodology: VM0050", "GS is a VPA under a PoA; VCS appears to be a standalone project" ], "reason": "Both records share developer (UpEnergy Group), country / state / site (Nigeria / None / None), scope / type (Household & Community / Cookstoves).", "reason_from_model": false, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "GS11647~VCS2789", "a": "GS11647", "b": "VCS2789", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "Uganda", "screen_score": 0.7077, "name_sim": 0.7716, "overlap_vintages": [ 2022, 2023 ], "overlap_volume": 7732, "verdict": "unclear", "confidence": 0.5, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS11647", "Project Name": "UpEnergy-Social and Climate Impact Programme- Cooking Devices VPA-15", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "GS TPDDTEC Reduced emissions from cooking and heating – technologies and practices to displace decentralized thermal energy consumption", "Country": "Uganda", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "UpEnergy Group", "Total Credits Issued": 7732, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2022": 1082, "2023": 6650 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS2789", "Project Name": "UpEnergy-Social and Climate Impact Programme-Uganda 1", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "VMR0006 Energy Efficiency and Fuel Switch Measures in Thermal Applications", "Country": "Uganda", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "UpEnergy Group (PP)", "Total Credits Issued": 383201, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2022": 74774, "2023": 184854, "2024": 123573 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "unclear", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "UpEnergy Group", "value_b": "UpEnergy Group (PP)" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "Uganda / None / None", "value_b": "Uganda / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Household & Community / Cookstoves", "value_b": "Household & Community / Cookstoves" } ], "differences": [ "GS name: 'VPA-15'; VCS name: 'Uganda 1'", "GS methodology: GS TPDDTEC; VCS methodology: VMR0006", "GS is a VPA under a PoA; VCS appears to be a standalone project" ], "reason": "Both records share developer (UpEnergy Group), country / state / site (Uganda / None / None), scope / type (Household & Community / Cookstoves).", "reason_from_model": false, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "GS12020~VCS3160", "a": "GS12020", "b": "VCS3160", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.7056, "name_sim": 0.7375, "overlap_vintages": [ 2022 ], "overlap_volume": 15317, "verdict": "unclear", "confidence": 0.55, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS12020", "Project Name": "Smokeless energy efficient cookstoves distribution in rural India-4", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "GS TPDDTEC Reduced emissions from cooking and heating – technologies and practices to displace decentralized thermal energy consumption", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "GRENEITY INFOCOM SERVICE PRIVATE LIMITED", "Total Credits Issued": 116038, "Total Credits Retired": 69499, "issued_by_vintage": { "2022": 15317, "2023": 43070, "2024": 37081, "2025": 20570 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS3160", "Project Name": "Distribution of energy efficient cookstoves in India-4", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Withdrawn", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "VMR0006 Energy Efficiency and Fuel Switch Measures in Thermal Applications", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Greneity Infocom Service Pvt Ltd (PP)", "Total Credits Issued": 99737, "Total Credits Retired": 63273, "issued_by_vintage": { "2021": 49619, "2022": 50118 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "unclear", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "GRENEITY INFOCOM SERVICE PRIVATE LIMITED", "value_b": "Greneity Infocom Service Pvt Ltd (PP)" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Household & Community / Cookstoves", "value_b": "Household & Community / Cookstoves" } ], "differences": [ "GS name: 'Rural India-4'; VCS name: 'India-4'", "GS methodology: GS TPDDTEC; VCS methodology: VMR0006", "GS registry: GOLD; VCS registry: VCS" ], "reason": "Both are numbered '-4' cookstove distribution programmes in India by the same developer (Greneity Infocom Service), suggesting they may be the same programme registered under both standards, but different methodologies and naming conventions prevent certainty.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false }, { "id": "GS12018~VCS3158", "a": "GS12018", "b": "VCS3158", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.705, "name_sim": 0.7364, "overlap_vintages": [ 2022 ], "overlap_volume": 17574, "verdict": "unclear", "confidence": 0.55, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS12018", "Project Name": "Smokeless Energy efficient cookstoves distribution in Rural India-2", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "GS TPDDTEC Reduced emissions from cooking and heating – technologies and practices to displace decentralized thermal energy consumption", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "GRENEITY INFOCOM SERVICE PRIVATE LIMITED", "Total Credits Issued": 103458, "Total Credits Retired": 85174, "issued_by_vintage": { "2022": 17574, "2023": 34528, "2024": 33202, "2025": 18154 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS3158", "Project Name": "Distribution of energy efficient cookstoves in India-2", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Withdrawn", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "VMR0006 Energy Efficiency and Fuel Switch Measures in Thermal Applications", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Greneity Infocom Service Pvt Ltd (PP)", "Total Credits Issued": 243104, "Total Credits Retired": 128631, "issued_by_vintage": { "2021": 97394, "2022": 145710 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "unclear", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "GRENEITY INFOCOM SERVICE PRIVATE LIMITED", "value_b": "Greneity Infocom Service Pvt Ltd (PP)" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Household & Community / Cookstoves", "value_b": "Household & Community / Cookstoves" } ], "differences": [ "GS name: 'Rural India-2'; VCS name: 'India-2'", "GS methodology: GS TPDDTEC; VCS methodology: VMR0006", "GS registry: GOLD; VCS registry: VCS" ], "reason": "Both are numbered '-2' cookstove distribution programmes in India by the same developer (Greneity Infocom Service), suggesting they may be the same programme registered under both standards, but the different numbering conventions and methodologies prevent certainty.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false }, { "id": "GS7754~VCS924", "a": "GS7754", "b": "VCS924", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.7, "name_sim": 1, "overlap_vintages": [ 2018 ], "overlap_volume": 19229, "verdict": "unclear", "confidence": 0.55, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS7754", "Project Name": "Tuppadahalli Wind Energy Project", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": null, "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Kosher Climate India Pvt Ltd.", "Total Credits Issued": 323794, "Total Credits Retired": 105716, "issued_by_vintage": { "2018": 50850, "2019": 116337, "2020": 107198, "2021": 49409 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS924", "Project Name": "Tuppadahalli Wind Energy Project", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Withdrawn", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Tuppadahalli Energy India Pvt. Ltd. (PP)", "Total Credits Issued": 798247, "Total Credits Retired": 798105, "issued_by_vintage": { "2012": 165964, "2013": 134330, "2014": 122000, "2015": 111670, "2016": 126066, "2017": 118988, "2018": 19229 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "unclear", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Tuppadahalli Wind Energy Project", "value_b": "Tuppadahalli Wind Energy Project" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Wind", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Wind" }, { "field": "Registry", "value_a": "GOLD", "value_b": "VCS" } ], "differences": [ "Developer: Kosher Climate India Pvt Ltd. vs Tuppadahalli Energy India Pvt. Ltd.", "GS listing describes 56.1 MW from 34 WTGs; VCS capacity not stated", "GS methodology not listed; VCS uses ACM0002" ], "reason": "Both list the identical project name 'Tuppadahalli Wind Energy Project' in India with the same scope (Wind), but the developers differ (Kosher Climate India Pvt Ltd. vs Tuppadahalli Energy India Pvt. Ltd.), leaving open whether this is a name/ownership change or a distinct project.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false }, { "id": "GS6832~VCS1784", "a": "GS6832", "b": "VCS1784", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.6977, "name_sim": 0.9231, "overlap_vintages": [ 2019, 2020 ], "overlap_volume": 71348, "verdict": "unclear", "confidence": 0.65, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS6832", "Project Name": "50 MW Solar Power Project by Mytrah Energy India Private Limited", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Solar - Centralized", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "MYTRAH ENERGY (INDIA) PRIVATE LIMITED", "Total Credits Issued": 71348, "Total Credits Retired": 13173, "issued_by_vintage": { "2019": 20093, "2020": 51255 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS1784", "Project Name": "Solar Power Project by Mytrah Energy India Private Limited", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Verification approval requested", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Solar - Centralized", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "JSW NEO ENERGY LIMITED (PP)", "Total Credits Issued": 3141114, "Total Credits Retired": 1515492, "issued_by_vintage": { "2017": 33067, "2018": 390627, "2019": 578461, "2020": 617428, "2021": 633723, "2022": 544516, "2023": 343292 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "unclear", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name (reference)", "value_a": "50 MW Solar Power Project by Mytrah Energy India Private Limited", "value_b": "Solar Power Project by Mytrah Energy India Private Limited" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Solar - Centralized", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Solar - Centralized" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "value_b": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources" }, { "field": "Country", "value_a": "India", "value_b": "India" } ], "differences": [ "GS6832 developer is MYTRAH ENERGY (INDIA) PRIVATE LIMITED; VCS1784 developer is JSW NEO ENERGY LIMITED", "GS6832 specifies 50 MW capacity at Nizamabad, Telangana; VCS1784 has no capacity or site detail listed" ], "reason": "Both records share name (reference) (50 MW Solar Power Project by Mytrah Energy India Private Limited), scope / type (Renewable Energy / Solar - Centralized), methodology (ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources), country (India).", "reason_from_model": false, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "GS7629~VCS2243", "a": "GS7629", "b": "VCS2243", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.689, "name_sim": 0.98, "overlap_vintages": [ 2018, 2019 ], "overlap_volume": 38137, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.95, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS7629", "Project Name": "Wind power project in Madhya Pradesh (2) India", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Orange Renewable Power Pvt Ltd", "Total Credits Issued": 270342, "Total Credits Retired": 2254, "issued_by_vintage": { "2018": 1340, "2019": 69558, "2020": 61762, "2021": 70737, "2022": 66945 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS2243", "Project Name": "Wind power project in Madhya Pradesh, India", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Late to Verify", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Ratedi Wind Power Private Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 125737, "Total Credits Retired": 125737, "issued_by_vintage": { "2016": 6729, "2017": 39311, "2018": 42900, "2019": 36797 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Wind", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Wind" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "value_b": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS7629 vs VCS VCS2243", "Developer: Orange Renewable Power Pvt Ltd vs Ratedi Wind Power Private Limited", "Status: Gold Standard Certified Project vs Late to verify", "Credits issued by vintage: 2018:1340, 2019:69558, 2020:61762, 2021:70737, 2022:66945 vs 2016:6729, 2017:39311, 2018:4290" ], "reason": "Both listings describe a Renewable Energy / Wind project using Methodology ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources in India / None / None.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "GS12302~VCS2944", "a": "GS12302", "b": "VCS2944", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.6729, "name_sim": 0.678, "overlap_vintages": [ 2022, 2023 ], "overlap_volume": 467233, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.88, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS12302", "Project Name": "Clean Cooking Program in Rural India", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": null, "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "EKI Energy Services Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 511108, "Total Credits Retired": 398183, "issued_by_vintage": { "2022": 4087, "2023": 463146, "2024": 43875 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS2944", "Project Name": "Clean Cookstoves for Rural India", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Verification approval requested", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "VM0050 Energy Efficiency and Fuel-Switch Measures in Cookstoves; VMR0006 Energy Efficiency and Fuel Switch Measures in Thermal Applications", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "EKI Energy Services Limited (PP)", "Total Credits Issued": 870015, "Total Credits Retired": 870015, "issued_by_vintage": { "2022": 164300, "2023": 705715 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "EKI Energy Services Limited", "value_b": "EKI Energy Services Limited (PP)" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Household & Community / Cookstoves", "value_b": "Household & Community / Cookstoves" } ], "differences": [ "Registry: GOLD vs VCS", "Name: 'Clean Cooking Program in Rural India' vs 'Clean Cookstoves for Rural India'", "Methodology not provided in GS12302; VCS2944 uses VM0050 and VMR0006" ], "reason": "Both listings share the same developer (EKI Energy Services Limited), the same country (India), the same scope (cookstoves), and very similar names describing clean cooking programs in rural India, indicating the same physical programme.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "CAR509~VCS1888", "a": "CAR509", "b": "VCS1888", "registry_a": "CAR", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.6653, "name_sim": 0.8764, "overlap_vintages": [ 2019 ], "overlap_volume": 2635, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "CAR509", "Project Name": "Larimer County Landfill Gas Project", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Waste Management", "Type": "Landfill Methane", "Methodology / Protocol": "CAR U.S. Landfill Protocol", "Country": "United States", "State": "COLORADO", "Project Site Location": "Larimer County, Colorado", "Project Developer": "Larimer Energy, LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 184522, "Total Credits Retired": 165932, "issued_by_vintage": { "2009": 3408, "2010": 17110, "2011": 16616, "2012": 17024, "2013": 18452, "2014": 19036, "2015": 18232, "2019": 2635, "2020": 17907, "2021": 16757, "2022": 18584, "2023": 11398, "2024": 7363 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS1888", "Project Name": "Larimer County Landfill Gas Flaring Project", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Late to Verify", "Scope": "Waste Management", "Type": "Landfill Methane", "Methodology / Protocol": "Methodology Under Development", "Country": "United States", "State": "COLORADO", "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "3Degrees Group, Inc..", "Total Credits Issued": 84910, "Total Credits Retired": 84910, "issued_by_vintage": { "2016": 22201, "2017": 24510, "2018": 21923, "2019": 16276 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "unclear", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Country / State", "value_a": "United States / COLORADO", "value_b": "United States / COLORADO" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Waste Management / Landfill Methane", "value_b": "Waste Management / Landfill Methane" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: CAR CAR509 vs VCS VCS1888", "Name: Larimer County Landfill Gas Project vs Larimer County Landfill Gas Flaring Project", "Developer: Larimer Energy, LLC vs 3Degrees Group, Inc..", "Methodology: CAR U.S. Landfill Protocol vs Methodology Under Development" ], "reason": "While both listings describe a Waste Management / Landfill Methane project in United States / COLORADO, they differ in Registry / ID, Name, Developer, and Methodology.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false }, { "id": "GS7469~VCS701", "a": "GS7469", "b": "VCS701", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.6369, "name_sim": 0.7034, "overlap_vintages": [ 2019, 2020, 2021, 2022 ], "overlap_volume": 83537, "verdict": "unclear", "confidence": 0.5, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS7469", "Project Name": "50.6 MW Wind Energy Project by Powerica Limited", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": null, "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Powerica Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 745400, "Total Credits Retired": 278141, "issued_by_vintage": { "2019": 92074, "2020": 131169, "2021": 136167, "2022": 127598, "2023": 134641, "2024": 123751 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS701", "Project Name": "Wind power project at Gujarat by Powerica Limited", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-I.D. Grid connected renewable electricity generation", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "POWERICA LIMITED (PP)", "Total Credits Issued": 244452, "Total Credits Retired": 244452, "issued_by_vintage": { "2010": 16388, "2013": 23415, "2014": 22222, "2015": 24722, "2016": 24079, "2017": 25163, "2018": 24926, "2019": 23052, "2020": 18915, "2021": 21273, "2022": 20297 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "unclear", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Powerica Limited", "value_b": "POWERICA LIMITED (PP)" }, { "field": "Country", "value_a": "India", "value_b": "India" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Wind", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Wind" } ], "differences": [ "GS7469 is 50.6 MW; VCS701 capacity not listed", "GS7469 uses no listed CDM methodology; VCS701 uses AMS-I.D.", "GS7469 description references Indian grid broadly; VCS701 is specifically Gujarat" ], "reason": "Both records share developer (Powerica Limited), country (India), scope / type (Renewable Energy / Wind).", "reason_from_model": false, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "GS7620~VCS701", "a": "GS7620", "b": "VCS701", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.6352, "name_sim": 0.7004, "overlap_vintages": [ 2020, 2021, 2022 ], "overlap_volume": 60485, "verdict": "unclear", "confidence": 0.6, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS7620", "Project Name": "50.6 MW Wind Power Project at Umrali Gujarat by Powerica Limited", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": null, "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Powerica Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 601565, "Total Credits Retired": 133982, "issued_by_vintage": { "2020": 27935, "2021": 149587, "2022": 141870, "2023": 147078, "2024": 135095 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS701", "Project Name": "Wind power project at Gujarat by Powerica Limited", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-I.D. Grid connected renewable electricity generation", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "POWERICA LIMITED (PP)", "Total Credits Issued": 244452, "Total Credits Retired": 244452, "issued_by_vintage": { "2010": 16388, "2013": 23415, "2014": 22222, "2015": 24722, "2016": 24079, "2017": 25163, "2018": 24926, "2019": 23052, "2020": 18915, "2021": 21273, "2022": 20297 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "unclear", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Powerica Limited", "value_b": "POWERICA LIMITED (PP)" }, { "field": "Country / State", "value_a": "India", "value_b": "India" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Wind", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Wind" } ], "differences": [ "GS7620 is 50.6 MW at Umrali, Gujarat; VCS701 has no capacity or specific site listed", "GS7620 uses no listed CDM methodology; VCS701 uses AMS-I.D." ], "reason": "Both records share developer (Powerica Limited), country / state (India), scope / type (Renewable Energy / Wind).", "reason_from_model": false, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "GS7664~VCS2059", "a": "GS7664", "b": "VCS2059", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.6292, "name_sim": 0.7501, "overlap_vintages": [ 2021, 2022 ], "overlap_volume": 460154, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS7664", "Project Name": "250 MW Solar PV Plant by Mahindra Renewables in Rajasthan", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Solar - Centralized", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Mahindra Susten Private Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 867303, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2021": 287677, "2022": 579626 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS2059", "Project Name": "Renewable Solar Power Project by Mahindra Renewables Private Limited", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Solar - Centralized", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Mahindra Renewables Private Limited.", "Total Credits Issued": 1355158, "Total Credits Retired": 637611, "issued_by_vintage": { "2018": 23196, "2019": 228222, "2020": 464178, "2021": 467085, "2022": 172477 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Mahindra Susten Private Limited", "value_b": "Mahindra Renewables Private Limited" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Solar - Centralized", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Solar - Centralized" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "value_b": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS7664 vs VCS VCS2059", "Name: 250 MW Solar PV Plant by Mahindra Renewables in Rajasthan vs Renewable Solar Power Project by Mahindra Renewables", "Status: Gold Standard Certified Project vs Registered", "Credits issued by vintage: 2021:287677, 2022:579626 vs 2018:23196, 2019:228222, 2020:464178, 2021:467085, 2022:172477" ], "reason": "Both listings describe a Renewable Energy / Solar - Centralized project in India using Methodology ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources developed by Mahindra Renewables.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "GS7532~VCS1805", "a": "GS7532", "b": "VCS1805", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.6267, "name_sim": 0.7213, "overlap_vintages": [ 2019, 2020, 2021, 2022, 2023 ], "overlap_volume": 2020932, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS7532", "Project Name": "200 MW solar power project in India by SB Energy.", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Solar - Centralized", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Adani Green Energy Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 2020932, "Total Credits Retired": 1120771, "issued_by_vintage": { "2019": 228168, "2020": 463807, "2021": 459836, "2022": 421244, "2023": 447877 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS1805", "Project Name": "Solar Energy Project(s) by SB Energy Private Limited", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Solar - Centralized", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Adani Renewable Energy Devco Private Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 9446114, "Total Credits Retired": 6611931, "issued_by_vintage": { "2017": 521071, "2018": 810552, "2019": 626090, "2020": 1519558, "2021": 1877353, "2022": 2514594, "2023": 1576896 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "no", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Solar - Centralized", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Solar - Centralized" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "value_b": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS7532 vs VCS VCS1805", "Name: 200 MW solar power project in India by SB Energy vs Solar Energy Project(s) by SB Energy Private Limited", "Developer: Adani Green Energy Limited vs Adani Renewable Energy Devco Private Limited", "Credits issued by vintage: 2019:228168, 2020:463807, 2021:459836, 2022:421244, 2023:447877 vs 2017:521071, 2018:810552, " ], "reason": "The listings have different Registry / IDs, Developers, and Credits issued by vintage.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "GS4426~VCS1081", "a": "GS4426", "b": "VCS1081", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.621, "name_sim": 0.6745, "overlap_vintages": [ 2014, 2015, 2016, 2017, 2018, 2019, 2020, 2021, 2022 ], "overlap_volume": 147534, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.9, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS4426", "Project Name": "Wind Energy Project in Gujarat", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Wind World (India) Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 1040870, "Total Credits Retired": 326581, "issued_by_vintage": { "2014": 65197, "2015": 96753, "2016": 79666, "2017": 150931, "2018": 186142, "2019": 181908, "2020": 136864, "2021": 78679, "2022": 64730 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS1081", "Project Name": "Clean Energy Generation in Gujarat, India", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-I.D. Grid connected renewable electricity generation", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Wind World Wind Resources Development Private Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 188634, "Total Credits Retired": 188634, "issued_by_vintage": { "2011": 4855, "2012": 20515, "2013": 15730, "2014": 17560, "2015": 20088, "2016": 16127, "2017": 16096, "2018": 17863, "2019": 19248, "2020": 14979, "2021": 16700, "2022": 8873 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "no", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Wind", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Wind" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS4426 vs VCS VCS1081", "Name: Wind Energy Project in Gujarat vs Clean Energy Generation in Gujarat, India", "Developer: Wind World (India) Limited vs Wind World Wind Resources Development Private Limited", "Methodology: ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources vs AMS-I.D. Grid connected renewableসর" ], "reason": "The listings have different Registry IDs, Developers, and Methodologies.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false }, { "id": "GS607~VCS1703", "a": "GS607", "b": "VCS1703", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "China", "screen_score": 0.621, "name_sim": 0.8563, "overlap_vintages": [ 2010 ], "overlap_volume": 722, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": true, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS607", "Project Name": "The 2nd 45MW Wind-farm project of Huadian Ningxia Ningdong Yangjiayao", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "China", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Climate Impact Partners Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 49420, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2010": 49420 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS1703", "Project Name": "Huadian Ningxia Ningdong Yangjiayao 45MW Wind-farm Project - CER Conversion", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Units transferred from approved GHG program", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "China", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Credits transferred from approved GHG program", "Total Credits Issued": 722, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2010": 722 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "China / None / None", "value_b": "China / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Wind", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Wind" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "value_b": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources" }, { "field": "Credits issued by vintage", "value_a": "2010:49420", "value_b": "2010:722" }, { "field": "Name", "value_a": "The 2nd 45MW Wind-farm project of Huadian Ningxia Ningdong Yangjiayao", "value_b": "Huadian Ningxia Ningdong Yangjiayao 45MW Wind-farm Project - CER Conversion" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS607 vs VCS VCS1703", "Developer: Climate Impact Partners Limited vs Credits transferred from approved GHG program", "Status: Gold Standard Certified Project vs Units Transferred from Approved GHG Program", "Description: [Present in A] vs [Missing in B]" ], "reason": "Both records share country / state / site (China / None / None), scope / type (Renewable Energy / Wind), methodology (ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources), credits issued by vintage (2010:49420).", "reason_from_model": false, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "GS12302~VCS2942", "a": "GS12302", "b": "VCS2942", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.6206, "name_sim": 0.8556, "overlap_vintages": [ 2022 ], "overlap_volume": 4087, "verdict": "unclear", "confidence": 0.45, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS12302", "Project Name": "Clean Cooking Program in Rural India", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": null, "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "EKI Energy Services Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 511108, "Total Credits Retired": 398183, "issued_by_vintage": { "2022": 4087, "2023": 463146, "2024": 43875 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS2942", "Project Name": "Clean Cooking - Cook Stove for Rural India", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Verification approval requested", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "VMR0006 Energy Efficiency and Fuel Switch Measures in Thermal Applications", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Multiple Project Proponents", "Total Credits Issued": 148546, "Total Credits Retired": 12575, "issued_by_vintage": { "2022": 148546 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "unclear", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Household & Community / Cookstoves", "value_b": "Household & Community / Cookstoves" } ], "differences": [ "GS developer: EKI Energy Services Limited; VCS developer: Multiple Project Proponents", "GS specifies Assam and Madhya Pradesh; VCS states no specific states", "GS methodology not listed; VCS methodology: VMR0006" ], "reason": "Both records share country / state / site (India / None / None), scope / type (Household & Community / Cookstoves).", "reason_from_model": false, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": false }, { "id": "ACR0377~CAR1368", "a": "ACR0377", "b": "CAR1368", "registry_a": "ACR", "registry_b": "CAR", "country": "United States", "screen_score": 0.6142, "name_sim": 0.7076, "overlap_vintages": [ 2019, 2020 ], "overlap_volume": 22878, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 0.88, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "ACR0377", "Project Name": "Cappell Creek Improved Forest Management Project", "Voluntary Registry": "ACR", "Voluntary Status": "Transferred ARB Project", "Scope": "Forestry & Land Use", "Type": "Improved Forest Management", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: U.S. Forest Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "CALIFORNIA", "Project Site Location": "Humboldt County, CA", "Project Developer": "California Timberlands 2 LLC", "Total Credits Issued": 327740, "Total Credits Retired": 332948, "issued_by_vintage": { "2017": 302769, "2018": 2093, "2019": 2093, "2020": 20785 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "CAR1368", "Project Name": "Pine Creek Improved Forest Management Project", "Voluntary Registry": "CAR", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Forestry & Land Use", "Type": "Improved Forest Management", "Methodology / Protocol": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: U.S. Forest Projects", "Country": "United States", "State": "CALIFORNIA", "Project Site Location": "Humboldt County", "Project Developer": "Hoopa Valley Tribe", "Total Credits Issued": 610445, "Total Credits Retired": 362579, "issued_by_vintage": { "2019": 397099, "2020": 20897, "2021": 32831, "2022": 34887, "2023": 35130, "2024": 41023, "2025": 48578 }, "notes": "The project developer through v10 was California Timberlands 2 LLC" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Country / State", "value_a": "United States / CALIFORNIA", "value_b": "United States / CALIFORNIA" }, { "field": "Site", "value_a": "Humboldt County, CA", "value_b": "Humboldt County" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Forestry & Land Use / Improved Forest Management", "value_b": "Forestry & Land Use / Improved Forest Management" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: U.S. Forest Projects", "value_b": "ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: U.S. Forest Projects" }, { "field": "Developer (historical)", "value_a": "California Timberlands 2 LLC", "value_b": "California Timberlands 2 LLC" } ], "differences": [ "Different project names (Cappell Creek vs Pine Creek)", "Current developer differs (California Timberlands 2 LLC vs Hoopa Valley Tribe)", "Different registries (ACR vs CAR)" ], "reason": "Both records share country / state (United States / CALIFORNIA), site (Humboldt County, CA), scope / type (Forestry & Land Use / Improved Forest Management), methodology (ARB Compliance Offset Protocol: U.S. Forest Projects).", "reason_from_model": false, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "GS7469~VCS1830", "a": "GS7469", "b": "VCS1830", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.6121, "name_sim": 0.6583, "overlap_vintages": [ 2019, 2020, 2021, 2022, 2023 ], "overlap_volume": 68715, "verdict": "unclear", "confidence": 0.5, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS7469", "Project Name": "50.6 MW Wind Energy Project by Powerica Limited", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": null, "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Powerica Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 745400, "Total Credits Retired": 278141, "issued_by_vintage": { "2019": 92074, "2020": 131169, "2021": 136167, "2022": 127598, "2023": 134641, "2024": 123751 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS1830", "Project Name": "Wind Power Project at Theni by Powerica Limited", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-I.D. Grid connected renewable electricity generation", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "POWERICA LIMITED (PP)", "Total Credits Issued": 172406, "Total Credits Retired": 147485, "issued_by_vintage": { "2010": 2722, "2011": 1213, "2012": 752, "2013": 17216, "2014": 15871, "2015": 11353, "2016": 19099, "2017": 18933, "2018": 16532, "2019": 15532, "2020": 15721, "2021": 15598, "2022": 16570, "2023": 5294 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "unclear", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Powerica Limited", "value_b": "POWERICA LIMITED (PP)" }, { "field": "Country", "value_a": "India", "value_b": "India" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Wind", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Wind" } ], "differences": [ "GS7469 is 50.6 MW; VCS1830 capacity not listed", "GS7469 description references Indian grid broadly; VCS1830 is specifically at Theni", "GS7469 uses no listed CDM methodology; VCS1830 uses AMS-I.D." ], "reason": "Both records share developer (Powerica Limited), country (India), scope / type (Renewable Energy / Wind).", "reason_from_model": false, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "GS7469~VCS700", "a": "GS7469", "b": "VCS700", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.5978, "name_sim": 0.6324, "overlap_vintages": [ 2019, 2020, 2021, 2022, 2023 ], "overlap_volume": 121371, "verdict": "unclear", "confidence": 0.58, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS7469", "Project Name": "50.6 MW Wind Energy Project by Powerica Limited", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": null, "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Powerica Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 745400, "Total Credits Retired": 278141, "issued_by_vintage": { "2019": 92074, "2020": 131169, "2021": 136167, "2022": 127598, "2023": 134641, "2024": 123751 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS700", "Project Name": "Wind power project at Tamilnadu by Powerica Limited", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "POWERICA LIMITED (PP)", "Total Credits Issued": 354701, "Total Credits Retired": 276337, "issued_by_vintage": { "2009": 7447, "2010": 38747, "2012": 411, "2013": 28283, "2014": 26219, "2015": 20798, "2016": 37006, "2017": 40700, "2018": 33719, "2019": 31940, "2020": 18398, "2021": 33721, "2022": 29618, "2023": 7694 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "unclear", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Powerica Limited", "value_b": "POWERICA LIMITED (PP)" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Wind", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Wind" } ], "differences": [ "GS7469 does not specify state; VCS700 specifies Tamil Nadu", "Registry: GOLD vs VCS", "GS7469 capacity stated as 50.6 MW; VCS700 capacity not stated in listing" ], "reason": "Both records share developer (Powerica Limited), country / state / site (India / None / None), scope / type (Renewable Energy / Wind).", "reason_from_model": false, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "GS869~VCS1690", "a": "GS869", "b": "VCS1690", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "China", "screen_score": 0.5924, "name_sim": 0.8043, "overlap_vintages": [ 2012 ], "overlap_volume": 12793, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": true, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS869", "Project Name": "Biogas utilization project in Zhejiang Jingxing Paper Joint Stock Co. Ltd.. (300660)", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Waste Management", "Type": "Methane Recovery in Wastewater", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-I.F. Renewable electricity generation for captive use and mini-grid", "Country": "China", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Swiss Carbon Assets Ltd.", "Total Credits Issued": 37246, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2011": 13110, "2012": 24136 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS1690", "Project Name": "Biogas Utilization Project in Zhejiang Jingxing Paper Joint Stock Co. Ltd. - CER Conversion", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Units transferred from approved GHG program", "Scope": "Waste Management", "Type": "Methane Recovery in Wastewater", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-III.H. Methane recovery in wastewater treatment", "Country": "China", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Credits transferred from approved GHG program", "Total Credits Issued": 12793, "Total Credits Retired": 1693, "issued_by_vintage": { "2012": 12793 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Biogas utilization project in Zhejiang Jingxing Paper Joint Stock Co. Ltd.. (300", "value_b": "Biogas Utilization Project in Zhejiang Jingxing Paper Joint Stock Co. Ltd. - CER" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "China / None / None", "value_b": "China / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Waste Management / Methane Recovery in Wastewater", "value_b": "Waste Management / Methane Recovery in Wastewater" }, { "field": "Credits issued by vintage", "value_a": "2012:24136", "value_b": "2012:12793" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS869 vs VCS VCS1690", "Developer: Swiss Carbon Assets Ltd. vs Credits transferred from approved GHG program", "Methodology: AMS-I.F. Renewable electricity generation for captive use and mini-grid vs AMS-III.H. Methane recovery in废水", "Status: Gold Standard Certified Project vs Units Transferred from Approved GHG Program" ], "reason": "Both listings describe a Biogas Utilization Project in Zhejiang Jingxing Paper Joint Stock Co. Ltd. located in China under the Scope of Waste Management / Methane Recovery in Wastewater.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "GS7152~VCS1776", "a": "GS7152", "b": "VCS1776", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.5914, "name_sim": 0.657, "overlap_vintages": [ 2019, 2020, 2021, 2022, 2023, 2024 ], "overlap_volume": 455557, "verdict": "unclear", "confidence": 0.4, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS7152", "Project Name": "252 MW Wind Energy Project by Green Infra Wind Energy Limited", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": null, "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Sembcorp Green Infra Private Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 3855788, "Total Credits Retired": 1390014, "issued_by_vintage": { "2019": 196409, "2020": 599872, "2021": 652971, "2022": 613425, "2023": 650436, "2024": 555682, "2025": 586993 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS1776", "Project Name": "Wind Power Project by Green Infra Wind Power Generation Limited", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Verification approval requested", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Green Infra Wind Power Generation Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 631797, "Total Credits Retired": 113156, "issued_by_vintage": { "2016": 10638, "2017": 79951, "2018": 85651, "2019": 87800, "2020": 75495, "2021": 76857, "2022": 72186, "2023": 80580, "2024": 62639 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "unclear", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Country", "value_a": "India", "value_b": "India" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Wind", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Wind" } ], "differences": [ "GS developer: 'Sembcorp Green Infra Private Limited' vs VCS developer: 'Green Infra Wind Power Generation Limited'", "GS name specifies 252 MW capacity; VCS name does not", "Different methodologies: GS lists none; VCS uses ACM0002" ], "reason": "Both records share country (India), scope / type (Renewable Energy / Wind).", "reason_from_model": false, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "GS7625~VCS1767", "a": "GS7625", "b": "VCS1767", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.5873, "name_sim": 0.7951, "overlap_vintages": [ 2021, 2022 ], "overlap_volume": 195676, "verdict": "unclear", "confidence": 0.6, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS7625", "Project Name": "200 MW Solar PV Plant by Mahindra Susten in Rajasthan", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Solar - Centralized", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Mahindra Susten Private Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 529270, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2021": 70375, "2022": 458895 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS1767", "Project Name": "Bundled Solar Power Project by Mahindra Susten Private Limited", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Solar - Centralized", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Multiple Project Proponents", "Total Credits Issued": 2002439, "Total Credits Retired": 1446013, "issued_by_vintage": { "2016": 15339, "2017": 259979, "2018": 407574, "2019": 399456, "2020": 413215, "2021": 381575, "2022": 125301 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "unclear", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Mahindra Susten Private Limited", "value_b": "Multiple Project Proponents" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Solar - Centralized", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Solar - Centralized" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "value_b": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources" } ], "differences": [ "GS7625 is a single 200 MW plant; VCS1767 is a bundled project", "GS7625 developer is Mahindra Susten; VCS1767 lists Multiple Project Proponents", "Registry: GOLD vs VCS" ], "reason": "Both records share developer (Mahindra Susten Private Limited), country / state / site (India / None / None), scope / type (Renewable Energy / Solar - Centralized), methodology (ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources).", "reason_from_model": false, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "GS5377~VCS1753", "a": "GS5377", "b": "VCS1753", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.5585, "name_sim": 0.7428, "overlap_vintages": [ 2018, 2019, 2021, 2022 ], "overlap_volume": 73971, "verdict": "unclear", "confidence": 0.5, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS5377", "Project Name": "15 MW Solar Photovoltaic Power Project at Gujarat", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Solar - Centralized", "Methodology / Protocol": null, "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "EKI Energy Services Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 126765, "Total Credits Retired": 0, "issued_by_vintage": { "2015": 8438, "2016": 17645, "2018": 21456, "2019": 22568, "2021": 7950, "2022": 21997, "2023": 20728, "2024": 5983 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS1753", "Project Name": "Bundled Solar Photovoltaic Project by ACME", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Solar - Centralized", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources; AMS-I.D. Grid connected renewable electricity generation", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Multiple Project Proponents", "Total Credits Issued": 8526931, "Total Credits Retired": 5252692, "issued_by_vintage": { "2017": 343762, "2018": 1364177, "2019": 1876317, "2020": 2106282, "2021": 2083363, "2022": 753030 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "unclear", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Renewable Energy / Solar - Centralized", "value_b": "Renewable Energy / Solar - Centralized" }, { "field": "Country", "value_a": "India", "value_b": "India" } ], "differences": [ "GS5377 is a single 15 MW project; VCS1753 is a bundled project with multiple proponents", "GS5377 developer is EKI Energy Services / ACME Solar Technologies; VCS1753 developer is Multiple Project Proponents", "GS5377 site is Village-Wadgam, Anand District; VCS1753 site not specified" ], "reason": "Both records share scope / type (Renewable Energy / Solar - Centralized), country (India).", "reason_from_model": false, "dropped_facts": 1, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "GS7469~VCS1211", "a": "GS7469", "b": "VCS1211", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "India", "screen_score": 0.5569, "name_sim": 0.6671, "overlap_vintages": [ 2019, 2020, 2021, 2022 ], "overlap_volume": 171828, "verdict": "unclear", "confidence": 0.55, "transfer_mentioned": false, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS7469", "Project Name": "50.6 MW Wind Energy Project by Powerica Limited", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "Wind", "Methodology / Protocol": null, "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Powerica Limited", "Total Credits Issued": 745400, "Total Credits Retired": 278141, "issued_by_vintage": { "2019": 92074, "2020": 131169, "2021": 136167, "2022": 127598, "2023": 134641, "2024": 123751 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS1211", "Project Name": "Green Energy Project at Gujarat by Powerica Limited", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Registered", "Scope": "Renewable Energy", "Type": "RE Bundled", "Methodology / Protocol": "ACM0002 Grid-connected electricity generation from renewable sources", "Country": "India", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "POWERICA LIMITED (PP)", "Total Credits Issued": 584281, "Total Credits Retired": 511895, "issued_by_vintage": { "2013": 108555, "2014": 56412, "2015": 62580, "2016": 59817, "2017": 62765, "2018": 62324, "2019": 62324, "2020": 49967, "2021": 53792, "2022": 5745 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "unclear", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Developer", "value_a": "Powerica Limited", "value_b": "POWERICA LIMITED (PP)" }, { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "India / None / None", "value_b": "India / None / None" } ], "differences": [ "GS7469 is wind-only (50.6 MW); VCS1211 is RE Bundled", "GS7469 scope: Renewable Energy / Wind; VCS1211 scope: Renewable Energy / RE Bundled", "Registry: GOLD vs VCS", "VCS1211 specifies Gujarat; GS7469 does not specify state" ], "reason": "Both records share developer (Powerica Limited), country / state / site (India / None / None).", "reason_from_model": false, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "GS2500~VCS2716", "a": "GS2500", "b": "VCS2716", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "Honduras", "screen_score": 0.555, "name_sim": 0.7363, "overlap_vintages": [ 2017 ], "overlap_volume": 22397, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": true, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS2500", "Project Name": "Improved Cookstoves Project Activity in Honduras Vida Mejor con Ecofogones de Alto Rendimiento CPA No 001", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-II.G. Energy efficiency measures in thermal applications of non-renewable biomass", "Country": "Honduras", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Envirofit International Ltd.", "Total Credits Issued": 136154, "Total Credits Retired": 72257, "issued_by_vintage": { "2015": 19775, "2016": 17640, "2017": 22397, "2018": 34668, "2019": 28831, "2020": 12843 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS2716", "Project Name": "Improved Cookstoves Program in Honduras \"Vida Mejor con Ecofogones de Alto Rendimiento\" - CER Conversion", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Units transferred from approved GHG program", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-II.G. Energy efficiency measures in thermal applications of non-renewable biomass", "Country": "Honduras", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Credits transferred from approved GHG program", "Total Credits Issued": 74491, "Total Credits Retired": 74491, "issued_by_vintage": { "2017": 74491 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "Honduras / None / None", "value_b": "Honduras / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Household & Community / Cookstoves", "value_b": "Household & Community / Cookstoves" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "AMS-II.G. Energy efficiency measures in thermal applications of non-renewable or", "value_b": "AMS-II.G. Energy efficiency measures in thermal applications of non-renewable" }, { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Improved Cookstoves Project Activity in Honduras Vida Mejor con Ecofogones de", "value_b": "Improved Cookstoves Program in Honduras \"Vida Mejor con Ecofogones de" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS2500 vs VCS VCS2716", "Developer: Envirofit International Ltd. vs Credits transferred from approved GHG program", "Status: Gold Standard Certified Project vs Units Transferred from Approved GHG Program", "Credits issued by vintage: 2015:19775, 2016:17640, 2017:22397, 2018:34668, 2019:28831, 2020:12843 vs 2017:74491" ], "reason": "Both listings describe a project in Honduras involving Household & Community Cookstoves using the AMS-II.G. methodology.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "GS6111~VCS2716", "a": "GS6111", "b": "VCS2716", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "Honduras", "screen_score": 0.5488, "name_sim": 0.7251, "overlap_vintages": [ 2017 ], "overlap_volume": 17785, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": true, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS6111", "Project Name": "Improved Cookstoves Project Activity in Honduras \"Vida Mejor con Ecofogones de Alto Rendimiento\" – CPA No 004", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-II.G. Energy efficiency measures in thermal applications of non-renewable biomass", "Country": "Honduras", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Envirofit International Ltd.", "Total Credits Issued": 98925, "Total Credits Retired": 70655, "issued_by_vintage": { "2017": 17785, "2018": 36254, "2019": 31596, "2020": 13290 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS2716", "Project Name": "Improved Cookstoves Program in Honduras \"Vida Mejor con Ecofogones de Alto Rendimiento\" - CER Conversion", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Units transferred from approved GHG program", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-II.G. Energy efficiency measures in thermal applications of non-renewable biomass", "Country": "Honduras", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Credits transferred from approved GHG program", "Total Credits Issued": 74491, "Total Credits Retired": 74491, "issued_by_vintage": { "2017": 74491 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "Honduras / None / None", "value_b": "Honduras / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Household & Community / Cookstoves", "value_b": "Household & Community / Cookstoves" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "AMS-II.G. Energy efficiency measures in thermal applications of non-renewableAll", "value_b": "AMS-II.G. Energy efficiency measures in thermal applications of non-renewableAll" }, { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Improved Cookstoves Project Activity in Honduras \"Vida Mejor con Ecofogones deTO", "value_b": "Improved Cookstoves Program in Honduras \"Vida Mejor con Ecofogones deTO" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS6111 vs VCS VCS2716", "Developer: Envirofit International Ltd. vs Credits transferred from approved GHG program", "Status: Gold Standard Certified Project vs Units Transferred from Approved GHG Program", "Credits issued by vintage: 2017:17785, 2018:36254, 2019:31596, 2020:13290 vs 2017:74491" ], "reason": "Both listings describe a project in Honduras involving Household & Community Cookstoves using the AMS-II.G. methodology.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "GS6108~VCS2716", "a": "GS6108", "b": "VCS2716", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "Honduras", "screen_score": 0.5488, "name_sim": 0.7251, "overlap_vintages": [ 2017 ], "overlap_volume": 17215, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": true, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS6108", "Project Name": "Improved Cookstoves Project Activity in Honduras Vida Mejor con Ecofogones de Alto Rendimiento CPA No 002", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "Not provided", "Country": "Honduras", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Envirofit International Ltd.", "Total Credits Issued": 98290, "Total Credits Retired": 97310, "issued_by_vintage": { "2017": 17215, "2018": 35967, "2019": 31818, "2020": 13290 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS2716", "Project Name": "Improved Cookstoves Program in Honduras \"Vida Mejor con Ecofogones de Alto Rendimiento\" - CER Conversion", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Units transferred from approved GHG program", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-II.G. Energy efficiency measures in thermal applications of non-renewable biomass", "Country": "Honduras", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Credits transferred from approved GHG program", "Total Credits Issued": 74491, "Total Credits Retired": 74491, "issued_by_vintage": { "2017": 74491 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "Honduras / None / None", "value_b": "Honduras / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Household & Community / Cookstoves", "value_b": "Household & Community / Cookstoves" }, { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Improved Cookstoves Project Activity in Honduras Vida Mejor con Ecofogones deto", "value_b": "Improved Cookstoves Program in Honduras \"Vida Mejor con Ecofogones de Alto Rendi" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS6108 vs VCS VCS2716", "Developer: Envirofit International Ltd. vs Credits transferred from approved GHG program", "Status: Gold Standard Certified Project vs Units Transferred from Approved GHG Program", "Credits issued by vintage: 2017:17215, 2018:35967, 2019:31818, 2020:13290 vs 2017:74491" ], "reason": "Both listings describe a project in Honduras involving Household & Community Cookstoves with the name Vida Mejor con Ecofogones de Alto Rendimiento.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "GS6109~VCS2716", "a": "GS6109", "b": "VCS2716", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "Honduras", "screen_score": 0.548, "name_sim": 0.7236, "overlap_vintages": [ 2017 ], "overlap_volume": 17330, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": true, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS6109", "Project Name": "Improved Cookstoves Project Activity in Honduras \"Vida Mejor con Ecofogones de Alto Rendimiento\" – CPA No 003", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-II.G. Energy efficiency measures in thermal applications of non-renewable biomass", "Country": "Honduras", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Envirofit International Ltd.", "Total Credits Issued": 99748, "Total Credits Retired": 98755, "issued_by_vintage": { "2017": 17330, "2018": 36618, "2019": 32398, "2020": 13402 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS2716", "Project Name": "Improved Cookstoves Program in Honduras \"Vida Mejor con Ecofogones de Alto Rendimiento\" - CER Conversion", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Units transferred from approved GHG program", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-II.G. Energy efficiency measures in thermal applications of non-renewable biomass", "Country": "Honduras", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Credits transferred from approved GHG program", "Total Credits Issued": 74491, "Total Credits Retired": 74491, "issued_by_vintage": { "2017": 74491 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "Honduras / None / None", "value_b": "Honduras / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Household & Community / Cookstoves", "value_b": "Household & Community / Cookstoves" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "AMS-II.G. Energy efficiency measures in thermal applications of non-renewableAll", "value_b": "AMS-II.G. Energy efficiency measures in thermal applications of non-renewableAll" }, { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Improved Cookstoves Project Activity in Honduras \"Vida Mejor con Ecofogones deTO", "value_b": "Improved Cookstoves Program in Honduras \"Vida Mejor con Ecofogones deTO" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS6109 vs VCS VCS2716", "Developer: Envirofit International Ltd. vs Credits transferred from approved GHG program", "Status: Gold Standard Certified Project vs Units Transferred from Approved GHG Program", "Credits issued by vintage: 2017:17330, 2018:36618, 2019:32398, 2020:13402 vs 2017:74491" ], "reason": "Both listings describe a project in Honduras involving Household & Community Cookstoves using the AMS-II.G. methodology.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "GS6112~VCS2716", "a": "GS6112", "b": "VCS2716", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "Honduras", "screen_score": 0.548, "name_sim": 0.7236, "overlap_vintages": [ 2017 ], "overlap_volume": 16189, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": true, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS6112", "Project Name": "Improved Cookstoves Project Activity in Honduras \"Vida Mejor con Ecofogones de Alto Rendimiento\" – CPA No 005", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-II.G. Energy efficiency measures in thermal applications of non-renewable biomass", "Country": "Honduras", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Envirofit International Ltd.", "Total Credits Issued": 93307, "Total Credits Retired": 58523, "issued_by_vintage": { "2017": 16189, "2018": 34290, "2019": 30320, "2020": 12508 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS2716", "Project Name": "Improved Cookstoves Program in Honduras \"Vida Mejor con Ecofogones de Alto Rendimiento\" - CER Conversion", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Units transferred from approved GHG program", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-II.G. Energy efficiency measures in thermal applications of non-renewable biomass", "Country": "Honduras", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Credits transferred from approved GHG program", "Total Credits Issued": 74491, "Total Credits Retired": 74491, "issued_by_vintage": { "2017": 74491 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "Honduras / None / None", "value_b": "Honduras / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Household & Community / Cookstoves", "value_b": "Household & Community / Cookstoves" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "AMS-II.G. Energy efficiency measures in thermal applications of non-renewableAll", "value_b": "AMS-II.G. Energy efficiency measures in thermal applications of non-renewableAll" }, { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Improved Cookstoves Project Activity in Honduras \"Vida Mejor con Ecofogones deTO", "value_b": "Improved Cookstoves Program in Honduras \"Vida Mejor con Ecofogones deTO" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS6112 vs VCS VCS2716", "Developer: Envirofit International Ltd. vs Credits transferred from approved GHG program", "Status: Gold Standard Certified Project vs Units Transferred from Approved GHG Program", "Credits issued by vintage: 2017:16189, 2018:34290, 2019:30320, 2020:12508 vs 2017:74491" ], "reason": "Both listings describe a project in Honduras involving Household & Community Cookstoves using the AMS-II.G. methodology.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "GS6113~VCS2716", "a": "GS6113", "b": "VCS2716", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "Honduras", "screen_score": 0.548, "name_sim": 0.7236, "overlap_vintages": [ 2017 ], "overlap_volume": 16189, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": true, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS6113", "Project Name": "Improved Cookstoves Project Activity in Honduras \"Vida Mejor con Ecofogones de Alto Rendimiento\" – CPA No 006", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-II.G. Energy efficiency measures in thermal applications of non-renewable biomass", "Country": "Honduras", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Envirofit International Ltd.", "Total Credits Issued": 93307, "Total Credits Retired": 91552, "issued_by_vintage": { "2017": 16189, "2018": 34290, "2019": 30320, "2020": 12508 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS2716", "Project Name": "Improved Cookstoves Program in Honduras \"Vida Mejor con Ecofogones de Alto Rendimiento\" - CER Conversion", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Units transferred from approved GHG program", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-II.G. Energy efficiency measures in thermal applications of non-renewable biomass", "Country": "Honduras", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Credits transferred from approved GHG program", "Total Credits Issued": 74491, "Total Credits Retired": 74491, "issued_by_vintage": { "2017": 74491 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "Honduras / None / None", "value_b": "Honduras / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Household & Community / Cookstoves", "value_b": "Household & Community / Cookstoves" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "AMS-II.G. Energy efficiency measures in thermal applications of non-renewableAll", "value_b": "AMS-II.G. Energy efficiency measures in thermal applications of non-renewableAll" }, { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Improved Cookstoves Project Activity in Honduras \"Vida Mejor con Ecofogones deTO", "value_b": "Improved Cookstoves Program in Honduras \"Vida Mejor con Ecofogones deTO" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS6113 vs VCS VCS2716", "Developer: Envirofit International Ltd. vs Credits transferred from approved GHG program", "Status: Gold Standard Certified Project vs Units Transferred from Approved GHG Program", "Credits issued by vintage: 2017:16189, 2018:34290, 2019:30320, 2020:12508 vs 2017:74491" ], "reason": "Both listings describe a project in Honduras involving Household & Community Cookstoves using the AMS-II.G. methodology.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "GS6114~VCS2716", "a": "GS6114", "b": "VCS2716", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "Honduras", "screen_score": 0.548, "name_sim": 0.7236, "overlap_vintages": [ 2017 ], "overlap_volume": 11735, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": true, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS6114", "Project Name": "Improved Cookstoves Project Activity in Honduras \"Vida Mejor con Ecofogones de Alto Rendimiento\" – CPA No 007", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-II.G. Energy efficiency measures in thermal applications of non-renewable biomass", "Country": "Honduras", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Envirofit International Ltd.", "Total Credits Issued": 67761, "Total Credits Retired": 21046, "issued_by_vintage": { "2017": 11735, "2018": 24950, "2019": 22030, "2020": 9046 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS2716", "Project Name": "Improved Cookstoves Program in Honduras \"Vida Mejor con Ecofogones de Alto Rendimiento\" - CER Conversion", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Units transferred from approved GHG program", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-II.G. Energy efficiency measures in thermal applications of non-renewable biomass", "Country": "Honduras", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Credits transferred from approved GHG program", "Total Credits Issued": 74491, "Total Credits Retired": 74491, "issued_by_vintage": { "2017": 74491 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "Honduras / None / None", "value_b": "Honduras / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Household & Community / Cookstoves", "value_b": "Household & Community / Cookstoves" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "AMS-II.G. Energy efficiency measures in thermal applications of non-renewableAll", "value_b": "AMS-II.G. Energy efficiency measures in thermal applications of non-renewableAll" }, { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Improved Cookstoves Project Activity in Honduras \"Vida Mejor con Ecofogones deTO", "value_b": "Improved Cookstoves Program in Honduras \"Vida Mejor con Ecofogones deTO" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS6114 vs VCS VCS2716", "Developer: Envirofit International Ltd. vs Credits transferred from approved GHG program", "Status: Gold Standard Certified Project vs Units Transferred from Approved GHG Program", "Credits issued by vintage: 2017:11735, 2018:24950, 2019:22030, 2020:9046 vs 2017:74491" ], "reason": "Both listings describe a project in Honduras involving Household & Community Cookstoves using the AMS-II.G. methodology.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "GS6115~VCS2716", "a": "GS6115", "b": "VCS2716", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "Honduras", "screen_score": 0.548, "name_sim": 0.7236, "overlap_vintages": [ 2017 ], "overlap_volume": 10170, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": true, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS6115", "Project Name": "Improved Cookstoves Project Activity in Honduras \"Vida Mejor con Ecofogones de Alto Rendimiento\" – CPA No 008", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-II.G. Energy efficiency measures in thermal applications of non-renewable biomass", "Country": "Honduras", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Envirofit International Ltd.", "Total Credits Issued": 64668, "Total Credits Retired": 53571, "issued_by_vintage": { "2017": 10170, "2018": 23422, "2019": 22030, "2020": 9046 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS2716", "Project Name": "Improved Cookstoves Program in Honduras \"Vida Mejor con Ecofogones de Alto Rendimiento\" - CER Conversion", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Units transferred from approved GHG program", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-II.G. Energy efficiency measures in thermal applications of non-renewable biomass", "Country": "Honduras", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Credits transferred from approved GHG program", "Total Credits Issued": 74491, "Total Credits Retired": 74491, "issued_by_vintage": { "2017": 74491 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "Honduras / None / None", "value_b": "Honduras / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Household & Community / Cookstoves", "value_b": "Household & Community / Cookstoves" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "AMS-II.G. Energy efficiency measures in thermal applications of non-renewableAll", "value_b": "AMS-II.G. Energy efficiency measures in thermal applications of non-renewableAll" }, { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Improved Cookstoves Project Activity in Honduras \"Vida Mejor con Ecofogones deTO", "value_b": "Improved Cookstoves Program in Honduras \"Vida Mejor con Ecofogones deTO" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS6115 vs VCS VCS2716", "Developer: Envirofit International Ltd. vs Credits transferred from approved GHG program", "Status: Gold Standard Certified Project vs Units Transferred from Approved GHG Program", "Credits issued by vintage: 2017:10170, 2018:23422, 2019:22030, 2020:9046 vs 2017:74491" ], "reason": "Both listings describe a project in Honduras involving Household & Community Cookstoves using the AMS-II.G. methodology.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true }, { "id": "GS6116~VCS2716", "a": "GS6116", "b": "VCS2716", "registry_a": "GOLD", "registry_b": "VCS", "country": "Honduras", "screen_score": 0.548, "name_sim": 0.7236, "overlap_vintages": [ 2017 ], "overlap_volume": 7381, "verdict": "yes", "confidence": 1, "transfer_mentioned": true, "listing_a": { "Project ID": "GS6116", "Project Name": "Improved Cookstoves Project Activity in Honduras \"Vida Mejor con Ecofogones de Alto Rendimiento\" – CPA No 009", "Voluntary Registry": "GOLD", "Voluntary Status": "Gold Standard Certified Project", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-II.G. Energy efficiency measures in thermal applications of non-renewable biomass", "Country": "Honduras", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Envirofit International Ltd.", "Total Credits Issued": 58416, "Total Credits Retired": 39213, "issued_by_vintage": { "2017": 7381, "2018": 20429, "2019": 21672, "2020": 8934 }, "notes": "" }, "listing_b": { "Project ID": "VCS2716", "Project Name": "Improved Cookstoves Program in Honduras \"Vida Mejor con Ecofogones de Alto Rendimiento\" - CER Conversion", "Voluntary Registry": "VCS", "Voluntary Status": "Units transferred from approved GHG program", "Scope": "Household & Community", "Type": "Cookstoves", "Methodology / Protocol": "AMS-II.G. Energy efficiency measures in thermal applications of non-renewable biomass", "Country": "Honduras", "State": null, "Project Site Location": null, "Project Developer": "Credits transferred from approved GHG program", "Total Credits Issued": 74491, "Total Credits Retired": 74491, "issued_by_vintage": { "2017": 74491 }, "notes": "" }, "second_pass": "yes", "shared_facts": [ { "field": "Country / State / Site", "value_a": "Honduras / None / None", "value_b": "Honduras / None / None" }, { "field": "Scope / Type", "value_a": "Household & Community / Cookstoves", "value_b": "Household & Community / Cookstoves" }, { "field": "Methodology", "value_a": "AMS-II.G. Energy efficiency measures in thermal applications of non-renewableAll", "value_b": "AMS-II.G. Energy efficiency measures in thermal applications of non-renewableAll" }, { "field": "Name", "value_a": "Improved Cookstoves Project Activity in Honduras \"Vida Mejor con Ecofogones deTO", "value_b": "Improved Cookstoves Program in Honduras \"Vida Mejor con Ecofogones deTO" } ], "differences": [ "Registry / ID: GOLD GS6116 vs VCS VCS2716", "Developer: Envirofit International Ltd. vs Credits transferred from approved GHG program", "Status: Gold Standard Certified Project vs Units Transferred from Approved GHG Program", "Credits issued by vintage: 2017:7381, 2018:20429, 2019:21672, 2020:8934 vs 2017:74491" ], "reason": "Both listings describe a project in Honduras involving Household & Community Cookstoves using the AMS-II.G. methodology.", "reason_from_model": true, "dropped_facts": 0, "name_conflict": true } ] }